Episode 112 · September 25, 2021
Messed Up, Man
A host's wife asks how cameras, and old film, capture color, and the hosts correctly reason out layered film.
“The trade-off is you get to see everybody's pictures.” (04:19)
Questions
How does color photography and color film work? (01:08)
Our guess
Film with three layers sensitive to different primary colors (red, green, blue) producing a color negative; digital pixels respond to one of three wavelengths. Mid-to-late 1930s.
Film with three layers sensitive to different primary colors (red, green, blue) producing a color negative; digital pixels respond to one of three wavelengths. Mid-to-late 1930s.
Reveal the answer
The answer
The three-color method was suggested by James Clerk Maxwell in 1855 and Thomas Sutton produced the first color photograph in 1861. Kodachrome (1935) was the first modern three-layer color film. Digital sensors have pixels responsive to red, green or blue.
The three-color method was suggested by James Clerk Maxwell in 1855 and Thomas Sutton produced the first color photograph in 1861. Kodachrome (1935) was the first modern three-layer color film. Digital sensors have pixels responsive to red, green or blue.
Verdict right
Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:00] We are going to move to our UndaGoogables section this week. [00:04] Coalson, again, I'd like to thank you for making the UndaGoogables spin-off podcast your brainchild. [00:15] It's lighting the Internet on fire. [00:18] That's right. If you haven't checked it out, go to our website, the UndaBeatables, and get the link to the UndaGoogables podcast, [00:29] which comes out every Saturday morning. [00:31] You can also find it on any of your podcast apps. [00:34] So, shout out. [00:36] It's usually 7 to 20 minutes long. [00:39] It depends on how much we talked that week about a certain topic, but much shorter than this show, [00:44] you can knock it out while you're taking a shower, doing the dishes, or... [00:49] Walking the dog. [00:50] Walking the dog. [00:51] So, check it out, and you know, you leave knowing a little bit more than you did when you turned it on. [00:57] Just a little bit. [00:59] Should we do an UndaGoogables? [01:08] That was the play of Super Excited. [01:10] You told us we had to, sir. [01:12] We said we signed up for it. [01:15] In the end, it's going to be better and more true than Google can give you. [01:21] So, the first one this week, Jason, I think you had a question for us that I'm hoping we can answer. [01:27] I do have a question. [01:29] Okay, so this is not a typical UndaGoogables, I guess. [01:34] Okay, so my wife and I were walking around the Arboretum last week with our goddaughter and her mom. [01:46] It's just beautiful fall foliage now. [01:50] The colors are amazing. [01:52] It's just ridiculous. [01:54] We're taking pictures and stuff like that. [01:57] And Jill asked what I thought was a really amazing question, which is how in the world do cameras capture all of this amazing color? [02:11] Like, we can sense it and we see it, but how do cameras do it? [02:16] And I kind of know the answer for the cameras that we use now. [02:22] So, digital cameras have a, I don't even know what it's called, but a detector, right, that has X number of megapixels. [02:36] And each of those has a photo diode in it, I think, that can detect different wavelengths of light. [02:44] So, you got your reds, your blues, and your greens, or something like that. [02:48] Depending on the intensity of each of those wavelengths, maybe you get a different color. [02:53] My bigger question, so we need to verify that, first of all, but the thing that I had was, you know, originally, the cameras were film, right? [03:04] Like, actual photographic film. [03:07] And I vaguely understand how black and white film works, but I have no idea how color film could possibly work. [03:16] You guys have any idea? [03:18] So, the old film cameras for the younger listeners. [03:24] Well, so, you probably are familiar, but you've got your, you know, your undeveloped film into the camera. [03:31] And you take your pictures, you know, and then you need to go, you know, like the, you know, once on the spool, or a roll, or whatever, you take that in when you're done to go get developed. [03:44] Developed at your local drugstore. [03:48] Drugstore, yeah. [03:49] Yeah. [03:50] Or one of those weird, like, little ones in the middle of a parking lot. [03:53] Do you guys ever use those? [03:54] Yeah, I'm sure. [03:55] Photo. [03:56] Yeah, that little photo parking lot. [03:57] Yeah, they were like just little photos. [03:59] It's like one guy in there. [04:00] And it's like the, you know, that, like, little, in broader bold, there's like that little snow cone stand where it's just like, basically, it's a building the size for one person. [04:12] It's basically that big. [04:14] But somehow there was like a photo developing lab, and it was usually in the middle of a parking lot somewhere. [04:19] In a mall, usually. [04:20] Yeah, near a mall. [04:21] I love that Coalson knew immediately, and Jason has no idea. [04:24] I love that. [04:25] I'm assuming that they just collected your film. [04:30] Oh, no, they did it right there. [04:31] To someplace else and developed it. [04:33] Nope. [04:34] They did it right there. [04:35] You come back in like an hour. [04:36] The people working in that place have to be clinically insane at this point. [04:41] The amount of fumes from the chemicals that they must have inhaled. [04:47] But the trade-off is you get to see everybody's pictures. [04:50] True, sure. [04:51] It's true. [04:52] So I think it's a special type, you know? [04:55] Right, right. [04:57] So on the mechanics of this, Coalson, do you have an insight? [05:01] Well, okay, so originally, right, so you would put your film in, you basically, it's about how much light you're letting in, right? [05:09] The light is coming in, and that's how you get your black and whites or your browns, right? [05:16] I mean, it's on some level, right? [05:19] Right, so original film, photographic film, yeah. [05:25] Areas that got more light actually turned darker, and that creates a negative, right? [05:35] And then you take the negative, and you shine light through that, and then you can print a picture, right? [05:44] So that makes sense. [05:45] That's how you get black and white. [05:46] That's a binary thing. [05:47] It's on level, right? [05:48] So each little, they're not really like pixels, but every part of the film would be a shade of gray. [05:57] It would be on some scale from white to black, right? [06:02] And then, at some point, color film was introduced around the time of The Wizard of Oz, I think. [06:08] Okay, and Kodak, right? [06:10] Didn't they include the color? [06:12] Right. [06:13] Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. [06:14] Good, nice. [06:15] Okay. [06:16] I mean, I feel like it's still, you know, a very similar process, but there's just the medium is using materials that are able to... [06:31] Absorb more color? [06:32] Right, so you can absorb whatever color. [06:35] Right, so the original film would be wavelength agnostic, right? [06:40] Okay, yeah. [06:41] Any form of light, I guess it could capture. [06:47] But in color film, you would have to have individual, I think, parts of the film or individual elements of the film that could capture different wavelengths of light. [06:57] That's the only way that you could get color, I would assume. [07:01] But I have no idea how that would work, right? [07:04] Would you make, like, an amalgam of molecules? [07:13] I don't even know. [07:14] It's so weird. [07:15] Yeah, I mean, what if you... [07:17] I mean, weren't the negatives pretty thick for a while? [07:22] Like, couldn't you have... [07:23] Or, like, think of, like, a Polaroid, right? [07:25] Like, maybe they're... [07:28] Each individual... [07:30] The negative has its own color, right? [07:32] And they're layered on top of each other? [07:34] So the film might actually be three different thin layers of... [07:38] Yes, different RGB. [07:40] Each sensitive to different wavelengths of light. [07:44] Yes. [07:45] Ooh, that's really clever. [07:46] That's what I'm going with. [07:47] I like that idea. [07:48] Yeah, yeah. [07:49] With the way the colors work, right, you could just use primary colors, right? [07:53] I would think so. [07:54] I mean, because they blend, right? [07:56] I mean, that's the thing. [07:57] That's... [07:58] They make all the other colors. [07:59] That's why they're primary. [08:00] Right. [08:01] Right. [08:02] I like that idea. [08:03] I like that it was three individual sheets that they just smacked on top of one another. [08:08] Yeah, and then they'd collect whatever color they're seeing. [08:11] Yeah. [08:12] Right. [08:13] And then as you... [08:14] So you still create a negative, right? [08:16] So your negative would be freaky looking, but then you shine light through it and you [08:22] would get the original colors, right? [08:25] Yeah. [08:26] In fact, the colors would be the opposites of what they're going to end up being. [08:32] Yes, exactly. [08:33] Yeah. [08:34] Yeah. [08:35] In color, too. [08:36] The negative, yeah. [08:37] Right. [08:38] So it's negative... [08:39] So it's going to be negative on the white to black scale, like the light to dark scale, [08:46] and then it's going to be negative for the RGB. [08:49] I would think so, yeah. [08:51] Yeah. [08:52] Yeah. [08:53] It's messed up, man. [08:56] Do we have guesses as to when this came about? [08:59] Like, certainly it must have been... [09:01] I mean, Wizard of Oz was like one of the first color... [09:05] Yeah. [09:06] ...motion pictures, right? [09:07] Right. [09:08] But there must have been people experimenting with still photographs. [09:12] But I assume once you like had... [09:15] Once you got the film, you got the film. [09:17] ...still photographs, like people were immediately making movies out of it. [09:19] Right. [09:20] So this is mid-30s, late 30s. [09:22] I'm thinking, yeah, I'm thinking mid-late 30s. [09:24] Okay. [09:25] Yeah, I don't really see another... [09:28] Because, I mean, I don't really... [09:29] I mean, you think about pictures in the 20s and stuff. [09:32] I don't remember seeing any color pictures, you know? [09:35] Right. [09:36] I don't really see a lot of... [09:37] God, do you see a lot of color pictures from World War II? [09:41] Weirdly, no. [09:45] Yeah. [09:46] They were all... [09:47] I think it was just hyper-expensive, right? [09:49] Yeah. [09:50] Yeah. [09:51] I'm sure right away. [09:52] Sure. [09:53] But by the 50s, everything's in color. [09:55] Right. [09:57] Because everyone had more money. [09:59] That's right. [10:00] Make America Great Again. [10:03] All right, yeah. [10:04] Well, what I'm seeing is that Coalson is absolutely correct. [10:08] Yes! [10:10] That basically made film that had three different layers, basically. [10:16] Yeah, that's wild. [10:21] And it was the era, right? [10:23] Oh, wow. [10:24] The first color photograph was produced by Thomas Sutton in 1861. [10:31] Oh, my goodness. [10:33] The first movie made in color was Cupid Angling in 1918. [10:38] Wow. [10:39] But so Wizard of Oz and Gone with the Wind were made using Technicolor. [10:47] Okay, yeah. [10:48] The foundation for all practical color processes, [10:52] the three-color method, was first suggested in an 1855 paper [10:56] by Scottish physicist James Clerk Maxwell. [11:01] And Thomas Sutton produced the first color photograph in 1861. [11:07] Wow. [11:09] So Kodachrome comes along in 1935. [11:14] Eastman Kodak introduced the first modern, integral, tri-pack color film [11:19] and called it Kodachrome. [11:22] Cool. [11:24] Yeah, and digital photography color-wise seems to work the way that I describe, [11:31] is that you have each pixel is responsive to one of the three wavelengths of light [11:42] and then you just have them in a similar pattern, basically. [11:49] So you crushed that then? [11:51] Yeah. [11:52] Well, that I knew from, like, microscopy and stuff like that, [11:56] so that was kind of a new, basically, the answer to that. [12:01] We did a good job. [12:04] Thank you. [12:05] Yeah, you nailed it. [12:06] Good work. [12:07] The more you know. [12:10] Oh, I think we stole that one from somebody else. [12:12] Nah, I think it ran out. [12:14] I had trademarks expired by now, right? [12:17] They're not Disney.