Episode 175 · June 17, 2023
Rhymes with Jaw
The hosts try to figure out what a craw is and why something gets "stuck in your craw".
“What's a craw and what's stuck in it?” (01:07)
Questions
Where does the phrase "stuck in my craw" come from? (01:07)
Our guess
Something stuck in your mouth or teeth, from rural 1800s America or animal husbandry.
Something stuck in your mouth or teeth, from rural 1800s America or animal husbandry.
Reveal the answer
The answer
A craw is the crop, a bird's preliminary stomach, where grit and stones help grind food. Stones too big to pass would literally get stuck there. The earliest known citation is an 1878 book (Old Times in Tennessee).
A craw is the crop, a bird's preliminary stomach, where grit and stones help grind food. Stones too big to pass would literally get stuck there. The earliest known citation is an 1878 book (Old Times in Tennessee).
Verdict partly
Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:00] Here's another wild stat. [00:02] It took Rick Smith's 867 games to get his 1,111 blocks. [00:11] And it has taken Miles Turner 48. [00:14] Rick Smith is also like 7'9", right? [00:23] Yes. [00:25] All right. [00:29] We have not done it on Google in a while, so I figure we should do one. [00:34] Coalson, what can we solve for you this week? [00:50] We do it under Googles. [00:51] That was the play-up. [00:52] I'm super excited. [00:53] You told us we had to. [00:54] You said we signed up for it. [00:55] In the end, it's going to be better and more true than Google can give you. [01:07] Well, I have questions all the time, and I usually hold them, I write them down, I put [01:12] them in my pocket, and I say, I'm going to wait until I talk to my smartest friends. [01:17] This week, I've got one stuck in my craw. [01:26] So I guess it's multiple questions here. [01:35] What's a craw and what's stuck in it? [01:39] Good place to start. [01:42] What is your sense of what the ... So what's the meaning of this phrase first? [01:47] Let's start there. [01:49] I always thought of it as something that was, I was annoyed or pissed off because there [01:55] was something bothering me. [02:00] Yep. [02:01] I'm with you there. [02:02] That's it. [02:03] Harper, that's your general. [02:06] Lasting irritation, perhaps? [02:08] Yeah. [02:09] Yeah. [02:10] I'm particularly upset about the fact that this thing is stuck in my craw. [02:16] But is craw an eye, a mouth, a butthole? [02:23] I don't know what my craw is. [02:26] I know about a craw dad or a craw fish, which is a mini lobster, basically. [02:36] Right? [02:37] Okay. [02:40] Is that what a craw dad is? [02:41] A craw dad is a craw dad and a craw fish, the same thing and a googable inside and a googable? [02:46] No, no, no. [02:47] The craw dad is like the little bitty thing and the craw fish is what you get and they're [02:52] like mini lobsters. [02:55] So what's a craw dad? [02:56] A craw dad is like a little, it's got like little pincers, it's like what you catch [02:59] in the crick. [03:00] In the crick? [03:01] Oh, okay. [03:02] I think you catch a craw fish, is ... So if you were to order them, they're all little [03:10] things with pincers. [03:12] Yeah. [03:13] You guys didn't catch craw dads when you were a kid? [03:14] Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. [03:15] You catch them in the creek and you put them in a little aquarium and they die a couple [03:20] days later? [03:21] We did not do that. [03:22] Okay. [03:23] I did that. [03:24] I'm with you. [03:25] Okay. [03:26] Okay. [03:27] And so a craw fish is just larger than that? [03:31] Yeah, but I would assume it's a different species. [03:35] Okay. [03:36] You know what they say about assuming, right? [03:40] That's true. [03:41] Okay. [03:42] All right. [03:43] A craw, let's get back to a craw. [03:46] Harper, you intonated earlier and we were discussing this that it's a mouth thing. [03:51] I thought a craw was mouth. [03:53] So my sort of intuition on this one is that if a human or perhaps an animal gets something [04:00] stuck in their craw, and maybe I just think that because it rhymes with a jaw, could [04:05] be no more complex than that. [04:07] But if he gets something stuck, like a piece of food, it will decay and cause irritation [04:13] potentially. [04:14] Yeah. [04:15] Yeah. [04:16] Well, there is a thing, like birds have a crop, which is like the thing before the [04:23] esophagus that like grinds up seeds and stuff like that. [04:29] So maybe you're conflating crop and jaw, I don't know. [04:34] Side note, I agree with you. [04:37] My initial thinking was that it was oral in some way, shape, or form. [04:40] I don't know why. [04:42] But I don't think of it as in the back of my throat because then I'd be choking, right? [04:46] I think of it as like it's stuck in my tooth. [04:51] So you also had an oral connotation to this. [04:56] I mean, I don't know, it was an irritant. [04:59] So like I thought, I guess I thought, yeah. [05:03] One of the holes. [05:04] I figured it was either, I figured it was my teeth. [05:07] Something's caught in my teeth, I think. [05:09] Yeah. [05:10] Okay. [05:13] Okay. [05:15] And so that makes sense. [05:16] If something gets stuck in your craw, you get a toothache. [05:20] It's a real pain in the A, you know? [05:24] So where do we think this is coming from? [05:29] Like what time period? [05:31] What region? [05:32] Is this an American thing? [05:33] It seems like an American thing, but it may be an American. [05:36] Well, okay. [05:37] So here's, I guess if it's stuck in your craw, it's not just an irritant. [05:42] It's an irritant that is such a big deal that it's sort of outraging you and you can't [05:47] really focus on anything else, right? [05:51] I've got something stuck in my craw. [05:52] I got to talk about it right now. [05:54] Okay. [05:55] Right? [05:56] Sure. [05:57] So it's not like having, you know, a popcorn seed in between your teeth. [06:00] It's more dramatic than that. [06:04] I feel like if I have a popcorn thing stuck in my teeth, I got to deal with it right then. [06:08] I can't just, like I'm, you know, mid-conversation and just like kind of finger in and out trying [06:16] to get it out. [06:17] Kind of noodling it with your tongue. [06:18] Like I'm not, I'm trying to be, you know, tactful or cooth in that situation. [06:22] Okay. [06:26] So, but to me, it sounds like a rural America type of thing. [06:32] Yeah. [06:33] I could buy that. [06:34] It definitely feels like animal husbandry thing. [06:36] Like I don't feel like this really is a human thing. [06:39] I feel like it's an animal thing. [06:41] Like you get an animal, it gets stuck in their craw, it gets infected and then you got chopped [06:45] set off. [06:46] Oh, God. [06:47] Oh, God. [06:48] Okay. [06:49] So that's definitely rural. [06:50] I thought we had to pull some teeth. [06:51] We had to cut their head off. [06:57] So are you talking about like, so you're thinking like it's for a cow? [07:00] A falconry. [07:05] What about, what about horse racing? [07:06] Could be horse racing. [07:07] Hey, let's go horse racing. [07:08] Let's go. [07:09] Okay. [07:10] So what if your craw is your toes or something? [07:13] Like it's in your hoof and then like that really bothers you. [07:18] Stuck in your craw. [07:19] Yeah. [07:20] It's like a bunion or something. [07:23] Yeah. [07:24] Like if you get like a, you know, a nail or a piece of wood or something spiked up [07:28] in your... [07:29] Oh, no, no. [07:30] I'm just saying. [07:31] Like if you have a thing on your foot, it's like annoying because you walk everywhere. [07:35] Yeah. [07:36] It hits you every time. [07:39] Just like if you have an annoyance in your mouth, you have to eat. [07:42] So it's going to bother you every day. [07:47] But I'm with you Jason. [07:48] I think this is a, it's a rural America 1800s slang, craw is a slang term for, for your [07:56] mouth hole, for your face hole. [07:59] And you, and they call it, they've called it craw for other situations in the past. [08:05] And somehow this is what filtered down. [08:09] All right. [08:10] I'm with you. [08:11] So I'm thinking Georgia O'Keeffe. [08:19] Georgia O'Keeffe. [08:20] You guys love it when I guess that. [08:28] All right. [08:29] So according to the Southern standard, stuck in one's craw means annoyed by something unpleasant [08:36] but forced to accept. [08:39] This saying comes from food, which is collected in a foul's preliminary stomach called a [08:44] craw. [08:45] I always thought it was called a craw. [08:46] The craw is the crap, but or preliminary stomach of a foul or it is predigested through the [08:53] use of grit and stones swallowed before going on into the gizzard to finally dissolve into [09:02] either usable form. [09:03] Okay. [09:04] So it's so you, so you nailed that the crop, but, but here's the thing does, is it the [09:11] idea that it's something that you can't break down with your little stone stuff in the [09:15] crop. [09:16] Right. [09:17] So it's hunters centuries ago. [09:19] Notice the sunburst swallowed. [09:20] This is from, um, whatever phrase origins or whatever. [09:24] It's a stone that were too large to pass through the craw and into the digestive track. [09:28] These stones, unlike the sand and pebbles needed by the birds to help crime the food, [09:32] literally stuck in the crop. [09:33] Oh, I see. [09:35] Right. [09:36] Okay. [09:37] And the odd part of the language in hunters used to figure the earliest known citation [09:44] is from old times in Tennessee and is a by Josephus Kahn guilt 1878. [09:53] I think we kind of nailed, we nailed the timeline for sure. [09:57] And also you guessed the bird crop. [10:00] I, it's very literal though. [10:03] It's something it's a stone actually stuck in their craw. [10:07] Okay. [10:08] One of the mold folks. [10:12] See isms.