Episode 16 · November 23, 2019
We're Huge in Liberia
After a listener correction about the middle finger, the hosts untangle panthers, jaguars, cougars and mountain lions, then ask where Thanksgiving comes from and who else celebrates it.
“We're huge in Liberia, I hear.” (20:17)
Questions
What is the difference between a panther, a jaguar, a cougar and a mountain lion? (04:14)
Our guess
Black cats vs. brown cats; the mountain lion is a puma, and the panther is a separate black cat.
Black cats vs. brown cats; the mountain lion is a puma, and the panther is a separate black cat.
Reveal the answer
The answer
Cougar, puma, mountain lion and catamount are all the same animal. "Panther" is a loose term for leopards, jaguars or any black (melanistic) big cat. The four big cats in the genus Panthera are lions, tigers, leopards and jaguars; cheetahs are a separate genus. The lynx group includes four species, including the bobcat.
Cougar, puma, mountain lion and catamount are all the same animal. "Panther" is a loose term for leopards, jaguars or any black (melanistic) big cat. The four big cats in the genus Panthera are lions, tigers, leopards and jaguars; cheetahs are a separate genus. The lynx group includes four species, including the bobcat.
Verdict partly
Where did Thanksgiving come from, and do other countries celebrate it? (13:06)
Our guess
A harvest festival the US originated and exported; Canada borrowed it from the US.
A harvest festival the US originated and exported; Canada borrowed it from the US.
Reveal the answer
The answer
Celebrated in Canada (second Monday of October), the US, some Caribbean islands and Liberia, with similar festivals in Germany and Japan. Some historians point to a 1578 voyage from England as the first celebration in North America. Norfolk Island's version came via US whalers, and Liberia's via freed slaves.
Celebrated in Canada (second Monday of October), the US, some Caribbean islands and Liberia, with similar festivals in Germany and Japan. Some historians point to a 1578 voyage from England as the first celebration in North America. Norfolk Island's version came via US whalers, and Liberia's via freed slaves.
Verdict partly
Transcript (auto-generated)
[00:01] We've got another segment, we do this one often, but actually before we get into that, [00:06] I want to hear, Jason, you've got some beef with, or some commentary, some follow-ups [00:12] on the Middle Finger episode. [00:14] Oh, are we moving on to Google? [00:16] It's Undo-Google-able time. [00:17] I want to clear the air before we move to new stuff. [00:21] Okay, so last week, Undo-Google-able was, what's the origin of the Middle Finger? [00:26] Yeah. [00:28] I was listening to it, so I was working in a lab and I was like, [00:31] oh, weird, I know this one, great. [00:34] And then the answer that you gave was completely different than what I thought to be the answer. [00:39] So I was always told, or my dad, I guess, always told me that the Middle Finger originated [00:46] from the Franco-English war. [00:50] So France and England were like basically always at war in the Middle Ages, right? [00:54] I think it originated with the French, because when French bowmen would be taken captive [01:04] by the English, they would cut off their Middle Finger so that they couldn't pull a bow string [01:10] and release, right? [01:12] And so the French would wag their Middle Finger to basically say, look, I still have [01:16] it and I'm going to shoot you. [01:19] That's how I learned that the thing came about. [01:23] The sides could be switched. [01:24] It could be the English did that to the French. [01:27] So we did read that story, and it sounds like that was probably true, but that there was [01:35] already a history to the Middle Finger. [01:37] Before that. [01:38] Right, before that. [01:39] So it was already, what was it, Greek? [01:41] Did we decide it was Greek? [01:43] Pliny the Elder. [01:46] Yeah, well, you guys said that that's why I was like, okay with it, because, okay, [01:53] the Greeks, I guess, had it and it was a phallic thing and all of that makes total sense. [01:59] So when we in our research, we found that I think I edited it out because we basically [02:03] said, well, it may be true, but it's yeah, it's entirely possible to that they just they [02:08] just made up the same thing again, because it was the Dark Ages. [02:11] I mean, we did kind of so it got lost to history. [02:15] Sure. [02:16] And what do we call that? [02:18] That's a parallel evolution. [02:20] Yes, exactly. [02:22] The Middle Finger is an inevitable result of. [02:24] Yeah, exactly. [02:25] Yeah. [02:26] Well, today we can spread fake news at the speed of light, which is fantastic. [02:31] That's right. [02:32] That's right. [02:33] But I think we've just we've honed in on something here, which is two things can be [02:36] true at the same time. [02:39] But I will edit out the one you don't agree with. [02:46] That's right. [02:47] I will get rid of some of the truth. [02:49] So you're like all of humanity. [02:51] Right. [02:52] Exactly. [02:53] We do under Google rules. [03:00] That was the play of super excited. [03:01] I told us we had to. [03:02] So we said we signed up for it. [03:03] In the end, it's going to be better and more true than Google can give you. [03:14] Google is this week. [03:18] Well, okay. [03:19] So I was, I don't know, I'm a Marvel geek. [03:24] Right. [03:25] I'm super, super dupe excited about the new Marvel movie coming out next February called [03:32] Black Panther. [03:33] There's another one. [03:34] There's always. [03:35] Yeah. [03:36] They come out like every three months. [03:37] Yeah. [03:38] How was the Justice League? [03:39] Oh, yeah. [03:40] That was the Justice League. [03:42] That's not Marvel. [03:43] That's DC. [03:44] Oh, okay. [03:45] Yeah. [03:46] No. [03:47] Keep up. [03:48] It just goes to show how much I'm going to do awesome at this under Google so you [03:49] can tell. [03:50] Yeah. [03:51] Exactly. [03:52] Well, no, I think you might because. [03:53] Just wait in line for Thor. [03:57] That's a Marvel. [03:58] Yeah. [03:59] But then three months from now, we're going to have, we're going to have a Black Panther [04:02] and then three months after that, we'll have Avengers 3. [04:05] How was Thor? [04:06] Was it good? [04:07] It was very, it was very enjoyable. [04:08] I enjoyed it. [04:09] Okay. [04:10] Yeah. [04:11] So we're losing, we're losing the thread here. [04:12] Black Panther. [04:13] Yeah. [04:14] And I'm always, and I, and I was thinking to myself, I always get this screwed up and [04:18] I can't ever remember it. [04:21] The Panther and the Jaguar and the Cougar and the Mountain Lion, and I think they're [04:28] all one thing. [04:29] Right? [04:30] Isn't that the thing? [04:31] They're all one animal? [04:32] No. [04:33] Or are they not? [04:34] No. [04:35] No, no, no. [04:36] I don't think they're all one animal. [04:37] Okay. [04:38] Well then, what's the, what's the difference? [04:39] Well, the Cougar, you're going to find it, Eiken Jones. [04:44] Fair enough. [04:50] That is their natural habitat. [04:55] With a shot of fireball. [04:57] Exactly. [04:58] They are carnivores. [05:02] So okay. [05:03] So the big distinction is you got, you got black cats and you got brown cats. [05:09] Okay. [05:10] Right? [05:11] Okay. [05:12] So, so Black Panthers and Jaguars are black. [05:14] Okay. [05:15] Your Mountain Lion, your Cougar, and what was the other one you said? [05:20] Jaguar. [05:21] Uh, jaguar. [05:22] No, jaguar's all right. [05:23] Oh wait. [05:24] Oh no, no, no, no. [05:25] Is there a Puma? [05:26] Is there a Puma involved? [05:27] There's a Puma. [05:28] Oh, a Puma. [05:29] Yeah. [05:30] The Puma. [05:31] Puma. [05:32] Puma. [05:33] So those, so the Pumas and the Mountain Lions and the Cougars, I get confused as well. [05:40] That's what I'm saying. [05:41] They're all brown cats, but then the Black Panther and the Jaguar are... [05:45] So those, so I shouldn't be confusing those. [05:47] You're saying so, Panther... [05:49] Well, so, so, okay. [05:50] So a Black Panther is black, actually, and I'm glad you said this, a jaguar, jaguar... [05:56] Isn't it spotted? [05:57] Is spotted. [05:58] Right. [05:59] Like a leopard. [06:00] Okay. [06:01] Right. [06:02] But the leopard and the jaguar are different animals. [06:04] Okay. [06:05] Different species. [06:06] Black Panther. [06:08] There's another name for a Black Panther, but I can't remember what it is right now. [06:12] It's not a Puma. [06:14] It's not a Puma. [06:15] It's not a Puma. [06:16] Puma. [06:17] Puma. [06:18] A Puma, I think, is a Mountain Lion. [06:21] A Cougar is different, I think. [06:23] Okay. [06:24] That's my guess, but I don't know. [06:27] So the Heartbird, you got a guess on this? [06:30] Because that's basically how I think about things, what Jason just said. [06:33] Like, I think it's that thing, but I guess I didn't know that the Panther was different [06:37] than the Puma. [06:38] Yes. [06:39] Okay. [06:40] That's good. [06:42] And everybody gets my Simpsons, right? [06:44] Right. [06:45] The what? [06:46] The Principal Skinner always, he liked the mighty Puma, even like Cheyenne, Cheyenne the [06:54] Statue. [06:55] Out in front of the school, at the school. [06:58] So with big cats, so there's big cats and then there's smaller cats, right? [07:03] Sure. [07:04] One of the distinctions is always climbing, isn't it? [07:10] So do big cats run and small cats climb? [07:14] Because I'm thinking like lions, I guess lions climb. [07:17] They can climb, but they don't live in trees. [07:19] They don't love climbing. [07:21] Right. [07:22] But like a jaguar loves the trees. [07:25] A Black Panther, I think, loves the trees. [07:28] But leopards run. [07:30] Mountain lions, trees. [07:33] Yeah. [07:34] I'm thinking mountains. [07:36] That's just my theory. [07:37] No. [07:39] I know that they like trees because it was like a weird incident. [07:45] So in the Santa Cruz Mountains, where I used to go jogging, basically, there were mountain [07:52] lions everywhere. [07:53] It sounds dangerous. [07:54] It was horrifying. [07:55] It was, yeah. [07:59] Never saw one. [08:00] But... [08:01] You constantly were in fear, though. [08:02] Totally. [08:03] There was like a big incident. [08:05] My advisor at the time was like on the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee. [08:11] And there were people that studied the mountain lions, and then there was like some incident [08:14] with mountain lions that he had to like deal with. [08:17] But they definitely take their prey and drag it up into a tree. [08:23] Okay. [08:25] That's hardcore. [08:26] Yeah. [08:27] Joey, do you know anything about big cats versus small cats? [08:31] Do you know their phylum and their species? [08:34] Oh, their genus? [08:36] Their genus. [08:37] So where are we at on the thing? [08:39] We got... [08:40] Could you be less descriptive? [08:42] Yeah. [08:43] Feline. [08:44] Okay. [08:45] For feline, sure. [08:46] We're all feline. [08:47] And then there's big cats and small cats. [08:49] I don't think those are... [08:51] That doesn't seem like a scientific name. [08:55] That's why you're the one that has the undergiggables. [08:57] Exactly. [08:58] That's why you come to us. [09:00] I think they're all different except for, I want to say the mountain lion, and there's [09:06] a lynx. [09:07] Is it a lynx? [09:08] Okay. [09:09] That's different. [09:10] What about bobcat? [09:11] They're much smaller. [09:12] Yeah. [09:13] Yeah. [09:14] Yeah. [09:15] I was thinking about renting a bobcat to dig up the backyard. [09:17] You think so? [09:18] No. [09:19] I mean, definitely... [09:22] I think the mountain lion was the only one I could think of that I thought had another [09:25] name. [09:27] But I feel like they're all different besides that. [09:30] Okay. [09:31] So they're just different animals. [09:32] Yeah. [09:33] I just... [09:34] I feel like somebody told me that they're all the same at some point, and I believe [09:36] in them. [09:37] So there are four species of big cats in the Felidae family, and panthera genus. [09:42] Lions, tigers, leopards, and jaguars. [09:47] So a leopard or a panther is not actually a cat, it's a genus of cat? [09:55] Panthera is the name of the genus. [09:57] And then there are subspecies. [10:00] So a lion is technically a panther? [10:04] Bear with me here, buddy. [10:05] Leopards and jaguars... [10:06] Okay, I got excited. [10:08] Leopards and jaguars are two distinct species, but they are similar. [10:11] The leopard has relatively short legs and a long body with a large skull. [10:16] Similar in appearance to a jaguar, but smaller and more slightly built. [10:22] Leopards are found in Asia and Africa, while jaguars are found in South America. [10:26] Cheetahs are also in the Felidae family, and the only member of the acynonyx genus? [10:37] Hmm. [10:38] Interesting. [10:39] Is it because they have a different skeletal structure for running? [10:45] Apparently. [10:46] Cougars are also members of the Felidae family, and they are also a distinct species. [10:50] They belong to the Puma genus. [10:51] Oh, it's the genus, the Puma. [10:54] Alternative terms for cougar include Puma, mountain lion, mountain cat, catamount. [11:01] What about bobcats? [11:04] I don't know. [11:09] Panther is a versatile word that can refer to different leopards, jaguars, or mountain [11:14] lions. [11:15] It can refer to a melanistic or black cat. [11:19] But see, this is what I'm saying. [11:20] This is why it's confusing. [11:22] You just told me that the mountain lion is a Puma, but a panther can refer to a Puma? [11:29] Yeah. [11:30] Dude, humans are not smart. [11:32] They just name shit whatever they... [11:35] They see it, and they're like, yeah, that's a panther. [11:39] Okay. [11:40] So that's why we call everything the same thing. [11:43] Because we're lazy. [11:44] We're like, that's a big cat. [11:45] It must be a panther. [11:47] Yeah, exactly. [11:48] Well, and then you could understand culturally, if you're trying to be like, we have a mountain [11:55] lion up there, and you point to it, and somebody else is like, oh, a panther. [12:00] Oh, you call a panther? [12:01] Okay, cool. [12:03] And getting to your bobcat, John, the lynx refers to four species, the Eurasian lynx, [12:11] the Canada lynx, the Iberian lynx, and the bobcat. [12:15] The lynx are much smaller than the mountain lions and leopards, and have smaller tails. [12:21] What about the Minnesota lynx? [12:25] I know some former Minnesota lynx are now cougars, but I don't know where the crossover [12:34] happens. [12:38] I don't know, but you know it when you see it. [12:42] All right, I think I'm going to clear that one up. [12:50] They're all the same, but different. [12:53] The big cats. [12:54] So you got another under Googles for us? [12:56] I don't know, that one went pretty well. [12:58] I think we're good. [12:59] Okay. [13:00] I mean, unless you want to talk about Thanksgiving. [13:06] It seems like the day it is. [13:07] Yeah, it is Thanksgiving, right? [13:08] And so I was wondering if, what'd you know about Thanksgiving? [13:14] Like what is Thanksgiving? [13:15] I mean, you know, I think we know that we did a play together as kids in elementary school [13:24] in which I was an Indian with a little racist feather in my head. [13:30] Was the feather racist? [13:32] What was the feather doing? [13:33] No, I just had like the single, I went and I went and found a duck feather and I painted [13:41] it red and I made a little headband and I was the Indian. [13:48] And we taught the pilgrims to popcorn, I think, in that. [13:52] And so that was the first Thanksgiving. [13:56] Isn't that how it goes? [14:00] And that's where they invented pumpkin pie. [14:03] We learned a couple of things. [14:05] We learned everything from under Googles. [14:10] Does anybody have anything? [14:11] I mean, basically the pilgrims were sick and starving and the Indians came and were very [14:18] nice to them and brought them bountiful food and they had a big meal and very thankful. [14:24] Is that pretty much it? [14:25] So here's my real question. [14:27] So we're not the only ones with a Thanksgiving. [14:29] Right. [14:30] Agreed. [14:31] Did we originate Thanksgiving or did we steal Thanksgiving? [14:37] I mean, I know we stole Thanksgiving. [14:38] Canada stole it from us, for sure. [14:41] You think? [14:42] Really? [14:43] Is there other thanksgivings besides the US and Canada? [14:46] I'll bet you, Australia has a thanksgiving. [14:48] Well here's the thing, I don't know that the rest of the world has anything to be thankful [14:52] for. [14:53] North America is pretty great. [14:58] Almost got a spit take from Coalson. [15:02] Does Mexico have a thanksgiving? [15:04] Yeah. [15:06] We'll never know. [15:09] The top two thirds of North America. [15:15] Just dismissing Central America. [15:19] There's no talk about putting a wall between the US and Canada. [15:21] Let me just put it that way. [15:22] Sure. [15:23] You haven't been hanging out in circles. [15:24] I always thought that it was a harvest festival that we just piggybacked on. [15:31] Yeah. [15:32] Or not we. [15:33] I mean, I guess we, I'm a European descendant, but I wasn't part of, I wasn't descendants [15:37] of the original Puritans. [15:39] You weren't on the committee that decided to speak. [15:41] No, not at all. [15:43] But yeah, I always imagined it was the American Indians were like, yeah, this is the time [15:51] of year where we're like, we have a bunch of stuff, we just harvested everything, so [15:55] we eat it. [15:56] What's happening? [15:57] You guys are here, you're clearly not going to make it through the winter. [16:02] Eat some of our stuff, like it's cool. [16:04] It's going to rot if we don't eat it. [16:06] You don't look good. [16:12] I actually could trace my family back to the Mayflower. [16:15] Really? [16:16] Yes, I can. [16:17] Very exciting. [16:18] Wow. [16:19] They came over on the boat? [16:20] They came over on the boat. [16:22] Wow. [16:23] They did not, as far as I can tell, send me or leave me a letter about the first Thanksgiving. [16:29] Okay. [16:30] I don't know. [16:31] I don't have inside information on this. [16:33] Were they recipients of the first Thanksgiving? [16:35] I don't know. [16:36] I'm zeroed, yeah. [16:37] I just know that we've got the boat log. [16:42] The manifest. [16:43] That's why we keep the smart people around where it's like manifest. [16:50] So the story we got as a child was a harmonious event between the Native Americans. [16:57] Actually no, the story I got at school was of the Indians, and they shared their bounty [17:04] with the pilgrims, and it was harmonious, and it strengthened the Europeans so they were [17:13] able to overtake their host very shortly afterwards. [17:20] The lesson is never be kind to strangers. [17:22] Yes, exactly. [17:23] They will take your house. [17:25] Right. [17:26] Thanksgiving Day is a national holiday celebration in Canada, the United States, and some of the [17:31] Caribbean islands and Liberia. [17:34] Oh, sure. [17:36] Harvesting, blah, blah, blah, similarly named festivals occur in Germany and Japan. [17:42] Let's see. [17:44] It's the second Monday of October in Canada. [17:47] That's ridiculous. [17:48] Because it seems too early for you. [17:50] Yes. [17:51] It's like Columbus Day days. [17:52] Oh my God. [17:57] According to some historians, the first celebration of Thanksgiving in North America occurred during [18:00] the 1578 voyage of Martin Frobichier from England in search of the Northwest Passage. [18:07] Failed. [18:09] Sad. [18:12] So, Australia, mostly not celebrated, but in the external territory of Norfolk Island, [18:26] it's celebrated the last Wednesday of November, similar to the pre-World War II American observance [18:31] on the last Thursday of the month. [18:34] The Norfolk Island observance is the day before or six days after the U.S. observance. [18:40] It was brought to them by the U.S. whaling ships. [18:44] Norfolk and Way, man. [18:47] And Liberia was actually brought there by the freed slaves. [18:52] Freed slaves, right? [18:54] Man has labored Thanksgiving Day on November 23rd. [18:59] The law establishing the holiday, which was adopted during the American occupation after [19:03] World War II, cites it as an occasion to... [19:05] So we brought everybody Thanksgiving pretty much. [19:08] Pretty much. [19:09] Whether they wanted it or not. [19:13] You guys don't do Thanksgiving? [19:17] You do now. [19:18] We'll fix that. [19:19] All right. [19:20] Well, there you go. [19:24] So basically, our ideas were correct. [19:28] We knew about Thanksgiving. [19:29] Yeah. [19:30] I still don't know why in the world somebody chose the fourth Thursday of November. [19:34] That's always weird to me, but... [19:37] I assume that it was... [19:40] They wanted to put something smack dab in the middle between All Saints Day and Christmas, [19:47] which they'd already had in there. [19:50] Well, but it's a floating holiday, though, right? [19:52] It's never on the same day. [19:53] Well, no. [19:54] What I'm saying is they sort of, like, you know, gives you at the end of the month of [19:58] November. [19:59] Well, you could just make it at the end of the month. [20:02] I see. [20:03] I see. [20:04] But they wanted a four-day weekend. [20:06] Right. [20:07] The Pilgrims wanted a four-day weekend. [20:09] Well, that shit did not work. [20:11] I'm working on Friday, so this is garbage. [20:14] Wow. [20:15] That is garbage. [20:16] Yeah. [20:17] Thanks, Pilgrims. [20:18] I feel like we learned something. [20:20] I feel like we always learned something on this show. [20:23] I usually forget it. [20:25] You can just re-listen to it. [20:27] That's part of why we record this stuff. [20:29] It's now part of an indelible part of human history. [20:32] Well, you're welcome, America. [20:37] And Canada and Liberia. [20:38] And future alien over the world. [20:40] The whole world. [20:41] Really. [20:42] That's right. [20:43] We're huge in Liberia, I hear. [20:44] Well, that sounds like it's time to get it going. [20:50] I'm happy. [20:51] We'll see you next week. [20:52] Bye, everyone. [20:53] Bye. [20:54] Bye. [20:55] Bye. [20:56] Bye.