Episode 211 · September 12, 2026
Squeegee
Joey and Jason both wondered why we 'keep our eyes peeled'. The hosts guess the eyelid peeled open and a French or Twain-ish origin; the true source is unsettled, with 'eyes skinned' and the Robert Peel police theory floated.
“And realizing that the term keeping your eyes peeled came from Jordan Peele. That's what I remember from this show.” (15:53)
Questions
Why do we say 'keep your eyes peeled'? (00:35)
Our guess
Peeling the eyelid open (Jason); French origin, 1920s PI slang, or folksy Mark Twain
Peeling the eyelid open (Jason); French origin, 1920s PI slang, or folksy Mark Twain
Reveal the answer
The answer
No definitive origin; first print is an 1853 St. Louis newspaper. 'Keep your eyes skinned' (Moby Dick) appears earlier; theories include peeling potato eyes and Robert Peel's police (1829), and 'peel' as literal stripping away of a layer.
No definitive origin; first print is an 1853 St. Louis newspaper. 'Keep your eyes skinned' (Moby Dick) appears earlier; theories include peeling potato eyes and Robert Peel's police (1829), and 'peel' as literal stripping away of a layer.
Verdict partly
Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:00] well you know what I want to get cultivated here I want to get I want to [00:08] get the truth cultivated for once out of an under Google how does that sound [00:15] guys you know this is the part where we just make up a bunch of shit right yeah [00:19] but then we fact-check it afterwards okay [00:35] under Google that was the play of super excited told us we had to we signed up [00:43] for it in the end it's gonna be better and more true than Google can give you [00:50] so here's an under Google wolf that's been that that's been in the back of my [00:58] mind and in one of my colleagues Ethan buddy mine and we've been wondering the [01:09] phrase keep your eyes peeled when I hear that phrase to me just means I'm [01:17] gonna keep looking for something specific so whatever it is like I'm gonna look [01:22] for you know whatever whatever it is I'm gonna look for that specific thing I'm [01:28] gonna pay extra special attention for it just to make sure you know I'll see it if [01:33] if it's there but then the you know things are peeled you're taking layers [01:41] off and stuff and eyes have layers as Jason can probably go into very thorough [01:47] detail I don't want my eyes peeled so every time that I say it I feel a [01:55] little a little gross why would we say that we're keeping our eyes peeled well [02:06] so yeah you mentioned Ethan and he actually asked me this question because I [02:12] think I said I think it was weird walking somewhere and I was like yeah you [02:19] always want to be looking around you know keeping your eyes peeled for [02:22] whatever and he was like what the heck does that mean and my thesis was that [02:32] it's not so much peeling a layer of your actual eyeball but that your eyelid serves [02:39] as the peel and you're keeping it peeled open your eyes are open so is [02:47] that what it was that the truth you cultivated for your child yeah yeah I know [02:56] I'm I am straightforward that I don't know things with them but uh yeah let's [03:02] say this is my best guess I like that and then I said but we should do that as [03:06] an under Google and then promptly forgot so I'm glad Joey it's in some sort of [03:12] kismet had the same thing occur in his world so so wait it's to Ethan's I [03:20] I'm so confused no just the one that makes money then you don't keep your ears [03:27] peeled right I think I've heard that before now you keep your ear to the [03:33] street keep your nose peeled you keep your nose on the grindstone right so it [03:41] does seem like a specific eye thing mm-hmm yeah I was also thinking of it [03:51] and yeah similar way in a pretty like sense the only other thing that had [03:59] occurred to me was you know if you're very tired and your eyes sort of close [04:06] involuntarily you can sort of peel back your own eyelids it's a try and stay [04:12] awake true okay maybe it's like a well Joey you've been you've been thinking [04:20] about it what is your bent what is your are we taking off the uvia or the cornea [04:26] that's just what comes that's what comes the layer on just cuz I mean I've had [04:30] eye surgeries in the past and they used some sort of fruit peeler nope well I [04:39] was out for you know what I don't know I can't speak to that I was sleeping I [04:46] think they use lasers but I had that when I had LASIK they used like a little [04:54] squeegee and scraped off the epithelial and then yeah that's disgusting that's [05:02] a real cross I mean yeah I just I think about yeah physically dismantling your [05:17] eyeball was which is okay unpleasant I don't like it so it's one of those [05:24] things when I say it and I'm like every time I say I'm like why did I say that I [05:27] don't want to say that and we're sure it's peel like not PEL right see I'm not [05:36] sure right so like I'm there's probably other uses of the word peel and that's [05:42] where we're at here right like bells peel the bells peel yeah wait what is [05:47] that it's like it's like it yeah it rings just the sound of a bell okay I'm [05:58] trying to think of I've seen it written I'm sure I've seen it written somewhere [06:01] but can't think off the top of my head but I always assumed it was yeah that's [06:09] what I thought too but I certainly can't remember everything I mean having seen [06:13] it written either so it may just be you know an old English word that has a [06:23] different meaning and we only use it in this context now or something like that [06:26] that's a possibility I mean when do you think people started telling people to [06:32] keep their eyes peeled this seems like a thing that ganks years in the 20s [06:37] I was feeling like PIs but around the same time frame keep your eyes peeled for [06:44] that for the fuzz same speed situation some some cool PI lingo yeah yeah keep [06:55] your eyes see I'm thinking like I think I said old English cuz I'm feeling like [07:02] this is really old I'm feeling like this is medieval times really yeah we're [07:13] keeping our eyes peeled for like some some guards of the yeah I'm thinking of [07:18] you know a storming party coming through the woods and we're trying we're [07:24] sitting we're sitting on the barracks or whatever and keeping our eyes peeled [07:27] because if you don't see them I'm gonna torture you with I stuff right and I'm [07:36] thinking this is a French it's a French derivation but so do you think it's like [07:44] PEL specific I think it probably in French it's like P E L E or something I [07:52] don't know and it just got morphed into something I think it means sharp or [07:57] open or something how do you say eyes and I think it's like eggs I took I took high [08:12] school French guys yeah yeah do you know how to say it like sharp and French no [08:19] yeah I'm just making all of this up guys this is what we do here yeah I mean it's [08:26] like oh hose and yeah Spanish so it's got to be something close to well like [08:31] you know if you hear a bell peel is that I don't know I'm wondering if it's the [08:37] same route somehow I like your your guys gumshoe is probably closer to the truth [08:44] you good with that Joey what do you think where do you following this I don't [08:49] think it's French I guess I don't have another that random thing I just made [08:54] yeah I don't know is that well I okay I think that the peel does maybe just mean [09:01] make you keep your eyelids open you know because that makes sense like it's peeled [09:08] it's it's open I just I was taking it as layers that were deeper than the eyelid [09:15] into the into the eyeball itself which I was not happy with but maybe if it was [09:19] just the outside just means keep your eyes open and look for this thing I [09:24] so maybe it's just like literary like somebody came up with a you know a nice [09:29] yeah which is why I'm super shocked you didn't just go with Shakespeare instead of [09:34] going on that weird French rabbit hole that we just boom I'm going I'm going for [09:37] Shakespeare I'm boxing a man with no Shakespeare [09:42] I'm going Mark Twain folksy Mark Twain okay yeah wow since we had a tweener it [09:54] is yeah watch it be French and I backed off I see alternate is keep your eyes [10:08] skinned oh I like that less I like that much less so yeah hey I overlords say [10:20] origin theories include peeling potatoes some suggest it comes from the day of [10:24] peeling the eyes or buds off potatoes to see them better or figuratively removing [10:30] a layer from your own eyes to improve vision or Robert Peel so connects it to [10:39] Sir Robert Peel who established the British police force nicknamed peelers or [10:44] bobbies who are expected to be watchful for lawbreakers that sounds truthy first [10:59] use in 18 oh wait no no probably not the first use but it did appear in the [11:07] Morning Herald in st. Louis in 1853 yeah young man keep your eye peeled when [11:18] you are after the women in in Moby Dick it says a white whale skin your eyes for [11:25] him men look sharp for white water if you see but a bubble sing out yeah so it [11:34] seems like keeping your eyes skinned is way proceeds the peeled and then it [11:41] sort of got overtaken I'm not seeing anything definitive no does seem like it [11:51] is spelled PE yes yeah and if it is after the cop it doesn't that doesn't seem to [12:02] work if the phrase was before that keep your eyes skinned I mean that can't [12:08] so according to the idioms it can be traced back to the time of sailing ships [12:15] when pirates were on the seas frequently in the 1800s the staying [12:22] incentive was crucial and then since became popular but there's no evidence [12:29] put forward here like people using it so maybe I mean maybe it was just largely [12:35] skin until around this you know 1830s time frame and everyone was just super [12:42] uncomfortable with that and decided to go with peeled instead yeah and Robert [12:48] Peel was the early 1800s yeah Metro police force in 18 1829 and okay so [12:57] that would 18 yeah and so they called them peelers because they reported [13:01] directly to him I was kind of curious just if that was the if there was [13:04] anything more to that but it doesn't appear to be well the grammar list has [13:10] some variations which we could also use we had the aforementioned keep your eyes [13:14] skinned but then the one I think I like the best keep your peepers open keep a [13:20] sharp eye out keep your gaze peeled keep a weather eye out that's probably [13:26] sailor blinkers on you know what I've been AI wrote this I've never heard [13:33] anyone say keep your blinkers on well I'm gonna say we nailed it we were [13:39] maybe a little bit off on the date but peel as the ringing of the bell is from [13:49] Middle English PLE meaning a call especially the ringing of church bells [13:57] so I just got my peels confused I didn't say French do you think I guess the [14:04] other one that I haven't I haven't seen anything come up for this do you think [14:07] it's from key and peel Jordan Pools George Jordan peels Wikipedia page and [14:21] it says not to be confused with Jordan pool which I would never get them [14:25] confused but then I that I did after then you did next thing that happened [14:31] immediately and French for I is a but it's no eil which is like in my mind [14:47] that's why I was like an egg sure I sort of remembered something but it's [14:53] basically just saying I and a French accent it's kind of piratey if we're [14:58] being honest about it oh the so for French the masculine term for peeled is [15:11] it's spelled the same as Pele we never we never mentioned all right well we did [15:18] not nail that but I think we did too it's literal yeah well yeah I would say we [15:28] got that mean you know yes like but the time is we weren't but what's a hundred [15:35] years in the grand scheme of things universe is 15 billion years sure it's [15:39] fair all right team well I think that gets us right to the end of the show I'd [15:47] like to thank everyone for being here with us coming on this ride and [15:53] realizing that the term keeping your eyes peeled came from Jordan pool that's [15:59] what I remember from this show