The Undegooglables
Better answers than Google can give you.

Apple PodcastsSpotifyYouTubeOvercastRSSWebsite

Episode 19 · December 14, 2019

That's Just Juggling

The hosts try to figure out where "keep the ball rolling" comes from, guessing at sports, snowballs and dances before landing on a presidential campaign.

“Just roll a ball to the next rally.” (09:22)

Questions

Where does the phrase "keep the ball rolling" come from? (00:32)

Our guess
Some old game such as stick and hoop, a snowball, a military ball, or a dance or party that has to keep going.
Reveal the answer
The answer
It's American, from the 1840 presidential campaign of William Henry Harrison ("Tippecanoe and Tyler too"), when supporters rolled a giant campaign ball across the country. It replaced the earlier British phrase "keep the ball up", which suggested juggling.
Verdict partly

Listen to the episode

Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:00] Next up, we're moving into the under-googlables.
[00:04] Should we do an under-googlables?
[00:11] That was the play of it.
[00:12] I'm super excited.
[00:13] I told us we had to.
[00:15] So we signed up for it.
[00:20] In the end, it's going to be better and more true than Google can give you.
[00:24] There's a lot of things we don't know in this world, John.
[00:28] What are we going to tell you about this time that we don't know anything about?
[00:32] Nice job last week with the St. Patrick's Day.
[00:36] We always do a nice job on the holidays,
[00:40] but one of my favorite things we do is trying to figure out the history of phrases
[00:44] and idioms and what they mean and where they came from.
[00:49] This one came up this week, and I thought immediately of Joey and Jason,
[00:55] so I thought I'd put it out there.
[00:57] Keep the ball rolling.
[01:02] I was wondering if this was a soccer reference.
[01:05] I don't know where this comes from.
[01:07] I guess we need to figure out what it means first,
[01:09] but that's what I'm going with.
[01:12] Keep the ball rolling.
[01:14] It's so funny how these phrases are so just natural to hear,
[01:21] and you never think about where the hell they come from.
[01:25] Because it seems obvious you hear,
[01:27] keep the ball rolling, you know exactly what it means.
[01:30] Is it a reference to, maybe not soccer,
[01:35] but a different game that people played?
[01:38] There was the stick and hoop game,
[01:41] where you just make the hoop keep going,
[01:44] but maybe there was a predecessor that was just a ball to you.
[01:47] The phrase means to keep the momentum going, right?
[01:53] Yeah.
[01:55] How do you play stick and hoop?
[01:57] The rules of stick and hoop.
[01:59] I think you just roll that sucker and go as far as you can, man.
[02:03] There's no like, you can't win, right?
[02:06] You just do it. It's just for fun.
[02:08] I think you just do it, but you could probably,
[02:10] whoever can make it go the farthest wins.
[02:13] I mean, you win when you get to the end of the earth,
[02:15] and you and Kyrie tip some beers.
[02:19] Sure.
[02:21] Do you think there were like, in tennis,
[02:24] people that specialize in grass courts or clay courts?
[02:28] Probably in stick and hoop, there were people that specialize
[02:31] on cobblestone streets versus feet meadows.
[02:36] Sure.
[02:38] He's never been defeated on dirt roads.
[02:42] Yeah.
[02:43] Or maybe even specifically like 10th Street or something
[02:46] was just like, you can't stop me here.
[02:49] Home street advantage?
[02:51] Yeah.
[02:55] So this goes back to a game in which you have
[02:58] to keep the ball rolling.
[03:00] Are we going uphill?
[03:01] Are we going downhill?
[03:02] Are we just going straight?
[03:05] So it's an old phrase.
[03:06] It's not soccer.
[03:08] I mean, I don't know.
[03:10] Soccer's pretty old.
[03:12] Would keeping the ball rolling in soccer be useful?
[03:14] This is why I thought of you guys.
[03:15] I was like, I don't know.
[03:16] Is that something that would be useful?
[03:19] Well, yeah.
[03:20] I mean, it's similar to basketball.
[03:21] You want to create the angles, ball movement,
[03:24] player movement kind of thing.
[03:26] You don't do a whole lot of ISOs in soccer.
[03:29] Some, but yeah, not a ton.
[03:32] But you don't really refer to the ball moving around
[03:35] as rolling it in soccer.
[03:37] OK.
[03:38] See, so it's probably not that.
[03:40] I was thinking that it might be connected to I
[03:43] have a lot of balls in the air, but maybe not.
[03:46] Well, that's just juggling.
[03:49] Yeah.
[03:50] Another phrase entirely.
[03:52] Different phrase.
[03:53] OK.
[03:54] Bowling is a sport that the ball has to be rolling.
[03:57] If it stops, that's no good.
[03:59] Yeah.
[04:00] I don't know a lot about what happens.
[04:02] Have the ball ever stopped?
[04:03] Yeah.
[04:04] That would be interesting.
[04:06] You've got your lawn bowling, too.
[04:08] I don't know a lot about what happens
[04:10] in like the rugby scrum, but don't you
[04:13] are supposed to like roll it back to your guys
[04:15] or something?
[04:17] Is that a thing?
[04:18] I think you just beat each other up.
[04:19] I think you kind of like roll over the ball
[04:21] to like protect it from the other guys
[04:23] to let your guys grab it.
[04:24] But yeah, again, I don't know much about rugby.
[04:27] I think we see people kind of rolling it backwards
[04:29] to their guys a little bit.
[04:33] And if it stops, then someone's going to jump on you
[04:35] and probably smash your face.
[04:37] Murder you?
[04:38] So you'd want to keep the ball rolling in that case?
[04:40] I mean, that would be, yeah.
[04:42] It doesn't roll a whole lot in that game in general,
[04:44] but I think in the scrum is like the only place it would.
[04:48] I just can't think of that many games
[04:50] where the ball has to continue to roll
[04:52] to gain momentum.
[04:56] You know, like basketball, football,
[04:58] baseball, they're just all, they're not...
[05:01] What about cricket?
[05:03] You're throwing, you're hitting the ball.
[05:05] With water polo, you know?
[05:07] Like none of these are really about rolling the ball.
[05:10] So weirdly, when you say that phrase,
[05:12] the first thing that comes to mind
[05:14] is like a snowball rolling down the hill.
[05:16] Yeah, I was thinking of like Sisyphus.
[05:18] Keep the ball rolling the wrong way.
[05:20] You don't want that ball rolling.
[05:22] Yeah.
[05:24] But yeah, for like a snowball, similarly,
[05:26] you wouldn't want it to keep getting bigger and bigger
[05:28] and bigger and like crushing the town.
[05:30] Unless you were like trying to invade that town.
[05:37] Are we bound to sports thing,
[05:39] or you think maybe some...
[05:41] It could be military.
[05:43] A military ball?
[05:46] A military ball, that makes sense.
[05:48] I mean, they used to...
[05:50] It's like the Indiana Jones trap,
[05:52] where you got the big boulder and...
[05:54] Oh yeah.
[05:55] Roll it down on the old enemies.
[05:57] Oh yeah, if you're a bad guy,
[05:58] you'd want to keep the ball rolling
[06:00] to run over Indiana Jones.
[06:02] Or maybe it's, you said military ball there, Joey,
[06:05] which made me think of like a dance.
[06:07] Maybe it's like an early version of
[06:09] Keep the Party Going.
[06:10] Oh yeah, keep the ball rolling.
[06:11] Let's keep this ball rolling.
[06:14] This is, I think, our best guest so far.
[06:17] So it's like you got to keep the dance going.
[06:19] Yeah, it was an early Schlitz motto.
[06:28] Schlitz.
[06:29] When you want to keep the ball rolling.
[06:34] They were marketing specifically to dead becomes.
[06:39] I'm sure they decided that was their market for sure.
[06:42] Yeah, totally.
[06:43] So we're thinking Southern ball or a European ball?
[06:47] Do you feel like this is a European phrase, Joey?
[06:50] Well, if it's old, the U.S. is not that old, so...
[06:57] Yeah, so I'm thinking, I don't know, Vienna probably.
[07:02] Very specific.
[07:04] Yeah.
[07:05] Very specific.
[07:06] I just imagine Vienna mostly, you know,
[07:09] the weekend evenings is lots of balls and lots of dancing.
[07:15] And apparently Schlitz too.
[07:19] All right, so the Vienna balls have to keep going on after dark.
[07:26] Keep them rolling.
[07:27] Yep.
[07:29] Yeah, you don't want the party to stop.
[07:30] We're terrible at this.
[07:31] That can't be what it's about.
[07:34] All right, so is it time to Google this thing?
[07:36] I don't know.
[07:37] We just gave you better than what...
[07:39] Oh, no way.
[07:40] You know, Google will give you.
[07:42] If it was Strasburg, I'm going to be pissed.
[07:44] No, I think Coalson might have been right.
[07:47] Which one?
[07:50] So according to phrases.org.uk,
[07:55] the American expression, keep the ball rolling,
[08:00] was preceded by the similar and now archaic British phrase,
[08:04] keep the ball up.
[08:05] Oh, yeah, no, I didn't mean that.
[08:07] They had much the same meaning.
[08:11] The earlier one leads to keeping a ball in the air,
[08:14] that is conveying the notion of keeping an activity going,
[08:18] which probably has to do with juggling, I'm guessing, right?
[08:21] You're keeping all the balls in the air.
[08:24] Okay, keep the ball rolling.
[08:28] Phrase owes its origin and popularity to the US presidential election of July 1840.
[08:35] 1840?
[08:36] Yeah, that election is widely regarded as introducing
[08:39] all the paraphernalia of present-day elections,
[08:42] that is campaign songs, advertising slogans,
[08:44] and publicity stunts of all kinds.
[08:47] It was Martin Van Viren versus William Harrison,
[08:52] and it was a war hero who had fought against the Shawnee Indians
[09:01] at Tippecanoe.
[09:03] The Whig candidate revealed his folksy cider-drinking log cabin,
[09:06] men of the people image, and adopted the first known political slogan,
[09:09] Tippecanoe and Tyler, too.
[09:12] The song of the same name was considered to have sung Harrison into presidency.
[09:18] Don't you hear from every quarter, quarter, quarter, good news and true
[09:22] that swift the ball is rolling on for Tippecanoe and Tyler, too?
[09:27] So Benjamin Harrison was 1888,
[09:30] but apparently they rolled a huge ball covered with campaign slogans
[09:35] halfway across the country, which seems like a weird thing.
[09:40] So instead of Trump flying around from campaign to campaign,
[09:44] you would just roll a ball to the next spot?
[09:47] Just roll a ball to the next rally.
[09:49] That is not what I thought.
[10:00] But it's one of two things.
[10:02] It's the magic of the game.
[10:03] The European version is you've got a lot of activities
[10:06] and you've got to keep it going.
[10:08] And then the American version is a huge ball for a presidential campaign.
[10:13] Shout out to Harrison, by the way.
[10:15] Shout out.
[10:17] Well, there you go.
[10:19] The more stuff you don't know.
[10:21] I'm intrigued by this ball that gets rolled across the country.
[10:25] I am, too.
[10:26] I'm really excited for it to come back.
[10:29] It was a steel ribbed and canvas-covered sphere
[10:33] and rolled at approximately 5,000 miles in several states
[10:36] to Benjamin Harrison's home state, of course, of Indiana.
[10:41] Yeah, this guy was big.
[10:43] I mean, this is like twice the height of a human.
[10:46] Like 10-foot gigantic ball.
[10:50] So that's crazy.
[10:52] Were like just random people rolling this thing,
[10:56] or was this like his aides and pages?
[10:59] Was he rolling it himself?
[11:03] I don't know.
[11:04] I don't think so.
[11:06] I think I would know if a president had rolled a ball 5,000 miles by himself
[11:11] at any point in American history.
[11:14] Well, if I know anything about presidential information,
[11:17] we just jiggle to Twitter to check that out, right?
[11:19] Sure.
[11:20] So you keep the momentum going by rolling the ball to the next rally.
[11:24] Yeah.
[11:25] Okay.
[11:26] Yeah, we've got a picture of it here.
[11:31] There's a big campaign ball.
[11:33] Or it's like juggling.
[11:35] Yep.