Episode 184 · September 30, 2023
Two For the Price of Three
After riding a carousel on Martha's Vineyard, a host asks if "grab the brass ring" comes from carousels, and the hosts also explain "brass tacks".
“You gotta kiss the brass pinky ring.” (06:32)
Questions
Where does the phrase "grab the brass ring" come from? (01:10)
Our guess
A championship ring or trophy in sports, a retirement watch, or a mafia ring; or possibly carousels.
A championship ring or trophy in sports, a retirement watch, or a mafia ring; or possibly carousels.
Reveal the answer
The answer
It comes from carousels, where riders reaching out from the horses tried to grab a brass ring from an arm for a free ride. It means a very desirable prize, and has appeared in dictionaries since the late 19th century (and in Catcher in the Rye).
It comes from carousels, where riders reaching out from the horses tried to grab a brass ring from an arm for a free ride. It means a very desirable prize, and has appeared in dictionaries since the late 19th century (and in Catcher in the Rye).
Verdict right
Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:06] Oh, we do under Google rules. That was the play of super excited told us we had to [00:19] We signed up for it in the end, it's gonna be better and more true than Google can give you I [00:28] Have a I have a interesting one. So, okay, so we were in [00:33] Cape Cod for over the 4th of July hanging out with the fan and [00:38] We we took the ferry over to Martha's Vineyard and on Martha's Vineyard [00:43] They have one of the oldest and I think it's the oldest carousel that operates [00:51] in [00:53] North America, maybe maybe the world. I have no idea [00:56] it was originally on Coney Island like in the 1880s and then it was it was there for like five years and then [01:02] Somebody on Martha's Vineyard bought it moved it to Martha's Vineyard [01:06] Anyway, so you can go and and ride this thing which is super fun [01:10] and one of the the things that they do is so they have [01:15] So it's a circle you guys know how a carousel works, right? [01:17] There's an inside lane and an outside lane and both ones [01:20] They have this little arm that comes down and there's these little rings that hang out at the end of the arm [01:26] And what you do is you go by as it as it's as the carousels going around and try to grab the the rings [01:32] And then there's a little post you can collect them or whatever [01:36] Most of them are little rings that are just some [01:40] Generic metal like steel probably or something [01:44] But if you happen to grab the brass ring then you get a free ride on the carousel and so actually [01:53] Ethan well, I I mean I was grabbing the rings, but [01:57] Grab them and I can eat so Ethan got the brass ring and got to go for a free ride or whatever nice [02:03] Which was which was super fun [02:06] but it got me thinking like this concept of like grabbing the brass ring, which I [02:12] Always thought was like, you know being very successful in business kind of or something like that [02:17] You guys can correct me if I'm wrong, but I wondered what the origin of that phrase was and if it [02:24] If there's any way in the world that comes back to carousels and people grabbing the brass ring at a carousel to get [02:30] The free ride. Are you guys familiar with this phrase? Or did I make this up in my head? [02:36] I haven't heard of it, but that's okay [02:40] So we're we're we're grabbing the brass ring and that's that's leading to success in business [02:47] That's the way I feel like I remember hearing it or whatever. Okay, but you haven't heard a video [02:54] No, no, no, no, no, it does. It does. I [02:58] Mean I vaguely recall this phrase because I and I feel like I've heard of it in [03:05] Yeah, not you're right not like quite in sports specifically but an achievement of things right? Yeah [03:13] He's like getting that brass ring. Yeah, like that is really like you have solidified yourself and reach the pinnacle of a thing [03:21] Right something like that. Yeah [03:23] I guess I always envisioned it as I always envisioned it as maybe a trophy in sports that no longer exists or that [03:30] that I don't I'm not aware of like [03:32] like [03:33] grabbing the [03:35] Belt or whatever like you would in [03:38] What is that boxing? [03:41] Yep, you know wrestling or wrestling. Yeah, so I always say there's [03:46] a real thing [03:48] I think I always envision the brass ring is something that you would you would win like the [03:53] You know the stanley cup or something [03:56] If I okay, but again, it's it's a real vague [04:00] Uh kind of image in my head from not really using that phrase very much [04:04] sure [04:06] The other ideas I had was you know, like when people retire they get a gold watch [04:10] I didn't know if like the brass ring was like [04:13] literally a ring that you get that's like, you know, some company gives you for [04:18] X number of years of achievement or something like that [04:21] So brass is a um [04:24] a very malleable metal [04:27] I think so [04:28] Okay. Yeah, it's an alloy. I know that okay [04:32] and and on the list of expensive [04:35] Metals where are we at on a brass ring? [04:39] I mean not super duper high. I mean [04:43] You'll see it on uh [04:45] Like a high end boat would have like brass furnishings or something [04:48] Sure. Yeah. Yeah, like a and brass taps at an old bar old timey bar or something [04:55] Yeah [04:57] and [04:58] You know, I suppose the the brass section [05:02] Of an orchestra. Sure. Yep [05:05] All right, that's all I know about brass apparently [05:09] You can clean brass with brass. Oh, yeah [05:12] It's a nice cleaner [05:16] That's solid otherwise it oxidizes right and gets dirty [05:22] Is that is that the oxidation that makes it [05:26] I believe so. Yeah turn green like copper. Yeah, it does. Yeah, it does. They are or brown like black. Yeah [05:34] Yeah, I think copper is one of the [05:36] elements of the alloy [05:39] Uh, well the reason I brought up we had nothing on this one. Sorry [05:44] I thought this was a more popular phrase than I one of the reason I bring up the the uh [05:49] whether whether brass would be expensive or not is because you know [05:53] if brass is [05:55] fairly [05:56] easy to get [05:58] Um, then then a brass ring wouldn't be that big a deal except in the scenario you just mentioned right where it's like [06:04] It's it's just a different color so that we can celebrate it not because it's an expensive [06:10] you know [06:11] Purely symbolic. Yeah [06:14] Yeah, I really under that so I hadn't put much thought into it [06:18] Yeah, I mean feels like a very sporting thing a trophy like [06:24] Sort of thing either that or it's mafia, right? Mm-hmm. You gotta kiss the brass ring [06:32] You gotta kiss the brass pinky ring [06:34] That's right, well, you know, I I also but I but I do love the idea Jason that your real life experience has taught you the actual [06:43] Story behind this phrase. So i'm gonna say that it's from this carousel. It's from the oldest carousel [06:50] 18 [06:53] I also want to know how they moved the carousel [06:56] uh [06:57] That's a good question. They had a bunch of like [07:00] horses [07:01] Gears and all that jazz. Yeah, I mean now it's run on electricity. So I couldn't tell you what they did back in the day [07:07] but well, no, but like I mean [07:09] They didn't have like a helicarrier to move the oh you mean physically [07:14] From coney island. I think they took it apart. I was also considering horses. I thought you made how it how the carousel [07:21] Which is probably also the answer to the other question as well [07:27] Yeah, no, I think they took it apart [07:29] Piece by piece and then yeah, and then put it back together [07:32] I think that was actually on the side of the building if they if they'd have left us some charge [07:36] There would have been a lot of screws left over after that thing came back [07:40] No, I would have gone with the horse idea. I just dragged it across [07:48] All right, let's see grab that brass ring that's the phrase [07:55] Yeah, um [07:58] It does look like it comes from the carousel nice, this is wild although this [08:12] Yeah, so [08:16] uh [08:17] Miriam webster [08:18] Defines it as a very desirable prize goal or opportunity [08:25] And it seems like maybe it comes from the carousel, right? Yeah, that's what i'm seeing [08:32] Not clear when the phrase came into wide use but has been found in dictionaries as far back as the late [08:38] 19th century including catcher in the rye [08:41] Yeah, it seems it's especially [08:44] Uh championship ring in sports is where it's most used these days. Yeah [08:51] But there's no sport that actually awards you a brass ring [08:54] No [08:56] I mean not anymore at least [08:58] Brass is an alloy of copper and zinc [09:02] So you're right on that varied [09:06] Nice brass is similar to bronze [09:09] It uses but bronze uses tin instead of zinc. Oh, I didn't even [09:17] Think about that that the they're [09:20] Closely related that way see now i'm learning about metal alloys [09:31] Yeah [09:32] Yeah, okay. So the [09:34] The carousel that I rode was [09:36] Called flying horses. It was built in 1876 [09:41] There's one from 1884 in watch hill road island [09:46] Another foreign horse [09:48] Interesting. Yeah, it seems like road island has a real lock down on brass ring carousels [09:53] Yeah [09:57] They do there's one in logan sport indiana [10:00] You guys could go do it [10:02] Listeners [10:04] That is [10:06] Wait, you're saying you didn't do that when you were in indiana recently? Yeah [10:10] Somehow I did not there was what there's one in santa cruz too. I never rode the carousel and apparently one in angola indiana [10:17] Another favorite hot spot of ours [10:22] cool [10:24] Uh, i've also got the uh [10:27] According to cora. I have the origin of brass tacks. Let's get down to brass tacks [10:32] Hmm [10:34] Let's knock that one out while we're here. What's the story? Uh, at least uh, at least according to this [10:41] They sold yard [10:43] Fabrics from a bolt of material which is stretched out and measured against a wooden yardstick was that was screwed down [10:49] into the counter [10:52] There were brass tacks driven into the counter 36 inches apart at the end of the wooden yard stick [10:59] After years of using the ends of the wooden yard stick would get rounded over and somewhat worn away [11:04] And the ladies wanted to ensure that they would get the full measure of their pad fabric [11:08] Would insist on getting down to the brass tacks to ensure that they were not being cheated [11:13] Hmm [11:15] For their fabrics, I don't know if that's true or not, but that's it that makes sense to me [11:24] That is pretty cool [11:29] Well, we solved another one, but that's two for one [11:32] listeners [11:35] You didn't you have to pay extra. That's all [11:38] It's uh two for the price of three. I think is what that was [11:44] It just old themselves a brass rank got a free ride [11:48] That's right