The Undegooglables
Better answers than Google can give you.

Apple PodcastsSpotifyYouTubeOvercastRSSWebsite

Episode 87 · April 3, 2021

Unholy Terror

At Easter, the hosts try to work out where the Easter Bunny comes from, weighing pagan fertility festivals against "big sugar".

“Which came first, the rabbit or the egg?” (04:17)

Questions

Where does the Easter Bunny come from? (01:05)

Our guess
A pagan spring fertility tradition (rabbits are very fertile), or a Hallmark and candy-industry invention.
Reveal the answer
The answer
German immigrants brought the egg-laying hare "Osterhase" to Pennsylvania in the 1700s, and the custom is first mentioned in a 1682 German text. The hare was a medieval symbol of fertility, and Bede linked Easter to a Saxon goddess, Eostre, though there's no firm evidence. Decorating eggs dates to at least the 13th century, since eggs were forbidden in Lent.
Verdict partly

Listen to the episode

Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:00] I think I'm ready to move on to just different, different realms of wisdom in the under Googles.
[00:07] What do you got for us this week?
[00:11] Oh, we do under Googles?
[00:16] That was the play of it.
[00:18] I'm super excited.
[00:19] I told us we had to.
[00:21] We said we signed up for it.
[00:26] In the end, it's going to be better and more true than Google can give you.
[00:31] Oh my gosh, I've missed the under Googles.
[00:33] I'm so glad it's back.
[00:35] I was, I was, you know, we have a separate feed for under Googles, right?
[00:39] So we've gone back and mined out all the under Googles over the years.
[00:42] And we play it on the under Google podcasts, which if you're not signed up for that, please subscribe.
[00:49] I was listening to this year and it occurred to me that even though we've done a lot of holidays,
[00:57] I don't think we've done Easter.
[00:59] I do not believe that I know the origin of the Easter Bunny.
[01:05] And I think we should figure it out right now.
[01:07] Never have any thoughts.
[01:11] Easter Bunny.
[01:12] Why does the Easter Bunny exist?
[01:14] I mean, they remind me, like, I don't know, we've done a bunch of these.
[01:18] Yeah, we've done a bunch of these.
[01:19] Where did like the Tooth Fairy come from?
[01:21] So the Tooth Fairy was, gosh, that was it had a bunch of different origins.
[01:27] But yeah, every every culture had some sort of sort of stealing children's teeth superstition around the teeth.
[01:38] Yeah.
[01:39] Yeah.
[01:40] Yeah.
[01:41] Like there was I think it was in Japan.
[01:42] They like take the tooth and like put it under the house to ward off evil spirits.
[01:47] Sometimes they take the mouse teeth because it's because mouse teeth like grow forever or something like that.
[01:53] And it's like good luck or something like that.
[01:57] But yeah, I think the idea was yet to either ward off evil spirits or bring in good spirits.
[02:03] Yeah.
[02:04] And culturally, it made sense that it happened around the world because every child has to go through the trauma of losing a tooth.
[02:10] And so they've all kind of created this stuff.
[02:14] Was the fairy specific to something, though?
[02:17] Oh, thanks.
[02:20] Because there was there was there was the magic thing.
[02:23] Yeah.
[02:25] Because there was like the the the, you know, tooth mouse or whatever.
[02:29] You're right. But like there was like the fairy was specific.
[02:32] I mean, because what was the like Santa was a Nordic elf.
[02:36] Right.
[02:37] That was that.
[02:38] Mm hmm.
[02:40] Everybody.
[02:43] Easter bunny.
[02:44] I feel like is a pagan thing.
[02:46] Are they all pagan things sort of.
[02:50] Yeah, sure.
[02:51] Aren't we all are we all pagans when it really comes out to it?
[02:54] No.
[02:56] No, but I feel like Easter.
[02:59] The Easter holiday basically was co-opted from the pagan.
[03:04] It's Vernal Equinox sort of festival.
[03:07] I thought of like fertility and rebirth and all of this stuff and and.
[03:15] Rabbits, as you know, as a rabbit owner, Coalson are.
[03:21] Notoriously fertile creatures.
[03:25] Hmm.
[03:26] So I sort of always assumed that that's where I came from that that,
[03:29] you know.
[03:30] So the rabbits are the representative of fertility sort of in this.
[03:35] The situation.
[03:36] Yeah.
[03:37] Do they have similar to the rabbit?
[03:39] Great.
[03:40] That's definitely why the egg way we do like egg hunts around Easter.
[03:44] Right.
[03:45] Because the egg is the sign of the new.
[03:49] Generation or whatever, right?
[03:52] Well, I mean, eggs make sense, right?
[03:54] In the sense that, yeah, it is.
[03:56] You're about to hatch from something.
[03:58] There's birth.
[03:59] That has nothing to do with rabbits at all.
[04:01] Right.
[04:02] No, that's what I'm saying.
[04:03] The eggs make sense.
[04:05] The rabbits are connected because rabbits don't lay eggs.
[04:09] But I suppose rabbits are.
[04:12] Fertile.
[04:13] Well, but I mean, that begs the question.
[04:17] Why eggs?
[04:20] Hmm.
[04:23] Which came first, the rabbit or the egg?
[04:26] It's an age old question.
[04:28] Very good question.
[04:29] Well played, sir.
[04:32] Do you think that our pagan ancestors had some kind of rabbit chase or
[04:36] something?
[04:37] Hmm.
[04:38] Yeah.
[04:39] There's there's probably something.
[04:42] Didn't didn't a lot.
[04:43] I feel like a lot of this stuff ended up being weird like key parties,
[04:48] like pagan parties.
[04:51] Haven't we gone through several of those in our watching man.
[04:57] We've done pagan parties before.
[05:01] And I feel like the vernal equinox was definitely that.
[05:05] So yeah, what if like like you send out like somebody's got to take
[05:12] their clothes off and chase a rabbit catches it like gets to have sex with
[05:17] whoever they want or something like that.
[05:20] I think I think I think Coney's are pretty good eating.
[05:27] Yeah.
[05:28] And they're probably easier to hunt when they're distracted by mating or
[05:34] taking care of their kids or the kids are stupid.
[05:37] So kids are stupid kids.
[05:39] Kids are stupid.
[05:40] Rabbits aren't super smart.
[05:44] Dumb is a kid rabbit quick.
[05:47] They are super quick.
[05:49] I mean, it's either like this or like big sugar, right?
[05:53] Well, okay.
[05:54] So it's funny because I we were thinking about we were doing the
[05:58] Valentine's Day one.
[05:59] You know, I was listening to that recently and Harper was like,
[06:03] this is definitely about Hallmark.
[06:05] And we know we argued and we like, no, there's got to be some
[06:09] history to it.
[06:10] I think in this sense, this is definitely Hallmark.
[06:12] I think that Hallmark made up the Easter Bunny because it doesn't
[06:17] make any sense.
[06:18] It's just it's not connected to anything.
[06:20] Why is it?
[06:21] Why is it a bunny?
[06:22] Why is a rabbit carrying around eggs?
[06:23] I think this is created by Hallmark.
[06:25] Or who's the who's the egg guy that the who's big egg?
[06:33] Is that what you're asking?
[06:34] I like the the people make the egg decoration.
[06:39] Yeah, I know what you're talking about.
[06:41] Like Cadbury.
[06:43] No, no, they make the chocolate eggs.
[06:46] Yeah, the cream filled chocolate.
[06:48] But like it's a puzzle.
[06:51] No, it starts with a P.
[06:53] Right.
[06:54] Like those little kits that you can get with the wire thing
[06:57] and you dip your egg in there.
[06:59] Yeah.
[07:00] That's good.
[07:01] What about peeps?
[07:02] Is it big peeps?
[07:03] Is that who made this up?
[07:05] Big peeps.
[07:06] Because they have they have the chickens to the little chicks
[07:09] and that makes sense.
[07:10] Right.
[07:11] The chicks make sense because they're connected to the egg.
[07:14] That's exactly why they wouldn't have the creativity
[07:16] to come up with the Easter bunny.
[07:20] Big peeps have been planted safe for a long time.
[07:24] Yeah.
[07:25] Oh, man.
[07:29] Could there be an outside link of like something?
[07:37] I mean, you're a biblical scholar.
[07:39] Sure.
[07:41] You've done so well on that.
[07:43] Do rabbits play a role?
[07:45] And like are there stories of rabbits?
[07:51] No, I think Aesop is big on the rabbits.
[07:55] I don't think the Bible's big on rabbits.
[07:58] Maybe it goes to the rabbit's foot, which is good luck.
[08:02] It's spring.
[08:04] We need good luck.
[08:06] So there's rabbits around.
[08:08] Good harvest.
[08:09] Yeah.
[08:14] I feel like a lot of this stuff does have its roots
[08:16] in like northern European Christianity sort of stuff.
[08:21] Yeah.
[08:22] This just feels weirdly American to me.
[08:24] OK.
[08:25] OK.
[08:26] Well, because we talked about if this is, you know,
[08:32] you're right, Jason, this is a pagan holiday.
[08:35] The Easter is put on top of a pagan holiday, right?
[08:37] And Jesus rising from the dead is about the rebirth
[08:42] and spring and all that stuff kind of works into that.
[08:47] And rabbits do have their litter in spring.
[08:50] And I suppose that makes sense.
[08:53] I'm just trying to figure out when somebody did that.
[08:57] Was that the were the pagans doing it?
[09:01] And when when the Christians put Easter on top that they just
[09:05] kind of inherited the rabbit or is this like America?
[09:09] Like this is is this like Coke?
[09:13] Yeah, yeah.
[09:14] And you could imagine, you know,
[09:18] big sugar trying to play off the popularity of Bugs Bunny
[09:23] or something like that.
[09:25] Kids like rabbits.
[09:26] Let's just start throwing rabbits on our packaging
[09:30] for these candies or something.
[09:32] Yeah, big sugar.
[09:33] OK.
[09:34] I like it.
[09:35] Yeah, because chickens are not that cute.
[09:37] They're not.
[09:38] And, you know, and basically dumb.
[09:40] I beg to differ.
[09:41] They're stupid, but I think they're cute.
[09:43] OK. Chicks are cute.
[09:44] Chicks are cute.
[09:45] Not chickens.
[09:46] Certainly not roosters.
[09:47] I want to murder every rooster I've ever had.
[09:50] Wow.
[09:52] They're mean.
[09:53] They're mean and loud in the morning.
[09:55] Not a good kind of rooster demographic.
[09:57] Yeah, that's true.
[10:00] That was a big demo for us.
[10:02] The other reason is that big sugar definitely, like,
[10:05] weave their way into Easter, right?
[10:08] Like, the only thing that I associate with Easter
[10:11] is getting an Easter basket full of candy.
[10:13] Candy, sure.
[10:14] Yeah, chocolate.
[10:15] Like, that's the only thing, right?
[10:17] No, we're dying eggs.
[10:19] You did that, no?
[10:20] Yeah, sure, dying eggs, but I definitely didn't.
[10:24] My older sisters got a lot more of that than I did.
[10:27] By the time I came around, my mom was like,
[10:29] man.
[10:33] That boy don't want to do this.
[10:35] Right.
[10:36] She was right.
[10:37] Was she wrong?
[10:38] No.
[10:40] So, OK.
[10:42] I think I'm pretty good with this.
[10:47] I think, Joey, do you have an opinion?
[10:50] Because I feel like we've...
[10:53] It's either some pagan key party that involves rabbits
[10:57] or it's big sugar.
[11:01] So, what's the specific question?
[11:04] Where does the Easter Bunny come from?
[11:06] Easter Bunny specifically, OK.
[11:11] I mean, I think the bunny is...
[11:12] So, I would say maybe the bunny and the eggs would be...
[11:17] Yeah, I mean, like, maybe I'm not, like, kind of unrelated.
[11:23] Maybe they came from different places.
[11:27] Yeah, I don't know about key party, but I would say maybe...
[11:34] Maybe...
[11:37] Yeah, I mean, I definitely see...
[11:40] You know, you see rabbits in the spring when they're...
[11:42] I see rabbits in the spring when my cat goes out
[11:46] and brings some back for us.
[11:49] Leaves them on the doorstep.
[11:54] That's...
[11:56] It's always sad.
[12:00] Yeah, I think they're a sign of spring.
[12:03] From age old...
[12:07] This goes back to Harper's pagan ancestors.
[12:11] Mine are Christian all the way back, but...
[12:14] Yeah, better stock than my pagan forefathers.
[12:19] My maternal side, all Christians.
[12:23] They're just the forefathers.
[12:25] Oh, sure.
[12:27] Did you guys know that there's an Easter Bunny tracker?
[12:30] Really? Just like Santa Claus tracker?
[12:32] Absolutely.
[12:33] That's awesome.
[12:34] Wow.
[12:35] Is the Easter Bunny already started?
[12:36] He's in Brasilia.
[12:39] He has delivered 1.1 billion baskets.
[12:42] Already?
[12:43] He's traveling somewhere...
[12:45] His speed is varying between about 1,500 and 4,500 miles an hour.
[12:51] And he's eating 31,607 carats.
[12:55] Now, those kind of speeds...
[12:59] I don't know, that doesn't seem like enough calories quite to me, but...
[13:03] Well, he's got all that chocolate he's probably popping.
[13:06] I know.
[13:07] Where's the chocolate ounce counter?
[13:12] Oh, he's a diabetic for a long time.
[13:18] He needs to be careful in the COVID, really.
[13:21] They say diabetes is high risk.
[13:24] And I'll say...
[13:25] You stay safe Easter Bunny.
[13:27] You don't eat your own supply, right?
[13:29] You don't eat your own supply.
[13:32] You're not going to make money that way.
[13:34] No.
[13:36] Okay.
[13:37] So what I'm seeing so far is that the Easter Bunny was reportedly introduced to America
[13:44] by German immigrants who brought over stories of an egg-laying hare.
[13:51] Really?
[13:52] Decorations of eggs is believed to date back to at least the 13th century.
[14:01] The exact origins are unclear, but rabbits, known to be prolific per creators,
[14:07] are an ancient symbol of fertility and new life.
[14:12] The Easter Bunny first arrives in the 1700s.
[14:17] German immigrants in Pennsylvania transported their tradition of egg-laying hare
[14:22] called Osterhass.
[14:25] Osterhass?
[14:28] My boy.
[14:29] Children made nests in which this creature could lay its colored eggs.
[14:36] Did you know there was a pagan god of fertility called Eostra?
[14:43] No.
[14:44] Uh-uh.
[14:45] And there was there for a festival of Eostra, which I'm guessing is just Easter.
[14:51] They just ripped that name straight off.
[14:54] Really?
[14:56] Just Christians used all of their creativity on writing that book,
[15:01] had nothing left for bread.
[15:04] Oster.
[15:08] Yeah, that looks that sounds a lot like Easter.
[15:10] You're right.
[15:11] E-O-S-T-R-E.
[15:14] The hare was a popular motif in medieval church art.
[15:18] In ancient times, it was widely believed, as by Pliny, the elder Plutarch,
[15:23] Philostratus, an alien, that the hare was a hermaphrodite.
[15:29] The idea that a hare could reproduce without loss of virginity
[15:33] led to an association with the Virgin Mary.
[15:35] Really?
[15:36] With hares something...
[15:37] That is ironic.
[15:39] ...occurring in illuminated manuscripts
[15:42] and northern European paintings of the Virgin and the Christ child.
[15:47] Boy, they did not have a good understanding of animal behavior.
[15:52] That sounds nothing like a key party.
[15:56] I mean, come on, the oyster.
[16:00] Yeah.
[16:01] I mean, this story is so far fetched.
[16:02] This is probably a Finleyville key party.
[16:04] That's what I'm saying.
[16:08] I don't have any specifics here, but time has...
[16:11] Some identify the holiday with other types of animals
[16:14] like foxes or cuckoo birds.
[16:23] And when I click on foxes, I get a Wikipedia site in German.
[16:28] So I'm going to go with, that's probably them.
[16:32] I'm saying that the custom was first mentioned in...
[16:35] George Frank von Frankenau's...
[16:39] De owes pashke...
[16:42] Pash...
[16:43] How do you say that?
[16:44] Nailed it.
[16:45] Pashchalibus.
[16:47] Which is about Easter eggs.
[16:50] In 1682.
[16:54] In 1682.
[16:56] Referring to a German tradition of an Easter hare
[16:58] bringing Easter eggs for the children.
[17:01] So it's Germans.
[17:03] The Germans.
[17:07] Okay.
[17:08] Yeah.
[17:09] The Austra, apparently a venerable bed.
[17:18] Wasn't that your nickname in high school?
[17:24] He's an 8th century scholar,
[17:26] and his work, The Reckoning of Time,
[17:28] said that Easter stems from oyster,
[17:32] although there's no historical evidence
[17:36] to prove his point.
[17:39] I'm seeing that the hare was the sacred beast
[17:43] of Easter, oystra, whatever.
[17:47] A Saxon goddess of spring and of the dawn.
[17:51] Yeah.
[17:52] There's definitely, it seems like there's
[17:54] probably some sort of through line there, right?
[17:56] Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
[17:58] So it's both something that the pagans were into
[18:02] and it sort of trickled down through.
[18:05] Probably fell away and then the Germans.
[18:07] The Germans came up with their own thing.
[18:09] Yeah.
[18:10] And then American brandy got a hold of that bad boy.
[18:12] Yeah.
[18:13] Did you, I've got 1572 Germany.
[18:19] Do not worry if the Easter bunny escapes you.
[18:22] Should we miss his eggs, we will cook the nest.
[18:27] Wait, what?
[18:30] Yeah, that's the earliest reference to the Easter bunny.
[18:33] Eel threat.
[18:35] Yeah, that is the kind of Easter bunny that we have.
[18:39] But it is very German.
[18:41] It's very German.
[18:42] It's basically the parents saying like,
[18:44] if the Easter bunny doesn't bring you treats,
[18:46] then I'm going to burn the Easter bunny's house there.
[18:49] We're going to murder that dude.
[18:50] Get this thing done.
[18:54] Yeah.
[18:56] Easter is the second best selling candy holiday in America after Halloween.
[19:01] Okay.
[19:05] According to the National Confectioners Association,
[19:07] over 16 billion jelly beans are made in the U.S. each year,
[19:11] just for Easter.
[19:13] Mmm.
[19:14] Enough to fill a giant egg measuring 89 feet high and 60 feet wide.
[19:20] This for the U.S.?
[19:24] Yes, correct.
[19:28] I also anecdotally know that this is the biggest day
[19:34] for buying baby rabbits, Easter.
[19:40] People give their children bunnies on Easter.
[19:45] And I believe within the first week is the busiest time
[19:50] for rabbit rescues, the first week after Easter.
[19:54] And so if you have bought a bunny for your child
[20:00] and you're going to give it up, do so responsibly.
[20:06] Or just do some research on the Internet.
[20:09] Rabbits are really sweet animals and easy to take care of.
[20:12] So they probably will poop on your floor,
[20:17] but it's really easy to clean up.
[20:19] And they will eat your cords.
[20:21] They will eat your cords.
[20:22] You should rabbit-proof your house.
[20:24] That's cool.
[20:25] Nobody has cords in this day and age.
[20:27] It's fine.
[20:28] Everything's wireless.
[20:29] Everything's wireless.
[20:30] Dude, history.com has killed this thing.
[20:32] So decorating eggs for Easter is a tradition that dates back
[20:35] at least to the 13th century.
[20:37] The explanation is that eggs were formerly forbidden
[20:40] during Lent.
[20:42] Oh, that makes a lot of sense.
[20:45] It doesn't?
[20:46] So people can decorate the mark
[20:47] from the end of the period of penance and fasting.
[20:50] Yeah.
[20:51] The first Easter egg hunt, or Easter egg,
[20:54] White House Easter egg roll occurred in 1878.
[20:58] It's Rutherford B. Hayes.
[21:00] Okay.
[21:01] That needs to go on our list of weird facts about presidents.
[21:05] Yep.
[21:06] The event has no religious significance,
[21:08] although some people have considered egg rolling symbolic.
[21:11] This is a stretch.
[21:12] Symbolic of the stone blocking Jesus's tomb
[21:14] being rolled away.
[21:16] Sure.
[21:17] Quick update on the Easter bunny.
[21:19] Santiago Chile, 1.6 billion baskets delivered.
[21:25] Wow.
[21:26] Okay.
[21:27] So how many baskets has your dumb rabbit delivered, Coalson?
[21:34] I'm assuming zero.
[21:37] My rabbit probably pooped on the rug.
[21:39] That's probably a big accomplishment today.
[21:41] But it took a nap.
[21:42] Unlike the Easter bunny, gave COVID to no one.
[21:47] The Easter bunny is rampantly carrying COVID.
[21:50] Just real trouble.
[21:52] So I do have a question.
[21:53] So is the Easter bunny considered magic like Santa is?
[21:58] Or is it just like real fast?
[22:00] I mean, it's going 2,700 miles an hour.
[22:02] I'll go ahead and call that magic.
[22:03] Right.
[22:04] I know.
[22:05] But like when you're,
[22:06] when you're a kid and like they tell you the story,
[22:08] like is I never think of the Easter bunny as magical necessarily.
[22:12] Right.
[22:13] I never really thought of the Easter bunny as like something
[22:16] that came and delivered the basket.
[22:18] I didn't either.
[22:19] Oh, really?
[22:20] That's why I think the Easter bunny tracker is novel because I don't think
[22:24] of them like Santa Claus at all.
[22:25] Right.
[22:26] Yeah.
[22:27] Is that how it was in your house?
[22:29] Like you woke up in the morning and the Easter bunny had left me at
[22:33] Easter basket.
[22:34] Yeah.
[22:35] So now that you say that maybe.
[22:36] I'm taking your teeth.
[22:37] No.
[22:38] So my memory was I went to see some friends in West Virginia during Easter.
[22:45] My, my family and I visited a family and they had this big thing.
[22:51] The big story was the Easter bunny got sick one year and couldn't hit all
[22:57] the houses and asked his friend,
[23:01] the Easter duck to help them.
[23:05] And so when I, so,
[23:07] and I don't know if this is a version of the story because they went to the
[23:10] store to buy an Easter bunny stuffed animal and they were out and they
[23:15] just had a stuffed animal duck.
[23:17] But when I woke up,
[23:18] there was a stuffed duck in my basket and they told me this long story
[23:22] about how the Easter duck takes half of the world now and the Easter bunny
[23:26] takes the other half because they're buddies.
[23:31] Yeah.
[23:32] Because it was too much work to do the whole world by yourself.
[23:35] And so some houses have the Easter duck come by and that was and in
[23:39] West Virginia, you get the Easter duck in Annapolis.
[23:41] You get the Easter bunny.
[23:43] Yeah.
[23:44] So I still believe that.
[23:47] I still believe that to this day.
[23:49] There's all these different things and you can figure out what it is.
[23:52] You want to tell your kids that the tooth fairy is creepy.
[23:57] In my, so my day, we just had, we just had one.
[24:03] We just had room in our lives and the budget in our lives just for,
[24:07] one generic holiday mascot.
[24:10] They did everything.
[24:11] They left a present.
[24:12] They just, they just took all your teeth and then left one egg.
[24:16] And that was it.
[24:17] What did you call that?
[24:18] They left an egg.
[24:19] Real messed up day.
[24:22] Real messed up day.
[24:25] Oh no, we were.
[24:26] Some random day.
[24:28] You didn't know when it was coming.
[24:30] Yeah.
[24:31] No.
[24:33] I don't know.
[24:34] When you see it, usually it's an unholy territory.
[24:37] So.
[24:38] Yeah.