Episode 192 · September 14, 2024
Lake Pirates
Coalson wonders whether 'crazy as a loon' is connected to 'lunatic' and 'looney'. The hosts argue over bird vs. moon, then find the words have separate roots, though the bird phrase influenced 'loony'.
“I'm going to write a letter to the dictionary editor. It had nothing to do with the Pittsburgh Pirates, however.” (18:39)
Questions
Where does 'crazy as a loon' come from, and is 'loony' related to 'lunatic'? (02:03)
Our guess
Loony comes from the bird, separate from lunatic (Joey: lunatic is much older, Greek or Roman, plus Shakespeare)
Loony comes from the bird, separate from lunatic (Joey: lunatic is much older, Greek or Roman, plus Shakespeare)
Reveal the answer
The answer
Loon the bird comes from a Scandinavian word and appeared in English in the 1600s; 'loon' meaning a fool is from Middle English 'loun'. 'Lunatic' is from Latin luna (moon), and 'loony' derives from lunatic, though Merriam-Webster says 'crazy as a loon' influenced it.
Loon the bird comes from a Scandinavian word and appeared in English in the 1600s; 'loon' meaning a fool is from Middle English 'loun'. 'Lunatic' is from Latin luna (moon), and 'loony' derives from lunatic, though Merriam-Webster says 'crazy as a loon' influenced it.
Verdict partly
Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:00] I've got that game for my PC called Into the Breach. [00:05] Is it like a World War II game? [00:08] No, it's like a futuristic hellscape. [00:14] Well, yeah. [00:15] In 2024? [00:17] No, you play as like these different kind of mechs. [00:25] But it's not like it's like a strategy kind of game. [00:30] It's not like first-person shooter or anything. [00:32] Turn-based. [00:33] Yeah, it's like a turn-based strategy thing. [00:36] But you play as these mechs, and you're [00:38] trying to keep these other future mechs to like, [00:41] you've got to save the people. [00:42] Got to save the people with the mechs. [00:45] Yep. [00:46] I actually have a similar game. [00:49] It's called Into the Brooch, where I helped my mom put [00:51] her little brooch on her neck. [00:54] Turn-based play? [00:56] Turn-based strategy. [01:03] I'll look for it on Steam here coming up, I think. [01:06] Yeah. [01:06] Sounds fascinating. [01:09] Yeah, I'm not going to pay full price, but I'm interested. [01:15] I'll watch it on Twitch, sure. [01:32] We doing under Googles? [01:33] That was the play of Super Excited. [01:36] You told us we had to, sir. [01:39] You said we signed up for it. [01:43] In the end, it's going to be better and more true [01:45] than Google can give you. [01:49] All right, team. [01:50] I think it's, I checked it, it was dame time, [01:56] then it was Halliburton's time. [01:58] Now it's time for the under Googles. [02:03] Coalson, how can we help you this week? [02:06] Well, I was thinking about this one, Crazy as a Loon. [02:12] And I kind of went down a little spiral in my head, [02:15] because then I was like, is Looney connected to Lunatic [02:21] or Crazy as a Loon? [02:23] And then I just was like, my own mind blew. [02:27] And I was like, I got to take it to my people's figure out [02:30] where we get Crazy as a Loon, as a phrase. [02:33] Mm, mm. [02:36] Yeah. [02:37] Interesting. [02:38] Well, you've already been down this rabbit hole. [02:39] What did you decide? [02:41] Actually, I didn't. [02:42] I was wondering, actually, if Loon [02:45] comes from the same root as Lunatic. [02:47] I know they're spelled differently. [02:50] And I think Looney is spelled like the bird Loon. [02:53] So I think they're probably separate. [02:57] And I think Looney comes from Crazy as a Loon. [03:02] But it's just so true. [03:03] And where does Looney Tunes fit in? [03:04] Yeah, I think it's from Looney, which is from Crazy as a Loon. [03:08] But again, that always reminisces of a lunatic. [03:12] And like I said, I got myself in a spin. [03:17] Got yourself in a state. [03:18] Yeah, there are different roots, probably. [03:21] I mean, I assume, especially since they're spelled [03:23] differently. [03:24] But I wonder if they're related, whether some sort of, [03:30] whether we named the bird Loon because we [03:33] thought it was a lunatic. [03:35] You know, like, I don't know. [03:37] I don't know. [03:37] What's the, what's the, is the bird [03:41] just the Loon, it's just the L-O-O-N? [03:44] L-O-O-N, yeah. [03:47] And it's like a water bird, right? [03:51] It's a waterfowl. [03:53] Yeah, waterfowl. [03:54] And it's black and white. [03:56] And I believe that it's kind of a night bird, doesn't it? [03:59] I feel like it's connected to the moon. [04:01] Or maybe that's just the Loon thing. [04:04] Moon and Loon. [04:05] I think there's more than one kind of Loon, I think. [04:09] Yeah, I feel like Loon's cry at night. [04:12] And I feel like maybe they make a crazy sound. [04:15] They do have a distinct call. [04:18] Yeah, it's like, I don't want to try to make it now [04:22] because I'm not a birdologist. [04:24] Not a lunatic. [04:28] That's what fans of Loon's are called. [04:31] Sure, but L-O-O-N. [04:34] Yeah, exactly. [04:36] But does it kind of like, ooh. [04:40] Is that a thing? [04:41] Is it kind of like a haunting cry out on the water? [04:46] Yeah, a little bit. [04:47] A little bit. [04:49] But why is that crazy? [04:54] Well, people who are truly hysterical [05:00] may scream or cry out or some such. [05:04] And so the ravings of a lunatic may indeed [05:10] sound a little bit like a Loon's call. [05:13] At least that's where my mind first went, [05:15] because it's a very strange, high-pitched sort of whale. [05:19] OK, a high-pitched whale. [05:21] Yeah, that makes sense, because birds [05:22] make lots of weird noises. [05:24] There's lots of animals that make weird noises, [05:26] and we don't necessarily call them crazy. [05:28] You know? [05:30] Well, how do whales get into this conversation? [05:34] Whales? [05:35] I'm just messing with you. [05:39] Are we sure? [05:40] I guess, how confident are we that the bird, Loon, [05:44] and like the word lunatic are related at all? [05:49] No, I don't think it's 0%. [05:50] 0%. [05:51] I've zeroed. [05:53] That's what made me ask this question, [05:56] but I don't think they're related at all. [05:58] OK. [05:58] But they might be. [06:01] But they're spelled differently. [06:02] So there's probably a different origin [06:06] from the Loon and the lunatic. [06:08] We have established also that English can be stupid, and. [06:12] Right. [06:13] You know. [06:15] Yeah, I mean, it could be like, that bird sounds like a lunatic, [06:18] and then we just spelled it different. [06:21] You know? [06:23] That's quite possible. [06:25] You think it might be short for doubloon? [06:31] Maybe. [06:33] What's your? [06:34] Pirates, right? [06:37] So your error would be like the 1700s on the water? [06:46] For the pirates? [06:47] Yeah. [06:48] I was actually thinking the Pittsburgh Pirates. [06:52] OK. [06:53] Yeah, so late 1800s. [06:54] I think Loon's are largely lake birds. [06:57] Yeah, I think they're lake birds as well. [06:59] Well, they're lake pirates. [07:01] Lake pirates. [07:02] Old lake pirates. [07:03] From the smaller stakes stuff. [07:05] Yeah. [07:06] Pittsburgh lake pirates. [07:08] Yeah, yeah, sure. [07:11] So a lot of steel. [07:12] Yeah, that's how we know them. [07:15] So you're saying that the Loon is directly connected [07:18] to the baseball team. [07:22] I mean, I can't envision another scenario. [07:31] But but do you think so? [07:34] I guess the reason it kind of screwed with me [07:37] is because when I always heard the term loony, [07:38] like loony tunes or whatever, I just assumed [07:41] that that was loony as in lunatic. [07:44] But then when I thought of the phrase crazy as a loon, [07:47] I went, oh, no, it's actually loony as in the bird loon. [07:53] And then just my world kind of fell apart. [07:56] I guess this is what I'm talking about. [07:58] I need help with this. [08:00] I would think maybe my uneducated guess [08:05] would be that the loony, like loony tunes [08:10] does come from lunatic. [08:12] But it's a cartoon, you know, it's a cartoon. [08:17] And they take liberties with language all the time. [08:21] Right, but like if you but if you say I'm with you, [08:24] I see we're saying it looks the same as tune, right? [08:27] Loon and tune. [08:28] You get that you want to spell it the same way. [08:30] But like, you wouldn't say that did is loony [08:34] and spell it L-U-N-Y, right? [08:37] You would spell it loony as in loony tunes. [08:40] So do you think the phrase loony tunes [08:42] was created to match tunes even though it [08:47] was coming off lunatic and has nothing to do with the bird? [08:50] Is that what you're suggesting, Joey? [08:53] Yes. [08:54] OK, all right. [08:55] Well, that solves that. [08:57] I'm now convinced that loony comes from crazy as a loon, [09:03] the bird, and I'm just saying. [09:07] That loony does and lunatic both? [09:09] No, no, no, just loony. [09:11] Yeah, OK. [09:12] And that loony is not connected to lunatic, [09:15] even though that's how we associate it. [09:19] That's what I'm going with. [09:21] OK, so. [09:22] And that the crazy as a loon came along in the when [09:28] when did loons come along? [09:31] Probably around 100 million years ago or so. [09:38] When did language come about? [09:43] When were people near lakes? [09:45] I'm going to go with, oh, OK. [09:49] I'm going to say that this is a native people's word [09:56] for this bird, like Algonquin or something like that. [10:02] I'm going to go with that and. [10:05] Like the bird loon. [10:06] The bird loon, right. [10:07] And it was translated incorrectly by white people. [10:14] And then that there was some superstitious era, [10:18] superstition, some sort of, there was witches [10:20] and we were drowning them and stuff. [10:22] And I'm going, I don't know. [10:23] When was when was the crucible filmed? [10:28] When was it filmed or what period does it cover? [10:31] You heard the man would have been filmed in the 70s. [10:37] I don't know when to go the 1500s. [10:39] I don't know. [10:40] Yeah, I mean, I'm going to go with Shakespeare. [10:42] I mean, this seems like a metaphorical thing here. [10:48] So for loon and crazy as a loon, loonie. [10:53] I'm to go with, you know, it does [10:55] have to do with the bird's whale or call Shakespeare. [10:58] It's a scary cry. [11:01] And then in a weird twist, I must say that lunatic [11:04] came much later, but out of it, like during the asylum era [11:10] when we were just making up words for crazies [11:13] and like turn of the century America. [11:16] OK, I'm going to say that lunatic is a root word [11:20] and, you know, the romance like it's from Roman times. [11:25] It's from the right. [11:26] The romance is plot. [11:27] It's the Romans created the word lunatic is what I'm thinking. [11:31] OK. [11:32] One question I have is what is a Native American word. [11:35] That's what I'm going with. [11:37] What's the what's the territory? [11:40] Where do loons live? [11:41] I think they live in the Northeast of. [11:47] Well, they definitely live in the Northwest. [11:48] I can tell you that as well. [11:50] OK, they live in the North. [11:52] I think they live in one that's cold lakes. [11:55] OK, but like North America, though, right? [11:57] Yeah, I guess. [11:58] Yeah, maybe Canada. [11:59] I think they're big in Canada. [12:01] Well, well, I guess what I'm getting at is. [12:04] Yeah, not a lot of cross language play between North America [12:07] and Shakespeare. [12:10] Yeah, I mean, that's if they're not in Shakespeare's. [12:13] Well, are they I mean, there are [12:15] in the British Empire. [12:19] I have no information to suggest that. [12:22] I mean, I mean, clearly the Americas were part of the British Empire, [12:26] but that would be after Shakespeare. [12:28] Correct. [12:29] And I feel like they weren't talking about North American birds. [12:31] Yeah. [12:32] Also, yeah, not a lot of cross play with Native American languages [12:36] in the 1400s, either or whatever you went with. [12:38] Well, right. We don't have to be right. [12:39] We both don't have to write Harper. [12:41] I'm saying I'm saying we're both wrong. [12:45] Shakespeare, I'm saying Native Americans doesn't mean that we're both right. [12:48] Well, right. [12:48] But we didn't have a lot of cross play with Native Americans in 1400 either. [12:52] That's not when we were here. [12:54] Yeah, I'm going later. [12:58] I'm going. I'm going. [12:59] We came up with the white people misunderstood [13:02] and misinterpreted Native Americans in the late 1800s, early 1800s. [13:08] Yeah. Yeah. Early 1800s in Canada. [13:16] All right. [13:17] I'm going to say maybe I'm going to say unconnected from somehow the loon. [13:20] I'll go with lunatic is older that it's Greek or something. [13:24] And so I'll plenty the elder plus Shakespeare. [13:27] I'll go for a two for. [13:28] I like that. I like that. [13:30] Joey's going with horse racing. [13:34] I was born with, you know, seafaring seafaring. [13:38] OK, not like ships. No, that's good. [13:40] I like that. [13:40] Falconry was on the nose. [13:42] Lake ships are on the beak, as the case may be. [13:45] All the lake ships. [13:47] All right. [13:48] Well, here's what I'm finding is that this is not [13:52] we are not the first people that had this question. [13:54] Oh, that's interesting. [13:57] So Lune L.O.O.N. [14:01] First. Appeared in English during the early 1600s. [14:06] Nailed it and is and believed to be derived [14:10] from the Scandinavian term for the loon lomer. [14:14] So they do have loons over there. [14:16] Apparently. OK. [14:18] A loon that means a crazy foolish or silly person [14:21] came from the Middle English loun. [14:24] Originally, this loon, which entered English in the 1400s, [14:29] meant a lout idler or rogue. [14:32] Like I said, you know, negative connotation. [14:35] And it was extended to mean a crazy person or simpleton. [14:38] Lunatic derived from the Latin luna moon. [14:44] Which was mentioned. [14:46] Insured English during the early 1300s, because many people believe [14:51] insanity was caused by the phases of the moon. [14:56] Like werewolves, werewolves and vampires. Yeah. [15:02] Looney, an adjective form of lunatic emerged during the late 1800s. [15:07] For like Looney Tunes. [15:09] But is that and that's connected to both or. [15:12] That's connected to lunatic. [15:16] It's just another version of that. [15:19] It says it's an action, action to verb of lunatic. [15:24] So are they connected or not? [15:26] They're completely separate things. [15:29] The bird and the lunatic, I think, are completely unrelated. [15:35] But there was like several. [15:37] Several similar sounding words [15:40] that had come from Scandinavia and English [15:46] that sounded similar and seemed to be kind of all come into the same same place. [15:55] What's really confusing to me is that loons. [16:00] Or at least the common loon is a North American bird [16:03] that you do find it in Greenland and Iceland. [16:08] Which I mean, I guess the. [16:11] You know, the Vikings got there pretty early on, [16:14] but it's sort of strange to me that the word made its way back [16:16] and then into the lexicon so early as the 1400s. [16:24] That's weird. [16:26] So when lunaticus originally referred mainly to epilepsy and madness. [16:32] Yeah, so I'm I'm I'm seeing here agreeing with you, Joey, that [16:37] the phrase loony comes not from the bird, but from lunatic. [16:44] And that is connected to the face of the moon. [16:51] I have the simile of lunatic behavior to a the water bird. [16:58] Was John Skelton in 1529 [17:04] wrote about the loons [17:08] speaking of their madmen cries. [17:11] So, yeah, we're trying to figure out where loons come from. [17:16] Yeah, I was looking at that, too. [17:17] Well, I mean, it's a common loon. [17:23] You know what? [17:23] I think I do see live on lakes. [17:25] We are in other waterways in Canada, the northern United States, [17:29] including Alaska and southern parts of Greenland and Iceland. [17:32] Small numbers breed on Svalbard and sporadically elsewhere in Arctic Eurasia. [17:38] Common loons winter on both coasts of the US as far south as Mexico [17:42] and on the Atlantic coast of Europe. [17:45] Yeah, that's what I'm seeing, too. [17:47] The they'll go to the Atlantic coast on Europe. [17:51] So they're all over the place up there, but they they that's [17:55] they just hang out there. [17:57] Merriam Webster suggests that loony is was influenced. [18:02] The word loony was influenced by the development and spread of the [18:08] crazy as a loon, even though it is directly from lunatic. [18:14] They suggest that the language and that phrase influenced the term loony, [18:18] which came later than both the phrase lunatic and crazy as a loon. [18:24] Well, I feel like we did good on time frames anyway. [18:27] Yeah, I mean, it wasn't. [18:29] We've done worse. [18:30] You know, it is a particularly American use of the word [18:33] to refer to a daft person as a loon. [18:36] That's what Merriam Webster says. [18:39] Can I disagree with the dictionary? [18:41] Yeah, you can do whatever you want, buddy. [18:47] All right, then I'll put I'll put it in. [18:50] I'm going to write a letter to the dictionary editor. [18:53] It had nothing to do with the Pittsburgh Pirates, however. Huh? [18:58] I think you should write that in your letter. [19:00] Oh, for sure. [19:03] Check your facts. [19:06] Who is my who is my favorite Pittsburgh pirate? [19:12] Do you know any Pittsburgh pirates? [19:14] Yeah, for sure. And events like [19:17] and events like who am I thinking of Roberto Clemente? [19:22] Definitely. He played there. Yeah. [19:26] He's my favorite. He's the only pirate that I like. [19:31] And maybe it's like just because it's fun. [19:34] And also Blackbeard, you like him? [19:37] Yeah. Well, did we learn anything? [19:43] I feel like we nailed it. [19:45] OK, you don't even. [19:46] Why do we need Google? [19:48] Yeah. Just listen to us, guys. [19:53] You could have read something in in 30 seconds on Google [19:58] or you could listen to us for 20 minutes. So yeah. Yeah. [20:02] What we need is to just like add three or four more people [20:05] to our Google show, so we just have more guesses that would [20:09] we could really blanket the potential options if we do that. [20:14] I mean, we did we did guess a lot of things. [20:17] We did guess a lot of things, but we were right on many of them. [20:20] Pretty pretty right on things. [20:23] Nice work, team. [20:25] Feel good about our big brains. [20:28] And Barry Bonds, I think, is who I was probably thinking of. [20:31] Oh, yeah, he was he was a pirate, right? [20:34] Yeah. For most, most famously a pirate. [20:37] Yeah. That was before all the steroids, was it? [20:40] Yeah, his head was like a totally normal size. [20:49] Were you still recording? [20:51] I mean, cut off what you want. [20:55] This is podcast where where all the gold is very end of the recording. [21:01] Yeah.