The Undegooglables
Better answers than Google can give you.

Apple PodcastsSpotifyYouTubeOvercastRSSWebsite

Episode 60 · September 26, 2020

Yellow Makes You Hungry

The hosts try to work out why red means stop and green means go, working through lighthouses, ships, cars and finally railroads.

“We forgot about the damn railroad.” (11:44)

Questions

Why is red universally stop and green universally go? (00:35)

Our guess
Red came first, tied to danger, blood or nautical lights, and green was chosen as the contrasting color after cars arrived.
Reveal the answer
The answer
The scheme comes from railroads, which have used it since the 1830s: red for stop because it signaled danger, white for go and green for caution. After a 1914 accident when a red lens fell out and white showed, green became "go". Automatic signals followed in the late 1920s.
Verdict partly

Listen to the episode

Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:00] Last thing on the plate, Mr. Coalson, I think we have an under-googlable.
[00:05] We do under-googlables.
[00:13] That was the play of it.
[00:14] Super excited.
[00:15] You told us we had to, sir.
[00:17] You said we signed up for it.
[00:23] In the end, it's going to be better and more true than Google can give you.
[00:27] We do.
[00:28] I was thinking about this on my drive home tonight.
[00:35] Why is red universally stop and green universally go?
[00:42] Now let me start by saying to super fan of the show and art professor,
[00:51] Jennifer Drinkwater, that I know that red and green are contrasting colors.
[00:56] And so I assume that one of these decisions was made either stop is red or green is go.
[01:04] And then the other one became to mean the opposite.
[01:09] But I don't know which one came first and when it came about.
[01:13] Sure.
[01:14] So I don't feel like the I feel like this goes back further than the psychology of color.
[01:22] You know, like they they say that yellow makes you hungry and light green makes you smart or something.
[01:29] And light blue makes you sleepy.
[01:31] I don't know.
[01:31] They've done all these studies and they paint rooms to make you feel different ways.
[01:37] And I assume that this that this did not come from that.
[01:41] I feel like this predates that.
[01:45] That's a safe bet.
[01:46] Yes.
[01:49] So, you know, when did somebody come up with a not stop light or stop sign?
[01:55] Right.
[01:57] And this was was in would this be the invention of cars?
[02:02] Did stop signs exist in different forms before cars showed up?
[02:08] Yeah.
[02:08] These are the questions I have.
[02:12] Definitely.
[02:12] So the I think the first real stop sign would probably be a lighthouse.
[02:18] Okay.
[02:20] But that wasn't red.
[02:22] You like crap on fire.
[02:24] That's right.
[02:26] Fair enough.
[02:27] All right.
[02:28] Yeah.
[02:28] So you think that's where it comes from?
[02:30] You think it's it's it's don't hit this rock because we're going to we're
[02:33] going to light this fire and it's red because you sort of think of it as orange
[02:36] really a fire maybe or blue or white depending on how far away you are from
[02:41] it or whatever or how hot it's running.
[02:45] Well, I'm not thinking about electric driven White House is I'm thinking
[02:49] about like Athenian.
[02:50] No, no, I know.
[02:51] But what I'm saying is a fire itself like depending on how hot it's
[02:54] burning can be different colors, right?
[02:57] I usually think of it as white or orange and not red.
[03:01] Sure.
[03:04] Okay, that's all that was my own.
[03:07] I'm not trying to shoot your idea down right away, but I'm shooting your idea
[03:10] down right away.
[03:11] Yeah, I mean, I think it's definitely nautical.
[03:14] Okay, I mean to this to this day like port and starboard are marked by
[03:20] red and green, right?
[03:21] So if you've got boat running lights, I believe that
[03:26] I was confused port and starboard, but believe starboard is red and
[03:34] port is great, but that don't import would be going forward.
[03:39] I know it's right and left basically, right?
[03:41] So you keep clearly I've done a lot of sailing in my day.
[03:45] Yeah.
[03:45] Yeah.
[03:46] No, it's been a few years for me to being you know, I just you
[03:50] know completely wealthy and never having to work.
[03:52] It's nice to just yacht for a living.
[03:55] Well, now if if if greens on right and Reds on left or vice versa,
[04:01] how do I know?
[04:01] So would I turn the boat to tell people to stop?
[04:04] I don't know.
[04:05] Well, so running lights on boats like you have bow basically your
[04:08] bow comes to a point, right?
[04:10] Right.
[04:11] And so on one side, there's a green light and one side, there's a
[04:14] red so you can tell which side of a boat you're looking at the
[04:16] dark, right, right?
[04:18] If it's coming if you can see both is coming right at you and
[04:20] you're in trouble.
[04:21] Okay, fair enough.
[04:23] Yeah, yeah, I like that.
[04:24] So let me see.
[04:25] So if you're going into port red, right return, right?
[04:28] So, okay, keep the red on your right when you're going back
[04:32] into port like that's a nautical thing.
[04:34] Okay, and I assume that the red came.
[04:38] I assume that the red came from lighthouses because those
[04:42] are like the first major points of navigation and I think
[04:45] that you're right.
[04:46] I think that that green is the contrast, right?
[04:50] So what's the opposite color of red because right be the
[04:53] most opposite visually, right?
[04:58] And also you don't want, you know, you need a brighter color
[05:01] than like blue, right?
[05:03] Right.
[05:04] You need navigable things at night.
[05:07] Sure.
[05:08] So okay, but at this point you're so these light runners
[05:12] on ships.
[05:12] So at what point did we have like oil lamps with red covers
[05:18] on them and green covers on them?
[05:20] Like did they have filaments for these things?
[05:22] Like how far back can we go with the actual coloring of light
[05:27] on this stuff on the boats?
[05:29] You see what I'm saying?
[05:31] I mean, that's a good question.
[05:33] I think I think that probably came around with electricity.
[05:35] I mean, I just don't think that there's enough water traffic
[05:38] to merit such a complex system.
[05:40] I mean, I think that I would have thought anyway that most
[05:45] of the time.
[05:46] Well, I don't know because you think about like navies used
[05:49] to go in formation, right?
[05:52] Like, you know, you got the Spanish Armada, right?
[05:55] Right.
[05:56] If you're traveling at night.
[05:59] How do you know where you are relative to other ships?
[06:01] I just assumed oil lamps.
[06:05] And maybe that's enough, right?
[06:07] Maybe that is enough.
[06:08] Yeah.
[06:10] Again, I guess my point is I don't really think of fire
[06:14] as red.
[06:16] Like if I have fire in a lighthouse, I don't just see
[06:20] that as red.
[06:21] I see that as as light as white or orange or yellow.
[06:29] Now coals, I think of as red.
[06:31] But and maybe maybe that's where it comes from.
[06:34] Like red means hot.
[06:35] Don't touch it.
[06:37] You know, strike why the iron is hot.
[06:39] I don't know.
[06:41] That's a different saying.
[06:43] But you know, I mean, I think there's something to that.
[06:46] I think idiomatically.
[06:47] There's always, you know.
[06:51] We associate red, not just with stop of danger.
[06:56] Yeah.
[06:57] And that may pre, I mean, I'm sure that that predates stop signs.
[07:02] Red peppers are hotter than green peppers.
[07:04] I don't know.
[07:10] Okay, so.
[07:15] I guess I'm curious about the evolution of how let's say
[07:19] it is nautical how that got transferred to how someone was
[07:24] like, yeah, universally, let's just do this.
[07:26] Because like, you know, if you're in Europe, the stop signs
[07:30] are red as well, you know, like, it's not just American
[07:35] stop signs.
[07:37] Right.
[07:38] I mean, the question at that point becomes who were the
[07:42] first people to start doing signage and lights.
[07:45] And I suspect that was America.
[07:47] Yeah, we had Thomas Edison.
[07:50] Well, not only Thomas Edison, but also Henry Ford, right?
[07:54] Yeah, we had enough traffic, right to warrant because none
[07:58] of this stuff matters if there's nothing to hit, right?
[08:00] And so you have other vehicles that there's risk of collision.
[08:04] These things aren't necessarily that important.
[08:06] Sure.
[08:06] If you're just riding around in the forest on a horse,
[08:09] you know, like whatever, you're probably good.
[08:11] Right.
[08:14] To your point about the psychological thing, I think
[08:17] there is something sort of ominous about red.
[08:21] Red is the color of blood, for instance.
[08:23] Okay, okay.
[08:25] And and so there may be something that underlies it
[08:28] that like red is red has been danger.
[08:32] For as long as people bled.
[08:35] Yeah, right.
[08:36] I mean, you know, if you were going to write a really
[08:38] ominous letter to someone like a true threat back in the
[08:41] day, you probably wrote in their blood.
[08:43] Right, sure.
[08:44] Right.
[08:45] Or in someone's blood.
[08:46] Like that's super scary.
[08:47] That happens in, you know, Dracula movies.
[08:49] I don't know that ever happened in real life, but I
[08:51] assume it has.
[08:52] Well, and green is, is, you know, plant life and growth.
[08:57] Yeah, it's earthy, right?
[08:58] Yeah, yeah, yeah, less scary.
[09:02] Mm-hmm.
[09:04] So I probably is an aspect of it to that.
[09:07] Are you going?
[09:11] We're not putting filaments on on lamps on ships.
[09:14] So it's got to be later than that, right?
[09:19] Oil lamps.
[09:20] It's got to be later than oil lamps.
[09:23] You're saying it's the invention of the motor vehicle
[09:28] where they decide.
[09:28] So I mean for lights clearly, but that doesn't mean
[09:32] that it's not drawn from that.
[09:34] At least the red part isn't drawn from, you know, nautical
[09:38] stuff. You also have to navigate into a port in the dark
[09:42] without sat right without sat nav, right?
[09:45] So they clearly must have had some, the only system
[09:49] that they could have had was lighting.
[09:51] Right.
[09:52] So I mean, I'd be surprised if, you know, the Athenians
[09:55] and Greeks and all those dudes didn't have some sort
[09:59] of lighting system to lead people home.
[10:02] Yeah.
[10:04] And, and also even in airplanes now.
[10:09] So airplanes do use red and white.
[10:16] Red over white all right, white over red, you're dead.
[10:19] So when you're coming in for a landing, there's landing
[10:23] lights that you align for your, for your glide path.
[10:28] And when those are aligned correctly, like I said, red
[10:31] over white is the way that you want it.
[10:35] So clearly aviation has used the same red, but has gone
[10:41] away from the green.
[10:43] Which is interesting.
[10:44] Yeah.
[10:45] But I think that that buttresses the idea that the red
[10:47] came first and the green just kind of grew out.
[10:49] Yes.
[10:49] Yes.
[10:50] And the green is just the contrasting color.
[10:52] Yeah, and I think that what we've kind of decided red
[10:55] is blood, red is danger, red is hot coals.
[10:58] And yeah, it's like, you know, it's the color that
[11:01] you can make, right?
[11:03] Like orange, like I agree, like fire tends to be orange,
[11:07] but red, if you can make any color that you want, is
[11:10] a better color, brighter.
[11:12] Yeah, right.
[11:15] Okay, so I'm gonna say nautical red is ancient and
[11:18] stoplights such as they are were and signs for that
[11:23] matter are created in the US sometime after Henry Ford.
[11:27] Oh, hey, look at this.
[11:28] The first thing that I found the origin of the green,
[11:30] yellow and red color scheme for traffic lights.
[11:33] Nice.
[11:37] While some of the specifics have been lost to history,
[11:39] it is known that this color scheme derives from a
[11:41] system used by the railroad industry since the 1830s.
[11:44] We forgot about the damn railroad.
[11:46] We did.
[11:46] They're useful.
[11:47] Idiots.
[11:49] This is why we need Jason and Joey on the show right here.
[11:53] Of course, it's the railroads.
[11:55] They chose red as the color for stop.
[11:57] It is thought because red is for centuries been used
[11:59] to indicate danger.
[12:01] Okay.
[12:02] For the other colors, they chose white as the color
[12:04] for go green is the color for caution.
[12:06] The choice of a white light for go turned out to
[12:09] cause a lot of problems.
[12:12] Okay, I can see that.
[12:14] In an incident in 1914, a red lens fell out of
[12:17] its holder leaving the white light behind it exposed.
[12:21] Yeah.
[12:22] It's ended with a train running a stop signal and
[12:24] crashing into another train.
[12:25] Thus the world decided to change it.
[12:27] So the green meant go.
[12:29] Yep.
[12:33] In the late 1920s, several automatic signals were
[12:36] invested and invented.
[12:37] So we were pretty close on when we got automatic signaling.
[12:42] I see in this thing about the guy who tried to
[12:46] stop a train with his red shirt.
[12:49] That seems anecdotal.
[12:54] Also red is the easiest color to see by the human eye.
[12:58] Right.
[12:58] That's helpful.
[13:02] I do know a fun fact and I wish I knew which direction
[13:06] was I guess I do.
[13:07] I think it's red is on the left.
[13:11] If it's a sideways stoplight.
[13:15] Yellow in the middle and green on the right.
[13:18] But it always has to be the same for colorblind people.
[13:23] They can't just like switch it the other way.
[13:25] Right.
[13:27] So semaphore.
[13:31] You know that flag thing they do on ships?
[13:34] Comes from the ancient Greek word sema meaning sign
[13:37] of fours meaning bearer or bearing.
[13:38] So essentially semaphore translates to sign bearer.
[13:40] That's interesting.
[13:41] So maybe they were using flags back then.
[13:45] Okay, railroad semaphore.
[13:48] So I guess okay, so they're using this as so semaphore.
[13:52] It's not only the flag thing, but it's also the light system.
[13:55] So the row the railroad semaphore system was originally patented
[13:59] by Joseph James Stevens in the 1840s.
[14:03] And in the US and some other countries modern traffic signals
[14:07] are either 8 or 12 inches in diameter.
[14:09] It must be visible in every kind of weather and lighting condition.
[14:12] Yeah, it's important.
[14:13] I do like the idea that you know, we were we were going
[14:16] with lights and I was worried about filaments over, you know,
[14:20] oil lamps.
[14:21] But yeah, why not just have flags?
[14:24] Do whatever you want, right?
[14:25] Yeah, I mean nighttime is the problem, right?
[14:30] Okay, so I guess that's true on to Googleable.
[14:35] We'll do a little bit more research.
[14:37] See if we can find you a more complete answer and we'll
[14:40] link in and show notes if we can if not then just know red
[14:45] means stop and drive safely.
[14:46] Yeah, if you've got a if you got an answer there, go ahead
[14:49] and hit us up on the well, you know how to contact us or
[14:54] Harper does at least.
[14:55] Yeah, you can you can contact us at under beatables on
[14:59] Twitter Facebook.com slash the under beatables or the
[15:03] under beatables.com.
[15:05] And if you like the show, please do review us wherever
[15:08] you're listening to the show.
[15:10] Go ahead and lie.
[15:11] Give us five stars.
[15:13] We won't tell.
[15:16] And singing us out this week in true Pacer's form.
[15:19] For a once and always coach Bobby Sook Leonard now in
[15:22] the Hall of Fame.
[15:25] Turn out the lights the parties over.
[15:40] I found this really interesting site.
[15:41] That's giving me the history of stoplights.
[15:44] It's very exciting.
[15:45] I mean it is interesting, right?
[15:47] Yeah, apparently there was a street crossing signals that
[15:51] weren't lit up.
[15:51] They were just signs.
[15:52] They're different colors.
[15:56] That's kind of fun.
[15:58] Yeah.
[16:00] The first automated signs of Chicago in 1910.
[16:06] Oh, wow.
[16:06] They didn't light up.
[16:07] They just were indicators of stop and proceed.
[16:10] Wait, you said they were automated though.
[16:13] Yeah, they weren't lights.
[16:17] They were just they were just little arms.
[16:20] Like they chose on the how were they how were they
[16:23] automated.
[16:24] There's a picture of it and it's like this thing and
[16:26] they've got little arms and like I guess they went up
[16:29] and right.
[16:29] But what's the automation part?
[16:33] Some sort of some form of electricity.
[16:37] I'm concerned that our robot robot overlords have been
[16:39] here a lot longer than I was thinking.
[16:44] I think it works on some form of electricity.
[16:49] Or the wind maybe.
[16:52] You're right.
[16:53] Yes.
[16:55] Whoever gets to go is predicated upon.
[16:57] Downwinds.
[17:00] Downwind goes first.