Episode 162 · October 15, 2022
Disembodied Hand
The hosts try to work out where "the writing's on the wall" comes from, guessing at graffiti and whiteboards before landing on the Bible.
“Disembodied hand was the name of my girlfriend in high school.” (12:38)
Questions
Where does the phrase "the writing's on the wall" come from? (02:45)
Our guess
Graffiti, as political dissent written on walls in ancient Greece, or a whiteboard in a science lab in the 1930s.
Graffiti, as political dissent written on walls in ancient Greece, or a whiteboard in a science lab in the 1930s.
Reveal the answer
The answer
From the Book of Daniel (chapter 5): at King Belshazzar's feast a disembodied hand writes on the palace wall, and Daniel interprets it as a sign of the fall of Babylon (about 540 BC).
From the Book of Daniel (chapter 5): at King Belshazzar's feast a disembodied hand writes on the palace wall, and Daniel interprets it as a sign of the fall of Babylon (about 540 BC).
Verdict partly
Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:00] So we've got a lot of infighting and a duck mobile. That's what we got. I [00:08] Feel like this is the one thing that we used to be able to figure out how to do is get people freaking mail [00:15] We could put a man on the moon and get people mail in the middle of nowhere. Like we can do that [00:23] We can but the question is at what cost how expensive is it gonna be? [00:27] I mean, that's always been the question the USPS is an amazing institution [00:32] The idea that somehow if we privatized it all these problems would go away has never quite made sense to me [00:37] And in fact, it makes less and less sense [00:41] Wow, I mean given the tone of this article, I would argue that a private company would not be engaging in this sort of [00:50] profligacy [00:51] If it were left up to them, so this this would certainly be an argument for privatization fair enough [00:57] But I mean, you know, you've got Amazon and and you know [01:02] FedEx and [01:04] UPS, you know still using [01:07] The United States Postal Service to get stuff to unreachable points because it's an amazing [01:13] Entity. Yeah, shout out postal service. It's an amazing amazing shout out postal service 51 cents [01:21] Yeah, just for since up anywhere. Yeah, whatever you want [01:26] Actually Joey [01:29] I'm gonna I'm gonna I'm gonna send you some [01:32] Some good vibes 51 cents coming your way. Are you sending it through the postal service? Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep. Okay. All right [01:40] Well, you're coming here in like a day. So yeah, good call. Yeah, just show [01:47] No, actually, you know what I'm gonna do I'm gonna send I'm gonna talk shit and hope that arrives before I do [01:52] We'll see how it goes [01:54] Okay, so when I show up we can fight [01:57] We could fight no matter what man. Don't worry about it. Yeah, don't worry about that [02:03] Like I said, I'm gonna run away and wear the MIT headgear. Yeah, Joey and harden coming after you [02:11] Yeah, you were that a headgear leaving your your [02:14] soft body wide open [02:17] It's getting softer and softer my friend [02:22] All right, man, I think we should do an under Google and then get the heck out of here [02:27] Okay, I got a I got a couple good ones for you [02:45] Super excited told us we had to [02:50] We signed up for it in the end it's gonna be better and more true than Google can give you the writing's on the wall [03:02] When do we think that came about why do we think that's the thing? What do we think it means? [03:07] era [03:09] Meaning as we do on this show the writing is on the wall [03:16] So definition is as I understand it essentially it's [03:21] That you can see the conditions are in a way that something is going to happen, right? That's it [03:30] Something's gonna happen and you can tell what it is by [03:35] Almost almost obvious. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, it's it's it may be predetermined [03:40] But also very clear that this is gonna happen because the writing's on the wall [03:46] Yeah, so my first thought would be [03:52] Graffiti and the people who made that up. I think were the ancient Greeks [03:58] Okay [03:59] All right. So what were the ancient Greeks going with graffiti? They were the same thing that we're still doing with graffiti lots of dissent [04:06] Yeah, okay. So [04:09] Yeah, we got a lot of people writing stuff publicly on walls [04:13] Maybe the at that point the conclusion becomes foregone [04:19] Okay, so it's clear that the government's gonna be overthrown or somebody's gonna be out or right? [04:26] They're making clear their political dissent on the wall. Correct. Yeah, there was actually quite stable governance for the most part [04:33] But obviously democratic so people were in and out often [04:40] Now so [04:42] What form would that have taken back then I mean, this is not a spray paint can clearly [04:46] I mean, are we are we are we carving things with stone? Do we have paint? [04:51] People just lugging around pay cans [04:57] Well, I think [04:59] Krylon probably is the [05:01] Yeah one we would expect. Yeah [05:04] You got a tag stuff, right? [05:07] exactly [05:08] I mean, I think you'd have paints in that area. I would believe right. Yeah, sure [05:14] or some some sort of some sort of [05:17] You know paint paint like and that's how they made the the Grecian urns and stuff. Mm-hmm. Oh to a Grecian urn or [05:27] Something like that something like that [05:30] So do we think the well, so that's graffiti. Do we think the the phrase itself? [05:36] so I guess do you think the phrase itself is from [05:40] Something similar to back then or yeah, so he's going political protest back in Greece. I'm going old old school [05:46] That's what Harper's going with. Okay [05:49] Well, you think the phrase itself is also like that old? [05:53] Okay in [05:55] Latin Grecian [05:58] Whatever the language is. Yeah Greek was a language. I think Greek. Yeah, it seems like Grecian [06:06] Yeah, yeah, yeah [06:08] Quite prolific playwrights back then so [06:12] It may have made may have made it in I don't know and [06:16] And modern English, I don't know probably. Oh, we definitely interpreted all that stuff. Whatever, right? [06:24] Well, so that's the interesting thing, right? So we weren't able to understand ancient Greece [06:31] For ancient Greek for quite some quite some time [06:35] So it may have that that [06:41] Yeah, there there may be other other explanations here for sure [06:46] Joey, what do you think? [06:48] Writing is on the wall. We're seeing this coming. We know it's it's about to happen. It's almost predetermined. It's very obvious [06:56] Yeah, I mean I liked it. I like that for the graffiti. I mean, that's where you you know, literally see rightly writing on walls [07:03] And I think that's very literal is what you're saying [07:06] I mean, I think that yeah the I think that the root to me that that does sound pretty literal [07:12] I mean we see all sorts of stuff that I mean that not that I not a quibble with it [07:16] But just you know, we definitely do see things, you know written on walls that are you know [07:23] Not that we have not seen come to fruition like I've seen a lot of stuff in in graffiti in [07:29] Like bar bathrooms that I don't think it's true. I'm gonna say it [07:34] Did I ever ever tell you my favorite graffiti ever in a bar bathroom? Yeah [07:41] this was that oh [07:44] gosh was a cooter Browns in New Orleans and [07:48] When you went to the bathroom [07:51] Somebody had written my wife follows me everywhere and this is in the men's bathroom and then underneath somebody else wrote. No, I don't [08:01] That's solid work by some strong people. Yeah [08:08] So, yeah, maybe that's all it's about then don't want to guess Shakespeare or something [08:13] Yeah, no, no. No, I think it's got to be a little bit separated from that. I think it's not that odd [08:18] I don't think it's graffiti. I don't think it's people actually writing on walls [08:23] I think it's going to be a little bit different and [08:29] I think [08:31] I'm gonna say that it is [08:34] science lab related and there's a big whiteboard and [08:44] So you literally written on the wall on a on the wall [08:50] Just in a science lab [08:53] And the answer is in there somewhere, but we don't see it yet [08:59] Okay [09:00] That's what I'm going. So you're going [09:03] What time period I'm going with the [09:07] 30s the you think whiteboards were invented in [09:13] Okay, okay [09:16] Chuck board walls in the 1930s [09:19] More okay, or could be it could be a an overhead projector to that [09:26] And the answer is there somewhere we just don't have it I [09:30] Think that that makes the phrase slightly more interesting, right? [09:34] It's like it's not so obvious that the writing's on the wall [09:38] Even though the whole thing about the phrase is that it's obvious. So whatever you're welcome team [09:44] What do we got and I think it's we know that another thing I may be [09:49] From Pink Floyd it may be from there. Yeah [09:52] Yeah, what about the Great Wall? What about Trump's wall? I mean these things could all be a part of this [10:00] Well, the Great Wall was built Trump's wall wasn't so [10:04] Hey, you know what? I don't come to this basketball podcast to hear your politics Joey. It's not politics. It's just you know [10:15] Just the truth [10:18] They built like sections of it, but it's you know functional [10:22] All right. So according to idioms online [10:29] This idiom comes from the biblical story of belshazar's feast Daniel 5 [10:34] 5 through 31 in which in the presence of the king a disembodied hand appears and writes on the palace wall [10:41] The king frightened called for astrologers [10:45] Chaldeans and soothsayers and offered rewards to whoever could interpret the writing and did anybody was anybody able to do it? [10:56] You haven't read that come on [10:59] So, I'm sorry, I guess I could pull out my Bible and check [11:05] Let's see none of the wise men could read the messages of the Queen suggested [11:08] He called Daniel and whom is the spirit of the holy gods and in the days of thy [11:13] Father light and understanding and wisdom like the wisdom of the gods was found in him and whom the father's King King Nebuchadnezzar [11:20] Had become Beth or belt issues are and I'm seeing here that the phrase that was written was numbered [11:32] Wade and they are divided [11:34] Is that annual and interpret that as pointing to the downfall of the Babylonian Empire? [11:42] From according to the book of Daniel. It is a portent of doom [11:48] cool [11:50] Biblical so there's there's a disembodied hand that they went with [11:56] It's the Bible. Yeah, that's the most magical thing that happens in the Bible. I [12:00] Mean, I'm just saying if I was gonna tell the story [12:05] I probably wouldn't like make it it would just have like that the chalk right on the wall without a hand there [12:10] Look Harry Potter [12:13] What like [12:14] The Bible is not it's not it's not an entertainment. You know, it's I disagree. Yeah [12:22] This is the whole reason we we for generations we set our own campfires and needed a story about our people's [12:29] Entertain me Joey [12:31] Make me okay. Look you can teach me something, but I better be goddamn entertained. Yeah, okay [12:38] Amazingly, it was considered entertainment. I've tried to read that thing [12:43] boy [12:45] disembodied hand [12:46] Was the name of my masturbation in high school? I don't know [12:50] That didn't work just nope [12:53] Let's see didn't work [12:58] Disembodied hand was the name of my girlfriend in high school. That's better. That's closer [13:04] I like the audience can't see it [13:10] But I love it whenever you're on a bit you get super close to the mic [13:13] I love it. I love it when I get the lean in I know some greatness is about that [13:18] And it's funny cuz that's when I lean away from my computer [13:23] We're getting there. Yeah, I am finding I'm finding a little bit of maybe a put an alternative one [13:30] It says we don't need no education [13:34] We don't need no thought control [13:36] No, dark sarcasm in the classroom teacher [13:40] Leave them kids alone. And so that was from Nebuchadnezzar [13:44] in [13:46] In Daniel six, so the next Oh Daniel six. Okay. Yeah, this is the next chapter [13:52] All-in-all you're just another brick in the wall [13:56] So I have the good news is we got the time period about right we're talking, you know [14:01] circa [14:02] 540 BC ish [14:05] For sure. Yeah. Nice work, buddy. I think you nailed it [14:11] Of course dog. I've written down way later, but [14:14] Right. Well, that's the nature of the Bible [14:18] But we'll say it's all exactly true and that's how it happened and we nailed it. Mm-hmm [14:23] And shout out to Daniel five [14:26] All the other things out there [14:28] Yeah, Daniel five and the other one I like is Johnny five. I like that guy Johnny. Mm-hmm. Yeah [14:35] Shout out is alive [14:39] That was not a very good impression of a robot nope, he's alive no, that's not a good [14:48] That's my brother robot Harper, what's up with your boys? [14:55] I've seen the classic short-circuit skin like 1985 skin loopy. It's laid out there. Yeah. Yeah [15:08] There's an upside-down bottle of loopy