Episode 44 · June 6, 2020
Smarty Pantsedness
The hosts figure out the origins of "pipe dream" and "hair of the dog", with a detour through snowmen and Super Mario.
“The dark ages were a weird time, man.” (18:57)
Questions
Where does the phrase "pipe dream" come from? (00:30)
Our guess
An opium pipe, from opium dens in the 1800s.
An opium pipe, from opium dens in the 1800s.
Reveal the answer
The answer
From opium pipes, via the English literati of the 18th and 19th centuries; it appears in US newspapers in the 1890s.
From opium pipes, via the English literati of the 18th and 19th centuries; it appears in US newspapers in the 1890s.
Verdict right
Where does the phrase "hair of the dog" come from? (09:32)
Our guess
A drink to cure a hangover, perhaps from an ancient Mesopotamian or medieval remedy or from revenge.
A drink to cure a hangover, perhaps from an ancient Mesopotamian or medieval remedy or from revenge.
Reveal the answer
The answer
It originally referred to treating a rabid dog bite by putting hair from the dog in the wound. The earliest known hangover reference is in ancient Ugarit (mid-to-late second millennium BC), and the first English drinking reference is in John Heywood's 1546 text. Many cultures have a version.
It originally referred to treating a rabid dog bite by putting hair from the dog in the wound. The earliest known hangover reference is in ancient Ugarit (mid-to-late second millennium BC), and the first English drinking reference is in John Heywood's 1546 text. Many cultures have a version.
Verdict partly
Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:00] We got some under Googles this week under Google's that was the play of super excited told us we had to [00:14] this. So we said we signed up for it. [00:20] In the end, it's going to be better and more true than Google can give you. [00:26] First one, I ran across something I want to do on here. [00:30] Coalson, I pray and do what you need to do, buddy. [00:33] Can I pray this for me? [00:34] Hey, you've got you've got something you need us to answer. [00:37] We are here for you, buddy. [00:39] Good, because you know how it is, you know, at home and I want to know something, but I'm too [00:45] lazy to ask Siri or Alexa or just type it into. [00:50] And I was like, I got I got smart friends. [00:52] Why don't you just wait a week? [00:54] Right. [00:54] Let me just wait a week. [00:56] Ask my friends. [00:58] So I had always wondered where the phrase pipe dream comes from. [01:06] Do you guys have any any guesses as to where this comes from? [01:11] It's a pipe dream. [01:13] So meaning like it's unattainable. [01:15] You know, it's you know, you're never going to get this dream, but somehow different than a [01:23] regular dream, like even more preposterous than a regular dream. [01:27] Yeah, right. [01:28] More preposterous. [01:31] I like that. [01:34] Going with the Super Mario Brothers used to go down in those little tubes. [01:38] That's a pipe dream. [01:40] So it's sort of like a psychedelic mushroom dream when you go down a pipe. [01:46] Or does it along those lines, could it come from an opium pipe? [01:51] You know, that's a pipe way better than what I had. [01:55] I hadn't. [01:56] What did you have? [01:56] Well, I was thinking it was like drilling for oil. [02:00] They were just searching for oil with a pipe like the like we want to. [02:05] OK, sure. [02:06] So you're just hoping to get something that wasn't going to happen, really. [02:10] But I guess it would be a drill, not a pipe. [02:12] So yours is way better. [02:14] I don't know how they looked for oil back in the day, how they prospect that it [02:18] could have easily been a paddling rod or. [02:21] Yeah, yeah. [02:23] Just like jamming a pipe down there and hoping something. [02:25] Yeah, exactly. [02:27] Shut up. [02:28] That was what I was thinking. [02:30] But I like I like opium pipe dream. [02:32] That's good. [02:32] That's probably closer. [02:37] What else could it be, though? [02:38] I mean, the other pipes I can think of are like in, you know, skateboard. [02:43] You have the half pipe and whatnot. [02:45] Yeah, I feel like this goes back further than skateboarding. [02:48] Probably. [02:49] Yeah. [02:49] Yeah. [02:50] You don't think this is like Tony Hawk? [02:51] No, I don't think he came up with the pipe dream. [02:55] He does have an impressive resume. [02:57] Yeah, yeah, sure does. [03:00] Yeah. [03:00] There was that documentary that came out at the same time as hoop [03:03] dreams called pipe dreams kid in the inner city in the X games. [03:10] Yeah, it was powerful stuff. [03:13] Yep. [03:16] Uh, I don't know. [03:17] I can't think of any, I mean, so when do you think it was then, uh, Harper? [03:22] Well, before skateboarding. [03:24] So before the seventies, I guess. [03:28] But going back pretty far, huh? [03:30] Pre seventies. [03:31] Okay. [03:33] We're thinking, uh, falconry. [03:35] Does it, maybe this goes back to falconry. [03:37] You would train a falcon to go get a pipe in the woods. [03:43] Maybe. [03:43] I feel like if you have a falcon and you're participating in falconry, [03:48] uh, all your dreams already came true. [03:51] You've got a lot of leisure time. [03:53] What about, uh, the, what about frosty? [03:56] The snowman had a corn cob pipe and kind of any wish to stay alive to be a lot. [04:04] Yeah. [04:04] Yeah. [04:05] Yeah. [04:06] Didn't that work though? [04:07] No, the corn cob pipe was where all the dreams came from, right? [04:12] Or all the wishes came from. [04:14] So really all you're doing is saying that, uh, we should put him in jail. [04:21] Well, I was wondering, whenever that cartoon came out, it might've been [04:24] worth it. [04:24] No, no, no, no. [04:25] Harper, he's white. [04:26] He is very white. [04:29] If he's a drug dealer, I think we need to consider just the death penalty. [04:32] Isn't that how it works? [04:33] I think snowman is code for like Coke, right? [04:36] Like, yeah, right. [04:40] This guy's like some kind of kingpin, but he realized this before now. [04:44] I think it's crack of its pipe though. [04:49] No, I think you can, you could, uh, [04:53] smoke cocaine out of a pipe. [04:55] It's called crack. [04:56] I think it's the crack is a different form. [05:00] It's just a version of Coke, right? [05:03] So that you can smoke it, I think. [05:05] Yeah. [05:05] Oh, I see. [05:08] So now that we know this much about drugs, [05:14] I would like to say that if, if, if it is the opium pipe, where would that [05:18] put us timeline wise, and if it is the oil pipe, where would that put us [05:24] time wise, and if it is the Mario brothers, where would that put us time wise? [05:29] Well, let's see, Mario brothers would put us in the eighties. [05:31] So that's an escape thing. [05:35] Did you guys know that the Nintendo corporation was founded in like 1886 [05:39] or something like that? [05:40] Yeah. [05:41] It was like a car, uh, playing card game or company. [05:45] It's not that, um, so, uh, regardless, that was a sidebar. [05:51] So, uh, opium, when we're opium dens, like super. [05:55] 1800s in 18 hundreds. [05:57] It's one of the sampling. [05:59] Teen. [06:01] My. [06:05] What's up? [06:06] What's up FBI? [06:07] We'll be there. [06:09] It was a joke. [06:10] FBI just kid homeland. [06:12] Well, I spent opium dens were quite popular in Asia a long time ago. [06:20] They became populated popular in London. [06:23] Yes. [06:24] In the 1800s. [06:25] But that requires quite a lot of yeah. [06:29] Opium trade. [06:31] Right. [06:33] So I suspect that opium dens were around earlier than that in other places. [06:37] Okay. [06:39] Fair enough. [06:40] Asian opium dens in 1500s, 16, they wouldn't have called them well, I don't know. [06:48] Maybe they would have had pipe dreams by then, but yeah, so we're thinking London. [06:53] Legend 19th century. [06:55] Yeah. [06:56] Yeah. [06:56] Is that play on pipe dreams? [07:00] I don't know. [07:02] Oh no. [07:02] No, I think you're overthinking it though. [07:04] Oh, definitely. [07:05] I wanted this exercise. [07:07] I can't even under Google, right? [07:10] So I'm going to, I'm going to go 1800s on, um, just stabbing pipes into the ground, [07:15] trying to find oil. [07:19] Coalson, I got good news for you. [07:22] Yeah. [07:22] I'm sorry. [07:23] Everyone else have good news for you. [07:24] Besides Coalson, this, uh, it actually is, uh, from opium pipe dreams. [07:31] This, uh, it actually is, uh, from opium pipes. [07:36] And this is the English literati of the 18th and 19th centuries as [07:42] where the, uh, the phrase came from. [07:46] There's some articles, um, in print Chicago daily tribune, its aerial [07:52] navigation has been regarded as a pipe dream for many good years. [07:57] And there's another one from 1895, uh, from the Fort Wayne Gazette. [08:01] Shout out for Wayne shout out. [08:04] There's a, we'll put the link in the show notes, but, uh, talking about some [08:10] things in Chicago, which are also a pipe dream. [08:16] So it is opium. [08:19] Yeah. [08:21] Jason, you were, you were on it. [08:23] Good work on that way to win that one. [08:25] Yeah. [08:27] I mean, we're all winners in this game. [08:29] Yep. [08:31] Coalson, you got another one for us this week. [08:35] Oh, that was actually the proper like underground music. [08:42] Yeah, good work. [08:42] That's when you go to the pipe and you're underground nailed that. [08:48] All those years of playing Nintendo finally paid off this moment. [08:54] My entire life to this moment. [09:00] Should we do another one or do we want to talk about depression? [09:03] Are we good? [09:07] Cause I can do another, I've got another undergoes. [09:10] If we can go five minutes on it, I think we'll be all right. [09:13] Okay. [09:15] And then we can just, uh, later. [09:18] So, uh, again, uh, listener entry for this week's new goals. [09:23] Uh, thank you, Joey, for yours. [09:25] I feel like we learned some stuff. [09:27] This one is, uh, the hair of the dog. [09:32] Hmm. [09:34] Which, which was not in the, uh, entry, but I believe the whole phrase [09:38] is the hair of the dog that bitcha. [09:42] As a bartender, my understanding of this phrase is, um, your [09:48] hungover, so have a drink. [09:51] There's a reason that bartenders have come up with morning cocktails [09:55] like mimosas and bloody Mary's. [09:57] Uh, because if you're hungover, it's going to make you feel better. [10:00] There's things called corpse revivers for the very same reason. [10:03] Right. [10:04] Um, but what is that? [10:07] It was a survivor. [10:08] It's a, it's a, it's a really cool. [10:11] Actually, I don't know what the, I only know the corpse [10:14] survivor number two, um, but it's, uh, uh, fortified white wine, [10:20] gin, lemon juice, and yeah, something else, but it's, it's, it's [10:25] basically something that's going to go down pretty easy. [10:29] Um, and sort of sounds like someone's going to come up pretty fast. [10:34] No, it's going to, it's going to make you, it's going to make you feel better. [10:37] It's not going to, it's not like taking a shot at something and it's [10:39] going to make you come back to life. [10:42] So, so I think that the, the actual full phrase is the best cure is [10:49] the hair of the dog that bit you. [10:50] Right. [10:51] Okay. [10:52] So yes, alcohol, but I think more generally it's about revenge. [10:57] Right. [10:59] I, I'm just speaking from, uh, bartending and alcoholism. [11:02] I don't know. [11:09] So you're saying that originally the, the, uh, phrase was for a jilted lover [11:16] or somebody who was, uh, wronged and they wanted to get revenge and the best cure [11:22] for that is go kick their ass to really go take, literally take [11:26] care off of the dog that they, yes. [11:30] Um, I like that. [11:33] This sounds Shakespearean to me in origin, perhaps Machiavellian. [11:40] Oh, yes. [11:44] I mean, dogs go back as early as humans, right? [11:48] I mean, we've domesticated dog as long as we've been alive as humans. [11:54] Right. [11:54] So, um, so that doesn't give us a timeframe at all. [11:59] No, that tells during history. [12:02] Yeah, that, that narrows it down to I thought humans were [12:06] embedded like 2000 years ago. [12:10] So we've got at least a 2000 year span. [12:12] Yeah. [12:12] Dogs were also invented. [12:14] Right. [12:15] Nope. [12:17] Uh, well, okay. [12:18] What did it do? [12:19] Um, I, I, again, I'm going to stick with alcohol here. [12:23] Um, and I'm going to go, uh, people have been drinking since the dawn of time. [12:27] So I'm going to go back to earliest civilizations. [12:32] I'm going to go back to, um, the, uh, Fertile Crescent, the Mesopotamians. [12:38] That's the tamions. [12:40] Yep. [12:40] Uh, dogs and wine. [12:43] This is where that came from. [12:44] You got, uh, goes ours is goes are involved in this. [12:49] The dog from a, uh, uh, Ghostbusters was that goes are, was that goes our, [12:55] or, uh, no, that's not right. [12:57] I think you're close. [12:58] It's something like that. [13:00] Yeah. [13:00] Goes are the lesser. [13:03] Hmm. [13:04] Not the elder. [13:06] Okay. [13:08] So it goes on. [13:08] The master. [13:11] Yeah, it's not right, but it's something. [13:13] It's right. [13:15] Okay. [13:16] Let's go with that. [13:17] Let's go with that. [13:18] A million nerds are screaming out there. [13:23] And they're Alexis flashing in the background, giving the answer. [13:29] One with you. [13:29] I think it's old. [13:31] I don't know if it's as old as like, I like, I like Harper's idea that it's [13:35] not, that it's been adapted to drinking from something else that it has. [13:41] You said, well, my point is the drinks on back is, is there, yeah, [13:46] I'm not disputing that question is everything about drinking or do we [13:49] make everything about drinking? [13:51] That's yes. [13:53] So how did we make dogs about drinking? [13:55] That's the question. [13:57] So, okay. [13:58] Why is it about dogs? [14:00] That's the real question, right? [14:01] I could just be like, it's, you know, drink the tequila that gave you [14:05] a hangover, right? [14:06] That could be the phrase. [14:07] It's more polite than being like, Oh, somebody wrong to you should [14:10] scalp that dude, right? [14:12] Cause you're more allowed to hurt dogs. [14:15] Oh, I see. [14:16] So you're really okay. [14:17] You think it's revenge and we're trying to make it sound less painful [14:21] by making about animals. [14:23] I'm thinking it's actually about animals. [14:27] Like an actual dog that they, [14:29] then why would the, why would they, [14:32] would the hair help you? [14:33] Yeah. [14:33] How would they help you? [14:34] That's my question. [14:36] Well, okay. [14:37] Um, uh, DNA and forensic, you know, [14:41] Oh my God. [14:43] What the fuck? [14:44] Yeah. [14:45] If I got the analysis, I could, I could track the dog, put it down. [14:52] You're talking about a phrase that came about at a time when people [14:56] thought that diseases were little goblins running around in your body. [15:01] So you thought that you're thinking is that you could CSI a dog in court. [15:08] That's my guess. [15:10] I'm going with go find the hair of the dog to pitch you so that you [15:14] can analyze it and get it put ultimately. [15:18] Get your retribution in a proper court of law. [15:28] I'm going to say like middle ages. [15:33] With all the dogs that were biting people. [15:35] Oh no. [15:36] With people that were stabbing each other. [15:37] That's it. [15:38] You're, you're, you're on the revenge tip. [15:41] Jason's feeling Mesopotamia. [15:43] He's feeling Romans. [15:44] No, I'm feeling, I'm wondering if it's like a, if it's like a witchcrafty [15:49] thing, because that's the thing you can make, uh, that's what you'd be [15:53] making the old witches brew out of, right? [15:55] Yeah, that's how the hair could help you. [15:57] I have the dog. [15:59] Yeah, that's a good point. [16:01] Dog with hair. [16:02] And then, and then so that this is great. [16:05] So you ferment it and, uh, put in a big jar behind the bar in [16:10] the middle edge, right? [16:12] No hurry to get your revenge on the dog. [16:17] Got to take your sweet time. [16:18] Revenge is a dish, best served cold, right? [16:20] That is cold, cold and fermented. [16:22] That just sure. [16:23] It's not, they're all, they're all coming together. [16:27] All of these idioms have the same stories. [16:29] All right, here we go team. [16:32] Um, the expression originally referred to a method of treatment of a rabid dog [16:36] bite by placing hair from the dog in the bite wound. [16:41] That doesn't seem like it would help in the. [16:44] Now you've got an infected dog. [16:47] 1898 in Scotland, it has a popular belief that a few hairs of the dog that [16:52] bit you applied to the wound will prevent evil consequences. [16:57] What was your evil consequences? [16:59] Be if you got bit by a dog, but you would get rabies and die. [17:04] That was the air does not help that. [17:06] Oh, okay. [17:07] The earliest known reference to the phrase hair of the dog in connection [17:10] with drunkenness is found in a text from ancient Ugarit dating from the [17:15] mid to late second millennium BC. [17:18] Whoa. [17:19] Whoa. [17:21] You jump back to God. [17:22] Millennia. [17:23] Ilu becomes hungover after a drinking bench. [17:27] The recipe for the salivary is to be applied to the God's forehead, [17:30] which consists of hairs of a dog. [17:33] Um, so I have the first reference, um, uh, towards drinking being in 1546 in, [17:41] uh, an invaluable early text by John Haywood entitled a dialogue containing spelled [17:51] C-O-N-T-E-E-I-N-Y-N-G the number N-O-M-B-E-R in effect of all the pro [18:00] U-U-R-B-E-S in the English tongue, 1546. [18:07] I feel like I ran across that Hayward guy before at some point, didn't we? [18:10] Oh, maybe. [18:12] I pray thee let me and my fellow have a hair of the dog that bit us last [18:17] night and bitten where we both to the brain a right. [18:20] We saw each other drunk in good ale glass. [18:26] Um, so in Costa Rica, the same expression is used, but it refers to [18:30] the pig hair of the same pig referred to the same method to cure the hangover. [18:37] Apparently it's all over the world. [18:38] Hungarian, we got Slavic, we got German, we got Italian, Swedish. [18:45] Everybody's got a form of this thing. [18:48] Largely referring to drinking beer the next day. [18:52] So this is probably one of the only universal human truths. [18:57] Yeah. [18:57] In Japanese, they have a word which I can't read. [19:00] Uh, Ma-kei-zaki, uh, which literally means counter alcohol. [19:06] Drinking alcohol to counter the alcohol, quite literal. [19:10] Yeah. [19:11] Did people really put dog hair in their dog bites? [19:14] It appears to be the case. [19:17] The dark ages were a weird time, man. [19:20] I mean, but you could, you could imagine that like, yeah, you, you [19:24] dogs heal from their wounds. [19:26] Great. [19:26] And some of them, so you're like, okay, cool. [19:31] They can heal themselves. [19:32] So let's just, don't you just put down a rabid dog? [19:35] Yeah, that would be the smart thing to do. [19:37] Yeah. [19:37] Right. [19:39] But again, middle ages, not known for their smarty pants isness. [19:43] Great. [19:46] All right. [19:47] Interesting. [19:49] I think the lesson we learned though is that, yeah, it's a universal thing [19:52] that, uh, you know, people get drunk and then alcoholics are like, yo, yo, [19:58] I've been through this. [19:59] I know what works. [20:00] Drink more of this. [20:02] And then it works and then it catches on. [20:06] Uh, apparently hair in the wound, um, of a dog bite from a rabid dog [20:12] does not cure rabies. [20:13] I'm just learning that, um, on the internet. [20:16] You're just learning that. [20:17] Yeah. [20:18] So don't go with that. [20:19] Okay. [20:20] Um, there is no scientific evidence that that cures rabies. [20:24] Uh, in fairness, has anyone actually studied that? [20:31] Also, there's no scientific evidence that, um, alcohol cures a hangover, [20:35] but those people are wrong. [20:38] Well, it doesn't cure. [20:39] No, it doesn't cure anything. [20:41] It doesn't cure anything. [20:43] I think this is a treat the symptoms. [20:45] This is the part of the podcast where most of us, uh, will say [20:48] that we are not doctors. [20:50] Um, well, okay. [20:51] Well, one of us is a doctor and I'm not going to say who is you [20:55] guys at the listeners. [20:56] You can just guess. [20:57] You just guess. [20:59] It's my dog.