Episode 170 · February 4, 2023
Money Talks
The hosts ask why people say "sick as a dog", landing on vomiting and 17th-century attitudes toward dogs.
“Some dogs will just eat anything... that's where most of my socks go.” (02:57)
Questions
Where does the phrase "sick as a dog" come from? (01:19)
Our guess
Dogs vomit a lot, or dogs on ships were seasick; from the 1500s-1600s, possibly Shakespeare or Rome.
Dogs vomit a lot, or dogs on ships were seasick; from the 1500s-1600s, possibly Shakespeare or Rome.
Reveal the answer
The answer
Dogs were considered an undesirable animal in 17th-century England and many phrases used them negatively ("dog tired", "dirty dog"). "Sick as a dog" refers to vomiting, with the earliest literary use in 1705 (some find 1592).
Dogs were considered an undesirable animal in 17th-century England and many phrases used them negatively ("dog tired", "dirty dog"). "Sick as a dog" refers to vomiting, with the earliest literary use in 1705 (some find 1592).
Verdict right
Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:01] I mean, they might start thinking about heart disease. Well, I mean that's the thing, it's a slower death. [00:06] Right, right. Which, I think, my score is Lee. I think that's McDonald's new slogan. [00:13] It's a slow death. [00:19] All right, Coalson, that was a bummer of a stat and I hate to do that, but [00:29] Here we are. Do you have something that's gonna cheer you up? [00:33] Yeah, hook me up. That's something that's not like, you know, something that's not [00:41] Depressing. They all end up being [00:44] Depressing, right? It's it's it's well not at first [00:48] Well, so here's what I'll do. I'll start with something that's kind of sad and maybe it won't end up being [00:53] Negative, right? I'm gonna perfect. Yeah, we'll figure it out. I [00:57] Think this is good. This is flawless theory [01:00] We do under Google rules. That was the playa super excited told us we had to [01:19] So we signed up for it in the end it's gonna be better and more true than Google can give you [01:28] Sick as a dog where I'm it's sick as a dog. Why are dogs sick? [01:35] When I feel sick as a dog, what does that mean? I [01:39] Mean, I think what I always think it just means you feel really sick. I mean, I mean not [01:47] No, it's specific. But you just just say hey, I feel [01:51] Very terrible. I feel terrible. I don't know Jason deep. Yeah, I know dogs dogs are you know, they get the worst of it [01:58] you know, if you're [02:01] You know not pulling your weight you're dogging it, you know, I'm sure [02:06] like I feel like it's just a derogatory term for [02:10] You know a lower form of humanity, right as a dog [02:16] I keep hearing like manner dogs. I hear that a lot. Mm-hmm, you know [02:22] Yeah, I don't know I [02:25] Don't know no idea why sure I do know that [02:29] so [02:32] You know how this the side effect of lots of drugs is like vomiting or nausea or whatever [02:37] Mm-hmm [02:39] well in theory is that because they are [02:43] tested on dogs at some point and [02:46] dogs [02:47] have a very [02:49] robust [02:50] Vomiting response or whatever so that their strategy is to just eat everything and then if something's not good [02:57] They just throw it up [02:59] So they throw a like God sort of man wants to everything basically so [03:04] So maybe that's mmm part of where it comes from like they always oh, yeah [03:07] Sure, dogs do get sick quite often, but they'll eat grass [03:13] Yeah, yeah, okay [03:15] I like that they'll eat any some dogs will just eat anything that will go into their mouth [03:21] 98% of dogs [03:24] Like I said, that's where most of my socks go. I think right [03:28] Now and also this does it's does suggest that getting sick [03:34] Sort of a way that we think about throwing up, right? [03:38] Instead of just like I have a fever like a dog like maybe I'm actually it maybe it is about vomiting [03:44] Sick as a dog. Hmm. Do we think this goes back to like? [03:50] Now this seems like it's sailing thing or something like it's always in it always sailing. I was gonna say it was worth [03:57] One of the common ones you can imagine that yeah, I don't know if they took dogs on [04:02] Sailing vessels or whatever back in the day [04:05] But maybe they did and maybe dogs were particularly always sick. They don't have good sea legs. So they were always sick. I [04:14] See that's a fair. It's a really good guess [04:19] So I don't feel like dogs are gonna like [04:22] It's never feel at home on the sea. Yeah, but and it's also not a common [04:28] Image of a dog on a boat. Yeah, I don't have any of that in my head. So I don't I don't think that's likely [04:36] At one point [04:38] The mo major way of transportation, but you know to go places was you know by boat [04:44] And so if you had to move your dog from Europe to America in or whatever [04:50] You got to bring your dog. Yeah sure it happened. So when do you think this turn or this phrase eology? [04:59] Came about well if we're going with [05:02] Traveling by boat. I'm gonna go to fifteen. I'm not necessarily going with that. I'm saying well [05:08] What is your so if we're going with? I'm gonna go fifteen fifteen hundreds [05:13] But okay, I think that it's I think it's Mark Twain [05:18] Oh [05:20] Okay, so [05:22] Wait, oh, I think he came up with that house sick as a dog. So you don't think it's 1500s [05:29] I'm just saying if it ends up being the boat [05:31] I'm guessing 1500s and if it ends up being Mark Twain, I'm guessing when he was alive [05:36] What do you think Joey does this do you think this phrase goes back something a long time or is this a newer? I [05:43] mean, I feel like it's [05:45] What about Shakespeare? Hmm. Yeah [05:49] It's often Shakespeare [05:51] Does this go back to the the dog bite thing? What were the hair of the dog? Yeah, like the rabid dog. Yeah [06:00] Yeah [06:02] And what was the hair of the dog? That was like super old. That was like Rome, wasn't it? [06:07] Mmm, I believe so. Yeah, I don't remember. Yeah, I think they were these I know [06:11] I'm pretty sure that was went all the way back to Rome though. I'm pretty sure that [06:16] Sick as a dog thing and they would put the hair of a dog in the bite wound [06:23] Right, right [06:26] So, okay, let's go I'm gonna I'm gonna change my mind that I'm gonna say it's a Roman we're going back to the Romans [06:35] Yeah, I'm guessing [06:37] It seems me BC [06:41] Yeah, I mean it definitely seems like something that would come from a time where dogs were less [06:46] Integral to the family unit or whatever, you know what I mean? Like sharks are just running around [06:54] Rampant in the streets of like spoiled food and yacking up everywhere. Yeah [07:05] Okay, so you've got [07:07] London in the [07:10] 1600s [07:12] Yeah, okay, potentially Shakespeare is the first one [07:16] And then Joey, what's your guess before we look this up? I mean that's what I'm saying [07:20] I'm kind of I think I'm kind of in the same you kind of Shakespeare. Okay, I feel good about that [07:25] We I think we've got some three solid guesses here. We'll see what happens [07:30] We got a leg to stand on [07:34] I'm seeing from the idioms.com that dog was considered an undesirable animal in the 17th century [07:42] So much so that there are a lot of fridges phrases which refer to them negatively tired as a dog dog in the major [07:49] manger down to the dogs dogs breakfast and dirty dogs of [07:54] the murder of half of these [07:56] Sick as a dog refers to being so sick that one may feel like vomiting first literary use of the expression in 1705 [08:05] The face still reflexes in a in a negative sense [08:12] Synonyms invariant sick as a parrot [08:16] You know, that's gonna come from that's gonna come from the seafaring things, right? I don't know. Mm-hmm [08:21] There's an Aerosmith song called sick as a dog [08:24] It may have come from there. Oh [08:28] Apparently sick as a horse is was one and one is sick without the sensation of vomiting [08:33] That's a fairly fine line [08:36] The modern sick as a parrot recorded from the 1970s [08:40] At one time much overused by British sportsman as the opposite of over the moon [08:46] Refers to a state of deep mental depression rather than physical illness [08:51] This perhaps comes from instances of parrots contracting [08:56] Setet [08:57] Cosis, I don't know what that is and passing it to their human owners [09:02] I'm also seeing [09:04] some [09:06] some [09:08] Relation to throw it up. Yeah, so [09:10] The idea of being sick, which is connected to vomiting is apparently the reference here and that dogs [09:17] as you said [09:18] You know one of their ways of dealing with stuff is just a vomit stuff up [09:22] So that does seem like that we were right on that and also looks like [09:27] 1700s London, which I think is kind of what you were saying Jason the at the time dogs were not seen as human companions [09:34] often lived off the street and [09:38] A spoiled food and died naturally outdoors [09:44] Hmm [09:45] So I think I think Jason when I'm sure where you [09:48] I'm not sure you where you thought that one wasn't gonna be depressing, but [09:53] But we nailed it nailed it our list pretty good at this thing [09:59] Yeah, I'm seeing actually maybe here it goes back to 1592 even. Oh, really? [10:05] Herve's works whatever that is. Oh [10:08] Harvey's works. Mm-hmm. Yeah, I [10:14] Well, that one's always been on the tip of my tongue. I never guess it but I mean it's all there [10:20] That's another we talked the you've talked some of these phrases your dog tired [10:30] Right dirty dog [10:33] Yeah, I've seen a lot of the dogs were you know [10:37] dangerous disease, you know vectors basically [10:41] for a long long time [10:43] You slide dog. Mm-hmm. It's a good one. That's good. That's a good though [10:52] Generally, there you go. I love the Internet [11:00] So the one one person asked what is the origin of the phrase sick as a chip? [11:06] And the response was never having heard it before I can only assume the origin is you [11:14] By I'm now seeing the same stuff as you the 1592 it looks like [11:21] It's like it was the first time in print that we can find and they spelled sick. Si cke [11:29] Yeah, cuz they're British said it they just throw extra vowels in [11:34] Necessarily [11:38] Hello, got not [11:41] All righty. Well, we'll be back with you next week call us on use your drop in [11:48] What are you dropping on Thursday the the newest clip show which would be [11:54] 251 to 300. Oh [11:56] My goodness, I know [11:58] You actually if you are on iTunes right now, you actually can't go back to 300 [12:05] only on stitcher and [12:07] Spotify I think can you do that? So [12:10] So this is a way to catch up if you've not, you know, not heard those those episodes [12:17] Nice [12:18] So I am what is that? What does that cost? What's the pledge? That's that's free [12:23] If you want, I know that's how I know I know if you would like to hear it now [12:28] I like immediately like I said the Snyder cut version [12:32] The two and a half hour version [12:34] You can get on you just do just pay us five bucks a month and you'll be hanging out with us on on slack [12:41] Boy that sounds like a good deal. Yeah, I'm probably gonna do that right now [12:46] You can send some calls on some DMS said you can and you can send us [12:53] Send us your under google questions and the and I will accept stats of the week [13:00] He's not he's not necessarily gonna use them, but he'll accept them [13:03] Oh, no, for sure. Absolutely [13:05] In fact, one of my stats of the week is what percentage of other people's stats that I accept. It's low [13:12] Unless it's attached to Venmo then it gets higher right then then then that gets a more thorough read [13:22] Money talks, that's all I'm saying hi. Hi money on that note