Episode 124 · December 25, 2021
Big Little Gherkin
The hosts trace the Christmas tree and the legendary German Christmas pickle.
“Big North Carolina.” (03:17)
Questions
Where did Christmas trees come from, and what about hiding a pickle in the tree? (01:10)
Our guess
A pagan winter evergreen tradition, adopted by Germans around the 1500s, with candles and pickle ornaments.
A pagan winter evergreen tradition, adopted by Germans around the 1500s, with candles and pickle ornaments.
Reveal the answer
The answer
Germany is credited with the modern tradition in the 16th century, building on older pagan evergreen customs (the Romans had Saturnalia). A Martin Luther candle story is dubious, and German settlers brought it to America. The "Christmas pickle" tradition is probably an American invention by salesmen selling glass ornaments in the late 1800s.
Germany is credited with the modern tradition in the 16th century, building on older pagan evergreen customs (the Romans had Saturnalia). A Martin Luther candle story is dubious, and German settlers brought it to America. The "Christmas pickle" tradition is probably an American invention by salesmen selling glass ornaments in the late 1800s.
Verdict right
Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:00] Joey, as the host, I'm going to stop you for a second, because I feel like we need to do [00:10] an under-Google-able. [00:11] All right. [00:14] Is there a new recording then, or? [00:25] So I have a question for the team. [00:27] Smooth as silk. [00:28] Wait, I thought this was like a standalone thing. [00:32] It is. [00:33] It is. [00:34] What are you stopping me from? [00:35] I haven't even done anything. [00:36] It's got to make it seem like it was organic. [00:39] Exactly. [00:40] It's what I'm trying to do, because then we put in the... [00:41] Totally spontaneous. [00:42] Yeah, and then we put in the... [00:43] We just had a conversation. [00:44] We just happened to be recording it. [00:45] Okay. [00:46] That's what we always do on the other shows, so like I'm trying to... [00:49] Okay, let's start over. [00:50] Oh, hey. [00:51] I didn't see you there. [00:52] Ooh. [00:53] Can we do an under-Google-ables? [00:54] That was the play-up. [00:55] Super excited. [00:56] We told us we had to. [01:10] You said we signed up for it. [01:12] In the end, it's going to be better and more true than Google can give you. [01:23] So I've got a question for the team that I feel like needs to be answered without Google. [01:32] Christmas trees. [01:33] What's up with Christmas trees? [01:35] I have two things that I know about them, but I don't know enough about them, so I didn't [01:40] Google them without talking to my three smartest friends. [01:45] One, I know that at some point, Christmas trees existed and we put lit candles on them, which [01:52] seems like super dangerous to me before we had the Christmas lights. [01:58] More fire departments. [01:59] Yeah, yeah. [02:01] And then two, I know that in Germany, they used to hide pickles in the Christmas tree, [02:09] and I think that that is the beginning of ornaments, but I'm not really sure that's [02:13] something I heard, and I don't know how to have an era or anything. [02:17] Christmas trees. [02:18] Why do we bring dead trees inside the house to celebrate the death of, or no, the birth [02:22] of Christ? [02:23] Not the death of Christ. [02:24] That'd be weird. [02:25] The birth of Christ. [02:29] Does anybody have any thoughts of when or how or why? [02:32] Well, I'm going to guess most things related to Christmas, it has nothing to do with Jeebus, [02:42] and it's more of a pagan thing. [02:44] Yeah. [02:45] Christmas writ large is that way, so why would Christmas trees be any different? [02:51] And I'm going to guess that it was big pine. [02:56] Now, I will say to you that I have spent much of my life in North Carolina, and this [03:03] is, and people don't know this, but this is where most of your Christmas trees come from, [03:08] is North Carolina. [03:10] Huge Christmas tree farms all over the place. [03:12] It's like the corn of Indiana, it's Christmas trees, and we're sending you Christmas trees [03:17] all over the country here in North Carolina. [03:19] So maybe North Carolina is the reason why we have Christmas trees? [03:24] I don't know. [03:25] Like big North Carolina. [03:26] Yeah, big North Carolina. [03:30] So you said that they used to hide pickles in the trees, so I actually thought maybe [03:34] it was big little kurken. [03:36] Well, it seems to me like this comes from, yeah, it's a Northern European pagan thing [03:46] is what my guess is. [03:51] Going back to, God knows when, like the way back. [03:58] I mean, it's got to be just far enough along to your neighbors live close enough to come [04:02] over once a month, right? [04:07] So pretty early. [04:09] Yeah, I feel like I've not heard the pickle thing before, but I've never heard of hiding [04:21] it in a tree. [04:24] I mean, I feel like the Germans were... [04:29] Your wife never told you to hide the pickle? [04:31] Not in the tree. [04:35] I feel like the Germans were bringing the decorating game, and I feel like the candles [04:50] in the tree, that's what I associate that with is Germany. [04:54] Yeah. [04:55] Yeah, I do too. [04:56] I don't know why I feel like that's German, but I feel like lit candles on a dying tree [05:03] seems incredibly dangerous to me. [05:06] I had a bar regular who was German, and they had a German ornament, it was a pickle ornament, [05:17] and you would hide that in the tree, and then finding it gave you like an extra gift [05:22] or whatever. [05:24] So I assume that at one point it was a real pickle and not a pickle ornament, and I assume [05:31] that that's how people started hanging things on the tree. [05:35] That's my assumption. [05:37] But I agree with you. [05:38] I'm feeling this is German. [05:39] I mean, I agree that it's pagan originally, pagan tree connected to stuff, because everything [05:46] Christmas is pagan, but I think that the lighting of the tree and the hanging of ornaments [05:51] may be German. [05:52] Sure. [05:55] German is like Sid and St. Nicholas and Krampus and all that stuff. [06:01] Yeah. [06:02] It's like a German. [06:03] Right. [06:04] For sure. [06:05] And didn't we learn that the Easter Bunny was German as well? [06:09] Oyster? [06:10] I don't remember. [06:15] Yeah, I think it was the Oyster Hoss or something like that, and there was like a rabbit [06:22] that was the bisexual or something. [06:26] I'm going to assume homicidal. [06:29] I think it was a virgin rabbit, but it was the Oyster Goddess, I think. [06:35] The Germans are so weird, man. [06:37] Yeah, the Oyster Hoss. [06:39] Yeah. [06:41] That was German as well. [06:42] Easter was German as well. [06:44] So I'm going to go with the Germans created Christmas trees. [06:48] Yeah. [06:49] But probably before there was anything approximating a modern day Germany is probably what? [06:56] We're talking 1,600, 1,700. [06:59] Yeah. [07:00] So the Germanic peoples in what? [07:04] Let's go 1,200? [07:08] Middle ages. [07:12] 1,200 is really early. [07:14] It's really early. [07:16] Let's go 1,500 then. [07:18] Okay. [07:19] I want to go pre-Shakespeare though. [07:22] Pre-Shakespeare. [07:23] You don't want that Shakespeare stick on. [07:27] Exactly. [07:29] Shakespeare stick. [07:32] And then, yeah, so we think it's just like around whatever the winter solstice type thing. [07:39] Yeah, no, it's definitely from the pagans. [07:41] Trees, let's decorate this. [07:43] Hide a pickle. [07:45] No, it's definitely from the pagans. [07:48] This is a... [07:49] I think the pine trees are the thing that survives through the winter, and it's a [07:54] thing of life when everything else is dying. [07:58] Exactly, yeah. [07:59] This is hope for the next season, right? [08:02] And then lighting candles is super dangerous, and probably a lot of things got lit on fire. [08:09] A lot of houses burned down, and that's what I think. [08:13] It was cold, so if it catches... bonus bonfire. [08:19] Yeah, exactly. [08:20] So I'm going with pagan ancestry. [08:24] The pine trees survived through the winter, and that's why they are a hope for the birth of Jesus. [08:32] Did you guys see this thing? [08:34] 1,500. [08:35] I was watching Seth Meyers, and apparently Miller Lite has drinkable ornaments now. [08:42] So it's like a Miller Lite can in the shape of like a globe ornament, [08:47] which seemed both weird and awesome to me. [08:53] Do you know why Miller Lite and having sex in a canoe are the same thing? [08:59] Something about water. [09:03] They're both fucking close to water. [09:05] There you go. [09:08] Nice. [09:09] Oh, now I'll have to be explicit on this one. [09:15] For like no reason. [09:17] For no reason, just because I'm out of control. [09:22] Are we supposed to be clicking? [09:23] Yeah, yeah. [09:24] Yeah, what do we got? [09:25] No. [09:26] No. [09:27] Nobody cares. [09:28] Nobody listens to this. [09:29] Nobody cares. [09:30] Yeah, I don't know. [09:34] Yeah, super... [09:36] I mean, who doesn't... [09:38] You know, decorating is cool. [09:40] Cut something down. [09:42] What else were you doing? [09:44] Yeah, I had nothing else to do. [09:47] You're going 60. [09:48] No, press. [09:49] What about like pencil? [09:50] I'm going to say we nailed it. [09:53] According to History.com, Germany is credited with starting the Christmas tree tradition, [09:58] as we know it, in the 16th century when devout Christians brought decorated trees into their [10:05] homes. [10:07] Some built Christmas pyramids of wood and decorated them with evergreens and candles if wood [10:13] was scarce. [10:14] It is widely held belief that Martin Luther first added lighted candles to a tree. [10:21] That sounds sketchy. [10:24] Walking towards his home one winter evening composing a sermon, he was awed by the brilliance [10:29] of stars twinkling amidst evergreens. [10:32] To recapture the scene for his family, he erected a tree in the main room and wired [10:36] its branches with lighted candles. [10:38] No, I'm out. [10:39] I'm out. [10:40] That's bullshit. [10:41] Okay, yeah. [10:42] Sorry. [10:43] Sorry that you have a problem with. [10:44] I do. [10:45] Hey, look, we've got one guy that like made the Protestants. [10:49] Let's just make him in charge of the Christmas tree as well. [10:51] Like, come on. [10:52] Come on. [10:53] We already got one guy in charge of all the things. [10:57] Whatever. [10:59] If he nailed the thing on the door, he didn't also put a pickle on a tree, you know? [11:04] I'm not saying anything about pickles and trees. [11:08] German settlers brought Christmas trees to America. [11:11] See? [11:12] There you go. [11:13] And did they also bring pickles? [11:14] I'm going to look up pickles and trees real fast. [11:21] Saturnalia was the Roman celebration between the 17th and the 25th that Christmas was [11:27] meant to counteract. [11:31] What was that again? [11:33] Saturnalia. [11:34] Okay. [11:35] The Roman holiday. [11:36] Right. [11:37] Because they had to counteract it somehow. [11:40] Right. [11:41] Because pagans. [11:42] Right. [11:43] These evergreens were initially called paradise trees. [11:49] So, I haven't seen this Christmas pickle, but it is apparently, it was believed to have [12:02] come from Germany, but it is. [12:04] That seems like that is not true. [12:06] What? [12:07] Well, it seems so. [12:09] Yeah, that's the one. [12:12] It seems like the Americans say that, but the Germans don't know about it. [12:16] So, it seems like an American thing. [12:22] Well, I just let you know that, but I had a German regular who believed it was true, [12:28] but she was probably born in America, honestly. [12:32] Okay. [12:33] Or grew up in America at the very least. [12:36] What do you know about the German pickle? [12:41] You already tell you this is explicit, right? [12:47] I mean, all I've seen is that kind of what you say, you just kind of hide it in [12:53] the tree. [12:55] Did you get a prize or something for finding that? [13:00] Yeah. [13:01] Yeah. [13:02] But I don't know what that prize was. [13:04] Hopefully, something more substantial than a pickle. [13:07] Unless you really like pickles, you know what I'm saying? [13:12] Unfortunately, I do. [13:14] I'm hiding my pickle in the tree. [13:16] It was driven by big German glass. [13:20] The historical evidence supports the theory that the tradition was most likely [13:24] fabricated by salesmen during the late 1800s to promote German glass ornaments [13:29] in American stores. [13:30] Oh, and glass blown decorative vegetables. [13:35] It seems like I've seen a couple of places refer to a story where St. [13:39] Nicholas saved two boys who were trapped in a barrel of pickles. [13:44] But I don't think that I think that was completely fabricated by these glass [13:49] salesmen. [13:50] Okay. [13:51] One big glass. [13:52] All I know is that Santa is happy if you took on his pickle. [13:56] Merry Christmas.