The Undegooglables
Better answers than Google can give you.

Apple PodcastsSpotifyYouTubeOvercastRSSWebsite

Episode 80 · February 13, 2021

Snack Sized

The hosts discuss the numbers behind praying mantis mating and learn that sexual cannibalism is real but less common than people think.

“Might as well have another. My wife's gonna bite my head off anyway.” (06:20)

Questions

How does praying mantis reproduction work given that the female may eat the male? (00:37)

Our guess
Large clutches of eggs, possibly skewed toward males, with cannibalism not happening every time.
Reveal the answer
The answer
Cannibalism occurs in about 25% of encounters and is mostly seen in captivity, driven largely by hunger. Cannibalistic females laid more eggs (about 88 vs. 37 in one study). An egg case hatches 100-200 mantises, of which only about a third reach maturity.
Verdict right

Listen to the episode

Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:00] Coalson, it is time for some under Googables, which you got for us this week? How can we help you?
[00:13] Oh, we do under Googables. That was the play of super excited told us we had to
[00:21] we signed up for it. In the end, it's going to be better and more true than Google can give you.
[00:28] So this is another one that I had from the summer, and I've just held on to without Googling. This
[00:37] might be a math question or get us back into, you know, evolutionary stuff. But basically, there used
[00:47] to be a for about a week, there was a praying mantis that lived on my screen, and just kind of
[00:54] wandered around the screen and I guess was eating stuff, you know, and every night you go out and
[01:00] just a little bit further down the screen or whatever. They're not real fast moving. And
[01:05] apparently, we had some sort of level of food for him or her there. But it got me thinking.
[01:13] So the thing with praying mantis is right is that during sex, the female bites the
[01:19] male's head off. Is that correct? I think after like after. Okay, sure. Like at the end of the
[01:26] process. Okay, sure. Okay, well, when I was thinking about that, as far as efficiency, I was thinking
[01:34] about how like in a lot of other, you know, animals, so you know, like sort of bowls and
[01:41] cows or whatever, wherever, like you basically have the male is just going to go around and
[01:45] just impregnate as many things as possible to kind of keep the species alive, right? Whereas
[01:50] the male kind of has one chance. Right? So I was wondering what the birthing patterns were for
[02:00] praying mantises, whether they have like a huge litter, whether there are more males produced
[02:05] than females, whether it's all sort of randomized, or how does this make sense numbers wise and
[02:10] evolutionarily wise? That was my question. Okay, that's a good question. I know nothing
[02:20] about praying mantises. So yeah, I don't know any like, I guess I don't know any other species that
[02:25] do that that I can think of. You know, that you murder your partner at the end of.
[02:34] Yeah, because basically that you're just you've only got one shot, essentially, right? So like,
[02:38] this is you're not going to go around and have lots of other.
[02:45] Right. I mean, it seems like an extreme choice, or extreme example of sexual selection by females,
[02:53] which is not uncommon in the animal kingdom. Very matriarchal society, praying mantises.
[02:59] Okay, sure. Without a doubt.
[03:01] Well, and many other species, right, is, you know, like a bunch of different bird species,
[03:06] like the males have these crazy plumages and all that stuff, because females are selecting
[03:11] to have sex with them. Right. And so we're not. Yeah, we're not. Right.
[03:17] They have the choices. And in this case, the, I suppose the competitive advantage,
[03:24] right from the female's perspective is if she finds a good male that has the right
[03:28] characteristics, then she wants her offspring and only her offspring to inherit that
[03:37] good genetics, right?
[03:39] The other part of that is that in a low population density species,
[03:47] like you said, they're not fast movers, right? They are direct competition with each other for
[03:50] food on some level, right? So now, whatever he might have eaten can go to the baby.
[03:57] The baby mantis.
[03:59] That's right. Right. Well, and are they just having, I mean, they've got to be having more
[04:03] than one. Otherwise, I feel like this, but this, the whole population just falls apart,
[04:07] right? Like that you can't numbers game, right?
[04:09] Like, yeah, well, I'm assuming that mantises are like many other insects that they lay eggs
[04:16] and then they like a bunch of eggs, like a bunch of eggs. Okay.
[04:21] Like hundreds or thousands more.
[04:23] Exactly. Yeah. And then as far as sort of the distribution of sexual
[04:33] or gender, I guess, not gender, that's not the right.
[04:36] Sex is amongst the progeny.
[04:42] Yeah. Does it make sense for it to be skewed towards males in that context? I would think so.
[04:48] Yeah, you'd do more.
[04:49] Because otherwise, I mean, sort of the way I was thinking about it sort of like a
[04:54] queen bee, right? Or something like that. Like the more people that you have able
[05:02] to impregnate you, the better for that society, right? If you're if the males only get one shot.
[05:09] I suspect that in this sort of scenario, like, I've definitely heard this. I don't know that it's
[05:14] actually true. Right? Did Oh, the biting of the head thing. Yeah, I don't actually.
[05:20] But moving from that assumption, I mean, you would assume in order for the species to
[05:26] maximize, then you have to have insemination rates approaching 100%. Right? Like you just
[05:30] have to have a really high success rate. Yeah, timing was bad. And all of a sudden you're like,
[05:37] well, that guy's dead. Just move on to the next guy. That guy was great. Now he's dead.
[05:48] I waited so long to find the right guy. Yeah.
[05:53] I'm assuming that the if the females are having this much
[05:57] influence over mate choice and selection, that they would only choose to mate when they were,
[06:06] you know, ready to have offspring, right? Sure. This is when biology sort of mature
[06:13] that that's how I do it. Like a good point in their life when they're like financially stable.
[06:17] That's right. Yeah. They've gone through their hippy face.
[06:20] If you don't want to be bringing that baby brain in a backpack, you know, around Europe.
[06:32] This also reminds me of one of my favorite memes. I don't know if you've ever seen this. It's a
[06:36] there's a praying mantis with a with a beer. And he goes, might as well have another. My
[06:41] wife's gonna bite my head off anyway. Nice. Pretty good. Pretty good.
[06:47] I love those praying mantis memes, don't you? Just all we get on Slack these days.
[06:58] So we decide enough that we think that maybe the litter is very large with lots of eggs and it
[07:07] might skew towards male. That's my that's that makes sense to me. That's what I would think.
[07:15] And I also think that I agree with Harper that the the idea that mantises always kill their mates
[07:23] is overstated. Okay, so it's not just every time. So it's like maybe, right? Like I definitely don't
[07:31] want this guy impregnating anybody else. It doesn't happen every time. Would you agree that
[07:37] there's at least an attempted murder? Because maybe he's hip to what's going on. Yeah. And he's
[07:45] the French do call the mail regards on the Liberty more. Right. So it's a little every, you know,
[07:51] it's a little bit every day. I mean, maybe he's like, Oh, you know what, I got to go to the bathroom.
[07:58] I'll be right back. He don't come back. Sure. I mean, but I mean, I guess this goes to like,
[08:04] did your dad ever have a chance to tell you that this was an issue? Like maybe you just don't
[08:08] know like you're walking into a trap every time. Right. You didn't have a dad to tell you that
[08:13] you're going to get eaten. That's a good point. Yeah. Nobody's warning you about this stuff.
[08:19] And it sounds like the lack of father figures in the praying mantis community is really
[08:24] an undertold story. Yes. Well, and, and also I think probably some issue with their judicial
[08:31] system, like all these attempted murders and murders going, you know, unpunished. Well,
[08:39] I mean, who do you think sitting on the bench there? It's not the mailman. Tell you that.
[08:47] Okay. Let's see. See the cannibalism of the praying mantis is however, is mostly observed in mantises
[08:54] that are held in captivity. If he knows initially bite off the heads of their male partners before
[09:00] they actually start the process of mating. Oh, I was, I was hoping that that was not the
[09:07] case. You are not correct. Praying mantises are real weird. It's just like, uh, yeah,
[09:13] you're going to come anyway. It is still, these are repeated fella. Yeah. These are
[09:19] sexual predators. Okay. Uh, I'm reading that in praying mantises around 25% of all sexual
[09:25] encounters results in the death of the male. 70%. Okay. It is 25%. Oh, 25. Okay. Yeah. Oh,
[09:33] well that's not that bad. The female typically begins by biting off their partner's head,
[09:40] which apparently increases the vigorous sexual movement when their heads have been
[09:45] bitten off. Okay. Okay. I feel like some counseling might be able to fix this.
[09:53] Yeah. I like it better without your head on. Sorry. That's like, well, let's talk about this. Uh,
[10:00] in the actual geographic is saying maybe if the female is starving or if the male
[10:04] irritates her, she may engage in that behavior, but they don't always do it.
[10:10] So bring some food and, you know, don't be annoying. Yep. In the wild, the mating and
[10:17] reproduction of manages begins with courtship, wherein the male dances in front of the female.
[10:24] And those cannibalistic females are much more productive. They produce about 88 eggs,
[10:28] whereas those who didn't eat their partners produced about 37. Whoa. That's one study.
[10:35] Yeah. Oh my. In some cases, male praying mantis has actually comprised a significant
[10:41] portion, if not a majority of a female's diet during breeding. Oh, wow.
[10:48] These insects may eat other animals as well, including birds.
[10:55] Praying mantis are eating birds? Apparently yes. On every continent except Antarctica.
[11:02] And oh yeah, they do. Oh, there's some pictures that I can't see now.
[11:07] But apparently they eat their prey head first. Are the males smaller than the females? Yes.
[11:15] Substantially. They're, they're, they're snack size.
[11:22] Maybe that's, uh, there's, there's one school thought that it's strictly driven by hunger.
[11:28] One study showed that well-nourished female mantises refrained from cannibalism,
[11:32] while those deprived of food ate any male in sight.
[11:41] They said that she refrained from doing this. It was like, it was a bad idea.
[11:47] Oh, would you, would you mind refraining from doing that? Eating.
[11:54] Yeah. So there's, yeah.
[11:55] I mean, uh, the males have an evolutionary benefit because they pass genes on, I guess.
[12:03] For example, the sex act may be protracted when the female gets caught up in chewing her partner,
[12:10] which could increase the odds that he will fertilize her eggs.
[12:17] This, this has led to some very funny phraseology. This, uh, post-coital chomping
[12:23] cases that there's not words that I thought I was going to.
[12:27] Do we have like, we've probably got about 20 or 30, uh, different, uh, show titles we could.
[12:38] So it looks like an egg case will hatch between a hundred and 200 tiny mantises.
[12:46] Okay. Uh, but it looks like only about a third of them will reach maturity. Is that,
[12:53] is that mean that because they're being eaten or no, probably maturity means sexually, uh,
[12:59] maturity, right? I mean, they're dying. Yeah.
[13:03] Insects don't before they can procreate. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Insects don't have a super
[13:10] high survival rate. I don't think it's a numbers game. It's a strength in numbers.
[13:15] So sexual cannibalism is also common in many families of spiders and scorpions
[13:21] and has important effects on population size, sex ratio, and even persistence.
[13:26] Well, I'm not looking up that phrase. Yeah, I could go back.
[13:31] Looks like a life cycle of praying mantis is about six months to a year.
[13:38] Wow. It seems slow for an insect.
[13:42] There. Did we, uh, did we answer all your questions?
[13:45] Yeah. No, that was amazing. Nice work team.
[13:48] Yeah. We didn't do too bad for something. We knew nothing.
[13:51] Nothing about wild speculation.
[13:56] Yeah. And they're, that is interesting. I think that the, like, uh, more genetic material is
[14:03] passed if they're eaten. That's interesting. I don't know why that would be, but, uh,
[14:10] I think it's outside of the scope of this, but, uh, for further reading, check your local Google.
[14:17] Okay. So are you, uh, promoting sexual cannibalism? Is that what you're promoting?
[14:23] No. Okay. No. Well, for our praying mantis listeners, uh, you do you.
[14:37] But for our male praying mantis listeners, well, you've been warned.
[14:41] Run. Yeah. Run. Yeah. Run. Get the heck out of here. Unless you're looking,
[14:48] if you want to pass, when you want to pass on your, your genetic material.
[14:51] When your, when your mom tells you that, uh, dad left for cigarettes and never came back,
[14:55] she's lying. All right. You're going to smoke with no head.
[15:02] Oh, there are a lot of, uh, title options, but that's pretty good.