Episode 195 · May 3, 2025
Read-Option Father
Jason's son asks what 'throw your hat in the ring' means. The hosts debate boxing, crime rings and Shakespeare, and learn it is a boxing phrase popularized in politics by Teddy Roosevelt.
“I'm a read option father.” (02:11)
Questions
Where does 'throw your hat in the ring' come from? (01:09)
Our guess
Probably boxing (a challenger throwing in a hat), with Shakespeare-era guesses on timing
Probably boxing (a challenger throwing in a hat), with Shakespeare-era guesses on timing
Reveal the answer
The answer
Boxing: contestants literally threw hats into the ring to join the fight (London Morning Chronicle, 1804). Figurative use is attested in 1820, and Teddy Roosevelt made it a political phrase in 1912.
Boxing: contestants literally threw hats into the ring to join the fight (London Morning Chronicle, 1804). Figurative use is attested in 1820, and Teddy Roosevelt made it a political phrase in 1912.
Verdict right
Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:06] Oh, we do under Google rules. That was the play of super excited told us we had to [00:19] We said we signed up for it in the end it's gonna be better and more true than Google can give you [00:28] Guys it is that time of the show [00:33] Where we need to get some questions answered [00:38] I know that [00:41] We want to help but we just needs we need somewhere to point our our laser beam focus [00:53] What's been eating you up Jason [00:56] Well, this one goes back. I'm learning that a lot of my under Google has now come from [01:02] My son Ethan asked me what what does that mean when I say something? So we were sitting around the dinner table and [01:09] Talking about something [01:10] And and I was like, oh, yeah, I don't know. I've been thinking maybe I'll throw my hat in the ring, you know for this [01:19] Position or whatever [01:20] And Ethan was like, what is that throw your hat in the ring? What it? [01:26] Why would you do that? What are you talking about? I said, I have no idea son [01:32] But you just created more content for me [01:39] My boy is in this in the age where he just asked why for everything [01:43] Oh, yeah, and I try to give him good answers, but some of them are really unanswerable questions [01:50] so I [01:51] Those I pitched to his mother. Hmm, and I leave I just leave the premises generally [01:57] That's less pitching than punting. I [02:00] Mean, yeah. Well, it's like a it's a lateral pitch [02:03] I [02:11] Yeah, I'm a read option [02:13] father and I [02:16] Mean it works fine until it's 90% effect. Yeah [02:20] I'm pretty athletic, right? So [02:23] Compared to a three-year-old [02:25] He's more flexible to me though. Well a lot. Yeah [02:31] But those fine motor skills got a way to go [02:35] But so, yeah, so throwing my hat in the ring I didn't I didn't know I have no idea [02:42] circus rings [02:45] pricing rings [02:46] boxing ring [02:47] So I think that to defy like to define these first and so I think that just means you you want to be [02:55] I always sort of use it as I'd like to be considered. I like to try this kind of thing, right? Yep [03:01] You're planning to vie for whatever thing there is [03:05] Right the hat part again. I mean, I feel like that'd be a marker of who you were [03:13] But what is the ring? [03:15] It's probably not Lord of the rings, right? I feel like lots of people have similar hats [03:20] Yeah, especially probably when this phrase came about. Yeah, everybody was wearing a bowler [03:28] Fedora or something, right? It could be a boxing ring [03:32] Where you say hey, I'm ready to fight. Yeah [03:37] Yeah, who wants to take this guy on? [03:40] In this bear not quite so [03:42] So many people want to do it. They got a you got to throw your hat into the ring. Hmm instead of forming a line [03:49] Great, right. I [03:51] Mean the other things that we throw we did hat trick. Hey, did we? Yeah [03:57] Which there's a hot the hockey tradition where they throw things into the rink [04:04] The rink there's no way it comes from that right? I wouldn't think so [04:09] But also like I don't feel like that's [04:11] You know, you're that's like a celebration, right? You're not right, right? [04:16] For sure. Could it be a metaphorical ring like the political ring a political thing? [04:26] Metaphorical hat in a metaphorical ring, but then that's just the saying [04:30] Right, how likely is it planning the elder? [04:37] Involved in this one. I feel like they were using a lot of like clay shards for boating and [04:44] Things like that. Yeah, I guess they invented hats until like the well, that was my next thing was like technology was Roman [04:52] I [04:57] Definitely that one that you would that you would be able into toss, you know, they're mostly metal things, right? Yeah [05:03] I don't know. I imagine there were straw hats [05:06] very early on [05:09] So when do we think people started using this phrase along those lines if it's not planning the elder then it's [05:17] The younger or Shakespeare, I guess I kind of was thinking [05:23] Shakespeare hmm. I was kind of thinking maybe in that era [05:29] Could this somehow be horse racing do horses have more hats? [05:34] What about a cock fighting ring? [05:36] Hmm or a crime ring? [05:39] Hmm. They were more hoods than hats [05:44] The crowd gets I mean some of these guys the your old-timey gangsters like they're deaf. They're hat guys [05:51] Yeah, okay. Okay, British gangsters are definitely had guys [05:55] Yeah [05:57] Cuz it could say like who wants to do a crime tonight and say I mean [06:04] And my name is in my hat [06:07] so we know who [06:09] Is gonna participate? Yeah, was this like children whose mothers had written the names in the hats like yeah [06:17] Because that is this is I think the the wicket that we're getting stuck on which is [06:22] Okay, so you throw your hat in the ring. How do we know who's had it is like? [06:26] Shakespeare has me [06:29] Intrigue though. Yeah, I [06:32] Like I like British bare knuckle boxing [06:36] Okay from the I [06:39] Don't know Oliver twist days [06:42] Or maybe it's a thing like yeah, you don't [06:45] Since everybody's wearing a hat you toss your hat in the ring. You just look around for the guy that's not wearing a hat [06:55] That definitely could be because yeah [06:58] Because if everybody's got the hat then it's all right you for yeah, you go better not go fight. I [07:07] Like that wait, so we're gangs in New York days [07:12] Or but you're thinking in England [07:14] I was thinking British, but it could just as easily be [07:19] But same time same time frame same here other side of the pond gotcha do falconers wear hats [07:27] Just trying to cross off our likely said feel like you should [07:31] What about trains? [07:33] trains or [07:36] Nautical stuff. Oh [07:39] The Navy guys definitely wear hats [07:43] Yeah, but if they toss theirs, they're not gonna back. Yeah. Yeah, plus there's no [07:50] Volunterism in the military particularly you the whole thing is oh, yeah told [07:58] That's like the whole that's like their whole thing that's their whole bit [08:02] Yeah, I kind of like yeah, I'm with you on era but [08:10] Is it somehow Andrew Jackson? [08:13] Or like some weird political thing [08:17] Like the block of cheese thing whatever yeah or old kinder hook or they have weird stuff [08:24] It do have weird stuff. I'm going Shakespeare. I think it's the Shakespeare on Shakespeare. Okay [08:36] What do you think Joey [08:38] yeah, I mean Shakespeare I think to me seems about right because it's it feel like it's one of those things where it could be a [08:49] Just a clever like a clever phrase that everybody you know you get [08:55] But I feel like there's some missing context [08:58] That we don't have these days [09:02] Looks like Harper nailed this [09:07] According to well, I can't read the whole article. Okay, here we go [09:13] political dictionary calm [09:16] comes from boxing [09:18] where contestants would literally throw their hats into the boxing ring is a signal of wanting to join in [09:24] the fight [09:29] Morning Chronicle of London November 30th 1804 origin and politics [09:37] That him has evolved into a political saying in part due to Teddy Roosevelt who was an avid boxer in [09:44] 1912 a reporter asked Roosevelt about his plans to challenge Taft and Roosevelt replied quote [09:50] My hat is in the ring. The fight is on. Yeah, I'm stripped to the buff [09:58] Teddy letting it all hang out. So it does seem yeah boxing [10:05] with the close parallel with [10:09] with the same intention for [10:14] Mostly need [10:16] politicians and then it [10:19] quickly moved into [10:21] metaphorical things I guess the first [10:25] Figurative use [10:28] Published in the Reading Mercury Oxford Gazette [10:33] in 1820 [10:36] Now sir, I throw down my glove or according to the more [10:40] modern fancy throw my hat in the ring and challenge you to produce proofs from the Reading Address. I [10:47] Like it when people go with proofs as plural. Mm-hmm [10:56] Yeah, it seems like it's pretty solidly [11:00] Boxer sweet take that Shakespeare. Yeah. Yeah, you fucking nailed that [11:09] Teddy Roosevelt quote [11:16] This is going on